5 ms·
And it's amazing to me that any Telegram coverage on HN is met with extremely hostile reactions. All they did was not invent the best encryption in the world...
by pdimitar 6y ago
And it's amazing to me that any Telegram coverage on HN is met with extremely hostile reactions. All they did was not invent the best encryption in the world... like you, me, and 99.9% of the world. Mortal sin, right?
So please stick to facts and what can be reasonably proven, please. The rest is meaningless noise and mindless hate.
The author himself admits it's much more likely this was an amateurish mistake than some man-in-the-middle conspiracy. Did you make it until the end of the article?
- saagarjha 6y agoI don’t think your paraphrase is an accurate representation of the article.
- pdimitar 6y agoFrom the article: > Anyway, it’s been a while, the world is a different place now, and maybe Hanlon’s razor cuts deeper than I thought. How else would you interpret it?
- saagarjha 6y ago“This looks like a backdoor but if I think really hard maybe I can consider it to be incompetence?” Neither is a good look for a security team, of course.
- pdimitar 6y agoYes, it's not, but my (and his) point stands: it's likely incompetence. It's very biased and uncharitable to immediately assume malice.
- ryanlol 6y ago>(and his) point stands: it's likely incompetence That’s not what the post is saying. > It's very biased and uncharitable It’s not “very biased”, if you actually look at what Telegram did the balance of probabilities leans heavily towards “backdoor” and not “not backdoor”
- pdimitar 6y agoSo, give me your definition of Hanlon's Razor then (mentioned at the end of the article by the author).
- ryanlol 6y agoI think you’re completely missing the nuance in the words surrounding the authors mention of “Hanlon’s razor”. Besides, look at Pavel Durovs flagkilled reply here. The lady doth protest too much, methinks.
- pdimitar 6y agoThat's not saying anything of substance unless you offer your own interpretation. "You're wrong" is not a discussion, it's a kick in the gut. > The lady doth protest too much, methinks. Solid criticism with well laid-out arguments from you, no doubt. > Besides, look at Pavel Durovs flagkilled reply here. Since when do upvote / downvote count mean anything at all about somebody's opinion or statements? (I haven't read the comment though.) Look, it's obvious you have a beef with Telegram / Durov. But you are not giving any arguments, only snark. That's breaking HN's guidelines last I checked.
- ryanlol 6y ago>I haven't read the comment though Maybe do that. Not being snarky, you’re missing important context.
- pdimitar 6y agoI did read it now. It's not constructive, that's a fact, but have you never got worked up by unrelenting criticism? Still, he's an official public face and should know better. That I fully agree with.
- saagarjha 6y agoI certainly hope that’s not the real Pavel Durov…
- saagarjha 6y agos/likely/unlikely but possibly/
- pdimitar 6y agoWell, that's how probabilities work and I am not seeing your rephrasing as adding anything valuable to that discussion. Unless you put concrete % numbers on both sides then your replace is identical with the original.
- saagarjha 6y agoOh, please, this is not a math inequality where we compare with numbers. It is plain to any English speaker that what was written in the article and how you represented it differ significantly in the confidence that they communicate. As such, your continued insistence that there is no major difference between the two comes off as extremely poor faith.
- pdimitar 6y agoYou might be missing that many people here might not be native English speakers. As such, being crystal clear on what the author believes might be beneficial. Just putting "hey I might be wrong" in the end of an article is just word-padding and since I assumed the author doesn't do that, I entertain the possibility they mentioned seriously. ...Bad faith? Most of HN has bad faith when it comes to Telegram. This place devolves to Reddit / 9GAG levels of childishness when Telegram is mentioned. I think that's quite fascinating and it's a strange outlier. Yes -- strange, as in "not justified". They did nothing more wrong than a ton of other, much more widely used software, yet any mention of Telegram on HN brings about a big bandwagon of haters. Why do you think that is?
- ycombinete 6y agoHanlon’s Razor says to never assume malice where stupidity suffices as an explanation. The only way I read this sentence is to say that Hanlon’s Razor applies here, in-spite of how malicious the bug looks.
- pdimitar 6y agoSame for me. While others argue that it's "obvious" that the author believes much more strongly that this find is a backdoor and not a dumb mistake (a very easy one to make for a non-cryptographer programmer), I am still unconvinced. Would be curious to read a statement from Telegram's team though -- not that any team would ever admit to putting a backdoor...
