3 ms·
That’s the difficulty, isn’t it? If I say, let’s go and burn that police station down now! Let’s be there at 9:15. It’s pretty clear. If you say, I wish tha
by mc32 6y ago
That’s the difficulty, isn’t it? If I say, let’s go and burn that police station down now! Let’s be there at 9:15. It’s pretty clear. If you say, I wish that police station would get burned down. I don’t know. It’s not a nice thought, but you’re not actively working to have it burned down. On the other hand the wish does not have pure intentions.
This is why I think it’s impossible to “monitor” and purge or ban violent tweets or what have you.
One, what is the intention of the speaker, two who is responsible for the audiences reaction? Do you take the most extremely negative interpretation? It cannot work.
And that’s not even taking slang into account where violent words don’t mean violence and normal words can take on other meanings.
- wolco5 6y agoContext matters. "Let’s go and burn that police station down now" If anyone I knew said that I would treat it as a dry joke.
- mc32 6y agoI guess this is the problem in identifying “shooters”. Lots of people kid around about horrible things but don’t mean it. One day you find out that one of the kids was not joking and actually meant it. Even people who are friends of the perp have problems sussing this out and can only do it in retrospect.
- wolco5 6y agoWhat about songs like kill the police by ice tea. A direct call to action exists / police have been killed but he still is free to act in police dramas?
- mc32 6y agoIf we took “progressive” politics out of it but retained that we need to remove “violence” from discourse, yes they would have to be banned from Twitter. Progressive politics will say we have to consider the background of the singer and the audience as mitigating circumstance so they might let it slide. Objectively it would have to be banned if we use Twitter’s new rubric.
- stretchcat 6y ago(fyi the song is Cop Killer by Ice-T.)