10 ms·
It would be interesting if power companies run by various oligarchs started disconnecting power to AWS servers: “go generate your own power” Or maybe food deli
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
It would be interesting if power companies run by various oligarchs started disconnecting power to AWS servers: “go generate your own power”
Or maybe food delivery truck drivers is a better analogy since that isn’t a utility...
- commandlinefan 6y agoThis feels analogous to paper companies banding together and refusing to provide paper to a newspaper whose opinion column they disagree with.
- ABeeSea 6y agoMore like “whose letters to the editor page routinely featured calls for violent revolution.”
- moate 6y agoIt's more analogous to a single server host refusing to host a site, while the material components (actual physical servers) are still readily available if likely outside the financial range for a site at their size (tbh though, I have no idea what sort of server needs this site would actual have). Parler could still go out and build their own servers. The fact that this is a project driven by "free speech enthusiasts" and not actual engineers means they're probably going to have a real hard time getting the engineering stuff back in line. Apple/Google refusing to sell your app is just that: a store refusing to sell a product.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Parler could still go out and build their own servers. Yes, and as someone on Twitter pointed out, as a customer also denied service, Rosa Parks could have gone out and started her own bus line (likely outside her financial range though). The argument to "do it yourself" is silly. Europe sees it. The ACLU sees it. Why can't you? For the record: I think these platforms should be responsible for what they host.
- ABeeSea 6y agoThe 1st amendment gives all of the companies the freedom of association. They can deny doing business for any reason except for protected class. Are you trying to force companies to do business with entities that they do not wish to do business with?
- itsoktocry 6y ago>The 1st amendment gives all of the companies the freedom of association. I was under the impression the First Amendment was about the government imposing laws that restricted religion or expression of the citizenry. Can you point to the part that says anything about how businesses (built off of public infrastructure) are to be run?
- ABeeSea 6y agoCitizens United gave corporations constitutional rights (specifically the first amendment). Which means they have freedom of association. The only way to stop AWS from dropping Parler would be if the government forced AWS to host Parler which would be a violation of AWS’s freedom of association. The only caveat to this is protected class. There are some movements to make political affiliation a protected class, but I personally think that’s the wrong path to go down since it’s not an “inherent” attribute of a person like race, age, sexual orientation, etc.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>The only way to stop AWS from dropping Parler would be if the government forced AWS to host Parler which would be a violation of AWS’s freedom of association. I don't have an answer to this, because I agree with you. Maybe if you "arbitrarily" decide to stop doing business with someone, after you've already started, without a breech of any terms of service, you should be financially liable in some way? Contract law should cover that (I'm def no expert). Does it? Like, if Amazon decides to cut me off from hosting, and I haven't broken any laws, rules or ToS, they should have to pay for me to be up-and-running elsewhere. In other words, AWS can't boot someone without establishing wrong-doing. It feels like this wouldn't require much more than tighter contracts, handing more power to the customer. I'm in favour of that.
- maxerickson 6y agoYes, power companies have different regulations than AWS. Which means the analogy is boring. There's probably a good discussion to be had about how to regulate services like AWS though. The dynamics are probably different, with power companies not quite having the same potential for wanting to disassociate from noxious customers.
- blamestross 6y agoI think the interesting takeaway is that so many people consider social media and internet hosting to essentially be public services. The hidden premise/misunderstanding in the "social media censorship" concept is that they are so critical to participation in society that they should be a right like power or water. There are arguments for moving things like internet access into being a public utility. It is interesting that they have skipped directly to wanting to socialize social media.
- chillacy 6y agoInternet hosting doesn’t have as strong a geologic component though. Power and water are utilities because they are “natural monopolies”. UPS and FedEx are not utilities since they have less fixed infrastructure.
- blamestross 6y agogeologic component isn't relevant. In our current legal system, the only way to ensure equal access to a service is via regulation as a public utility.
- chillacy 6y ago> the only way to ensure equal access to a service is via regulation as a public utility Right, but afaik the reason water/power/etc are made public utilities is because they are natural monopolies: > Public utilities, the companies that have traditionally provided water and electrical service across much of the United States, are leading examples of natural monopoly. It would make little sense to argue that a local water company should be broken up into several competing companies, each with its own separate set of pipes and water supplies. Installing four or five identical sets of pipes under a city, one for each water company, so that each household could choose its own water provider, would be terribly costly. The same argument applies to the idea of having many competing companies for delivering electricity to homes, each with its own set of wires. Before the advent of wireless phones, the argument also applied to the idea of many different phone companies, each with its own set of phone wires running through the neighborhood. https://opentextbc.ca/principlesofeconomics/chapter/11-3-regulating-natural-monopolies/ https://opentextbc.ca/principlesofeconomics/chapter/11-3-reg... This same is harder to say for AWS. The physical wires? Yes, but your hosting provider? It's not as clear cut.
- wobblyasp 6y agoI mean; if there was a company that would capable of doing it... but yah this feels like a false equivalency. Private companies are free to refuse service to anyone; unless there is specific legislation to the contrary.
- InitialLastName 6y agoIt's more like if I rent you an apartment in my building and then find out you're using it to manufacture bombs. If you end up blowing up a bridge and it can be determined that I knew about your actions, I can potentially be held liable (in the PR sense, if not the legal sense) for abetting terrorism.
- optimalsolver 6y agoI assure you there will be countless power supply/food delivery companies extremely eager for the chance to service Amazon/AWS.