3 ms·
IANAL, but I already see one massive issue with the lawsuit: Count 1 is a claim against the Sherman Antitrust Act. By their own citation (see claim 31), they n
by jcranmer 6y ago
IANAL, but I already see one massive issue with the lawsuit:
Count 1 is a claim against the Sherman Antitrust Act. By their own citation (see claim 31), they need to allege specific facts that would conclude (1) the existence of a conspiracy, (2) intention on the part of the co-conspirators to restrain trade, and (3) actual injury to competition.
There's no facts that allege (2). Actually, I suspect they also need to list Twitter as a defendant to properly claim (1) as well, since it's Twitter that has the alleged monopoly, and the one for whom the alleged conspiracy to restrain trade exists.
Their facts probably don't even amount to alleging (1). They basically say "AWS also provides services to Twitter" (okay that's not a conspiracy by itself) and "Twitter also had an issue with the #HangMikePence hashtag" (omitting the fact that Twitter did kill the hashtag)--which still doesn't allege a conspiracy.
I'm sure some actual lawyers will shortly comment on whatever other gross procedural filings this lawsuit has (https://twitter.com/questauthority/status/1348700506470952960 https://twitter.com/questauthority/status/134870050647095296... suggests there's quite a few).
- moate 6y agoThis whole filing reads like "QQ, TWITTER HURT ME, MUH USERS!!!!1!!1!" It is...not a good complaint. They should be focusing a LOT more on breach of contract. Unless, you know, AWS didn't actually do that per the terms. For anyone reading this, Tort law (which is what this is) boils down to this basic idea: Was there a legal agreement between two parties, and did the violation of that agreement cause damage to one of the parties. From what I've seen (IDK the specifics of Parler's contract with AWS, and I'm just guessing based on general understanding of how good a ToS from a mega-corp like Amazon is) the answer is yes there are damages, but they seem unlikely to stem from the violation of the terms of a contract.