3 ms·
The infinite loop being UB was added because it prevents some important code motion optimizations and makes it hard to reason about the memory model. You can fi
by gpderetta 6y ago
The infinite loop being UB was added because it prevents some important code motion optimizations and makes it hard to reason about the memory model. You can find the details on the papers leading to the C++11 memory model.
- souprock 6y agoUh, so what? Letting the compiler assume that a "switch" without a default will never go there is a great optimization too. Why not put that in the standard? Actually, this is worse. Letting the loop be UB is like letting a true "if" be UB. Just never mind the code actually written; surely it doesn't mean what it says.
- gpderetta 6y ago> Letting the compiler assume that a "switch" without a default will never go there is a great optimization too. Why not put that in the standard? that's actually the case already. A missing default is UB if the switch condition does not match any of the cases. And C compilers already optimize accordingly.
- volta87 6y ago> The infinite loop being UB was added because it prevents some important code motion optimizations Which ones? If this optimizations are so important, how come Rust was designed in such a way to make them impossible? Also, how does this fit, e.g., the benchmark game results which show that Rust is faster than C for all benchmarks considered there ?
- gpderetta 6y agoStore sinking for example, which is unsafe unless the loop is guaranteed to terminate. C does not have this guarantee (at least not in all cases). Also rust is compiled with the llvm backend, so my understanding is that in practice rust assumes that loops terminate. See: https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/28728 https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/28728 There are llvm directives that can be added to prevent the optimization, but they are rejected by the rust maintainers exactly because they would cause performance regressions.