4 ms·
Advertising is evil episode 3457 I know I say this a lot but ad-supported business models are corrupting. Spam is the original sin of the open internet and the
by anigbrowl 6y ago
Advertising is evil episode 3457
I know I say this a lot but ad-supported business models are corrupting. Spam is the original sin of the open internet and the unwillingness to get to grips with this is a big part of why we can't have nice things.
Context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Siegel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Sie...
On Usenet, which ran on NNTP, every user could maintain their own killfile, which would allow people to hide spam. But it wasn't easy to share killfiles, and while the more technically capable people would easily filter it out they were also blinding themselves to a problem that eventually choked the life out of the community. Similar observations could be made about advertising on the web, from standardized banners leading towards today's web horrible mess.
The basic problem is that the costs of spamming and lying are generally a lot lower than the potential profits, so the more opent he system the more spam it tends to attract. Try looking at used car adverts on Craigslist for example, dealers in busy areas tend to run a hundred ads a day with 500 keywords. Some people flag them, of course, but most don't bother and the profit in selling a single car is worth the minor downsides.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Similar observations could be made about advertising on the web, from standardized banners leading towards today's web horrible mess. I think we have two separate issues here. One is the business model problem. Google puts ads on YouTube, then out-competes actually-free software alternatives because they have money from advertising and for-pay alternatives because they don't charge money to users. Hello surveillance capitalism. The other is the Twitter problem. It's harder to block (only) low-quality posts than make them, therefore Twitter. I think the first one is just a coordination problem. We need a one-time expenditure to get the likes of PeerTube to a level of usability, reliability and performance equal to YouTube, and that's it. Then you don't need YouTube anymore, or Twitter or Gmail or anything else that could be replaced in that way. It takes a one-time expenditure of resources to create the technology, so we just need a way to raise the money. Once it exists it's a lot easier to raise the smaller amount of money needed for incremental improvements. (And really it's already happening but it's taking too long to get to the mass adoption phase for lack of resources.) The second problem is harder, but maybe some kind of proof of work system for account creation. So there is a one-time cost of some kind for account creation, negligible for an ordinary user who will use it for ten years but costly to a spammer who will have their account blocked with all its posts removed in 30 seconds. Also, in article about first commercial spammer: > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Siegel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Sie... > Occupation: lawyer (disbarred in 1997)
- dibujaron 6y ago"we need a one-time expenditure to get PeerTube ... equal to YouTube" software is never a one-time expenditure. Even more so than usual for something as large and complex as YouTube.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoTell that to djb. Software is a continuing expense because software developers want to justify continuing to get paid. Tell me what I get from YouTube today, that I should care about, that I didn't get five years ago.
- lhopki01 6y agoWhat is djb? I tried googling it and couldn't find anything that made sense.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agohttps://cr.yp.to/ https://cr.yp.to/
- jefftk 6y agoThis approach doesn't work, not even for DJB. For example, take qmail: https://www.abuseat.org/qmailhelp.html https://www.abuseat.org/qmailhelp.html Qmail does late bounces for a very specific reason: since it was architected and implemented long before spam became a serious problem, Daniel J. Bernstein (DJB) implemented Qmail in a highly efficient, but inflexible way. ... Qmail is essentially dead - there is no further development on the project as a whole, users of it are stuck with an old core, and lots of ad-hoc and sometimes conflicting patches. In other words, an obsolete design, and no ongoing coordinated maintenance.
- lrem 6y ago> Tell me what I get from YouTube today, that I should care about, that I didn't get five years ago. Five years of progress in the spam filtering arms race?