5 ms·
It would also decimate their trustworthiness; how would anyone trust a secondhand iphone if it can be compromised like that? Could it be done in pure software,
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
It would also decimate their trustworthiness; how would anyone trust a secondhand iphone if it can be compromised like that? Could it be done in pure software, opening it up for malware?
I mean I get why one would want unrestricted access to hardware, custom software, etc, but at the same time I understand the resistance to allowing it. In Apple's case, security is really high up in their priorities.
- spijdar 6y agoHence why GP said "after a fuse is blown". The implication is some sort of irreversible, hardware-based mechanism that would disable the security measures while making it abundantly clear that it had done so, so someone would know if the device had been tampered with.
- colejohnson66 6y agoTo be fair, what’s stopping someone from blowing the fuse and putting on some “fake” (patched) software claiming it’s not blown? (Asking hypothetically here; I doubt anyone would, but it would be a “valid” concern for Apple)
- spijdar 6y agoMost hardware vendors that implement this sort of functionality add prominent warnings to the lowest level boot screens notifying the user the device is "unlocked" or in "dev mode" or some such. The idea is that the absolute lowest levels of firmware remain signed and controlled, while giving the option of loading unsigned code on top. So in theory, you get the best of both worlds. I don't think there's anything really stopping Apple from doing this, but as many others have said, it's not really their jam ;)
- colejohnson66 6y agoI can easily see someone claiming that Apple keeping anything signed and controlled isn’t going far enough. Is there any data on how many people believe it should be “all the way”?
- kevincox 6y agoThe Pixel devices do this well. If it doesn't trust the OS the bootloader shows a big scary warning. If the OS is signed by Google then it boots up without the warning. So when you got your second hand device you just need to check the bootloader while booting. If it warns then you need to flash a stock iamge.
- m45t3r 6y agoNot just Pixel, but most Android devices (both my previous Xiaomi and my current Samsung devices does this). I think it is probably part of Android CTS. It just shows that this is possible, but we are talking about Apple here.