- ncmncm 6y agoParaphrasing Clarke, "Any sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from a backdoor."
- FiloSottile 6y agoIt's not. (I'm the author.)
- pdimitar 6y agoAs said in another comment of mine, putting a generic "hey I might be wrong" at the end is pure fluff. Stick to what you believe in, you are not in front of a court. Case in point: the Hanlon's Razor mention definitely did mislead me in terms of your stance.
- FiloSottile 6y agoMy position is that this looks like a backdoor but there is no way to know for sure, and I stand by it. If you find it too nuanced that's ok.
- pdimitar 6y agoI found it ambiguous, nothing more. And I expressed an opinion to which half I subscribe to. Maybe that's valuable feedback for you as a writer, maybe it's not. In any case, no hard feelings were intended anywhere.
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoThe situation is (slightly) ambiguous. It looks like a backdoor. Anyone competent writing that code would be doing so because they wanted the backdoor. But there's no reason to assume Telegram's authors are competent unnecessarily, and competence in UI design doesn't imply competence in security. And it's also a rather obvious-looking backdoor, anyone competent would presumably try to hide it better. Then again, the NSA backdoor in Dual-EC-DRBG was pointed out before anyone started using the spec and not that well hidden, and the NSA are generally considered competent.
- pdimitar 6y agoOh, I am not firmly claiming that it's not a backdoor. It very well might be! But that's what mostly what I was saying (granted, I got worked up at one point because the blind stereotyping puts a black mark on HN's reputation in my eyes) is that indeed the situation is ambiguous and both possibilities are [mostly] equally likely.
- FDSGSG 6y ago>All they did was not invent the best encryption in the world. They shipped a backdoor. It's pretty clear that Telegram is actively malicious. They haven't been caught again? They probably realized that the front door of not encrypting chats was sufficient. >The author himself admits it's much more likely this was an amateurish mistake than some man-in-the-middle conspiracy This is not at all what the author is saying.
- pdimitar 6y ago> Anyway, it’s been a while, the world is a different place now, and maybe Hanlon’s razor cuts deeper than I thought. Unless you have another interpretation of the Hanlon's Razor, it seems that he is saying this is a mistake and not a backdoor. > They shipped a backdoor. Did they? Might be. I am 50/50 about it, people do dumb mistakes with self-rolled crypto all the time and that's a sad reality. But who knows, it might be the first try to embed a backdoor. My point is: being too sure one way or the either makes you biased. I err on the side of incompetence but I am open to the possibility that it was a first sloppy attempt at backdooring Telegram. Sadly we have no proof of either, so we speculate based on what's available.
- StavrosK 6y agoIf someone says "so this guy killed himself with three shots in the back, but maybe that's a common method of suicide" doesn't mean you think it's suicide. It's a turn of phrase to accentuate how much you don't think it was suicide.
- pdimitar 6y agoI suppose I missed his sarcasm then. Happens pretty easily over text. As said in another comment, I am no cryptography expert. I simply argue against the very visible negative bias against Telegram which is accentuated even more by very childish snarks on almost any Telegram HN thread. That gets to me and it's not how HN should be. I never argued that my opinion is a fact. I said how I arrived at my opinion and debate with people whether that's plausible or not [based on limited info]. The rest can be proven/rebuked by specialists.
- sneak 6y agoNothing about my comment could reasonably be described as "extremely hostile". You seem to be exposing a bias.
- pdimitar 6y agoYour whole comment is a simple middle-brow dismissal. Maybe not "extremely hostile" indeed, but not constructive by any measure. If by calling out people who break HN's guidelines I am exposing a bias then okay, I am exposing a bias then.
- 3np 6y agoI don't think anybody's hating on the authors of Telegram - just that it's not one of the better options today.
- pdimitar 6y agoI am not sure I can agree with that either (unless your definition is "does it strictly adhere to end-to-end encryption standards", in which I'll agree with you that it's not the best). Last I used Riot/Elements (the app the uses the Matrix network), I almost pulled my hair out. It was slow and buggy. Felt like I was using an alpha version of a software from the late 90s. Telegram and WhatsApp are two very positive outliers in a sea of very bad messaging apps IMO.
- 3np 6y agoThis whole thread is about security. That your priorities differ from other commenters doesn't make the criticisims "mindless hate" (and, again, not directed at individuals, just that we think the product and service is garbage from a security perspective. Don't conflate the creation with the creators)