3 ms·
Too much of this article made me feel uncomfortably like the author doesn’t understand that the “out group” to an oppressor isn’t the same as the oppressor iden
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
Too much of this article made me feel uncomfortably like the author doesn’t understand that the “out group” to an oppressor isn’t the same as the oppressor identified as “out group” by the people they oppress.
> And this isn’t a weird exception. Freud spoke of the narcissism of small differences, saying that “it is precisely communities with adjoining territories, and related to each other in other ways as well, who are engaged in constant feuds and ridiculing each other”. Nazis and German Jews. Northern Irish Protestants and Northern Irish Catholics. Hutus and Tutsis. South African whites and South African blacks. Israeli Jews and Israeli Arabs. Anyone in the former Yugoslavia and anyone else in the former Yugoslavia.
I’m not going to pick through every example here, but it’s plain as day there are examples where no reasonable person in this audience would characterize as “engaged in constant feuds and ridiculing each other”.
Imploring people to find grace in fault is one thing, but imploring people to find forgiveness for those who would murder them for who they are is another. And imploring people who don’t find themselves particularly in the middle of such violence to see them as “feuding” is despicable.
I’m sure there’s more nuance in the article but I honestly couldn’t get past this passage. And I’m comfortable with the fact that my tolerance has limits, including not treating nazis and German Jews as somehow morally equivalent in conflict, even rhetorically.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think one valuable insight is that blind hate can twist the mind and soul of an individual, even if the hated group is clearly in the wrong. When you dehumanize others, you give up some of your own humanity. It is one thing to make a stand and say something is wrong, it is another to give in to tribalism and lose perspective. >I’m sure there’s more nuance in the article but I honestly couldn’t get past this passage. And I’m comfortable with the fact that my tolerance has limits, including not treating nazis and German Jews as somehow morally equivalent in conflict, even rhetorically. The article did not touch on moral evaluations. It explored tribalism as a human tendency, how it manifests, and it who it targets. The example of Jews and Nazis illustrates this point.
- rendall 6y ago> Imploring people to find grace in fault is one thing, but imploring people to find forgiveness for those who would murder them for who they are is another Perhaps true, but Scott Alexander implored no such thing. I'm sure that he is quite intimately acquainted with the concept of people who would murder him for who he is > not treating nazis and German Jews as somehow morally equivalent in conflict, even rhetorically You really, really misunderstood the article