8 ms·
This has somehow gotten worse in recent years. When saving, it used to be you could use the mouse to navigate to a directory, then type the desired filename, a
by hedora 6y ago
This has somehow gotten worse in recent years. When saving, it used to be you could use the mouse to navigate to a directory, then type the desired filename, and press enter.
Now, typing the filename initiates a contextual search within the current directory.
Clicking in the filename textbox and starting to type doesn’t work either. You have to highlight the base (not the extension or “.”) of the filename. At that point, you can finally start typing the name of the file you want to save.
The same problem occurs if the file chooser happens to already be in the directory where you want to save the file.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoDoing some introspection (all too rare for me!), I find that this is the reason I've started avoiding creating new files in LibreOffice, and why my Downloads and Pictures folders are flat, unstructured messes. Too many programs use the GNOME file selector.
- Spivak 6y agoIsn’t that “better” in some sense? You don’t have to actually categorize anything in order to find it later. Just type what you want and let tracker pull it up for you. If I could just “accio my black jeans” I wouldn’t bother organizing my closet.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoI suppose it might be better? But the folder-first sort means I've got a miscellaneous pile of extracted archives very far away from the archives themselves… it's a complete mess.
- nl 6y agoThe assumes you know the name of the random image you downloaded to insert into the document. mjx3AmQXM5OrkxV7.jpg isn't super easy to remember (as a random real example chosen from my downloads directory)
- Spivak 6y agoI mean nothing excuses not having thumbnail previews. That’s just stilly. I just mean the default typing action to be search rather than typing the name of the file.
- nl 6y agoYeah ok. I think the OP was talking in the context of saving, where searching during the "save" process seems a much less frequent occurrence than giving the name to the file you are trying to save (which presumably you have to do 100% of the time).
- deergomoo 6y agoI’m not sure if this is still the case as I haven’t used desktop Linux for about a year now, but what made this extra irritating is that the file name would be highlighted already! How on earth can selected text in an in-focus modal window not be the target of keyboard input?
- alpaca128 6y agoFor me this is really annoying as well, together with the stupid text input fields that may display a blinking cursor even when they're not focused. And Firefox has this weird issue that now and then a newly opened tab doesn't focus the address bar, forcing me to use the mouse to select it. And I still don't get this trend in some newer software to make tab switching via Ctrl-[Shift]-Tab feel like the lottery instead of just going to the one on the left or right. There's a reason we can reorder tabs by dragging them around, and a reason our keyboards have more than just those three keys, and "fidget cube replacement" is not it. Sometimes I wonder if the UI designers never use their own products or just aren't aware that building habits for chains of workarounds should not be the normal way to interact with computers. /rant
- tomsmeding 6y ago> And Firefox has this weird issue that now and then a newly opened tab doesn't focus the address bar, forcing me to use the mouse to select it. I'm not sure I have this issue, but ctrl-L (or equivalently, ctrl-K) focuses the address bar. Less mouse usage.
- cesarb 6y agoIf you keep them separate (it's configurable), Ctrl-L focuses the address bar, Ctrl-K focuses the search bar. I don't know how these keys behave if you configure it to use a single combined address/search bar (I've always kept them separate).
- Rusky 6y agoWhen combined, Ctrl-K focuses the address bar with a `? ` prepended, which turns it into a search bar. (In the most recent version it replaces the `?` with the name of the default search engine, similar to Chrome.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rozab 6y agoYes! This issue infuriates me to no end. I've made my set up quite clean, I've got my tiling window manager set up how I like it, but if I want to keep using firefox I have to keep dealing with this ridiculous bug. What on earth was the person thinking when they created this? I've seen many other downgrades with gtk updates. The UI for Deluge, one of my favourite pieces of software, got pretty ruined by the gtk3 uptick.
- kiwidrew 6y agoYes, this exact issue frustrates me to no end. Another related issue: when saving something from Firefox, the file picker opens into _a random directory_ each time. Like maybe 50% of the time, it will be the most-recently-used directory, but the rest of the time it is a random directory that I had saved something to at some point in the distant past. It boggles the mind how these bugs can persist for years upon years, but my occasional forays into the GNOME bugtracker indicate that the developers just don't seem to care one bit about this stuff. They often seem downright hostile and defensive and dismissive of the bug reports, either closing them as WONTFIX or ignoring them until they rot.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI believe they are not random at all. I haven't dug into it, but I've seen similar behavior here, and my impression is that Firefox stores an association between some or all of the URL host component and the most-recently-save-to location. If you saved something from http://foo.bar.com/ http://foo.bar.com/ to /whatever in the past, future visits-and-saves to *.bar.com (or maybe just foo.bar.com) will use /whatever as the default location.
- ubercow13 6y agoYeah it is this. I believe there is some config option to turn this behaviour off, maybe browser.download.lastDir.savePerSite
- eitland 6y agoThe joys of modern ux where everything is supposed to be so intuitive that no manual, help file or getting started guide is needed. To achieve this features and configuration options are removed left and right. Now we have half the software, no manual and often it still confuses users :-) Edit: and I don't have a good, inexpensive solution to it.
- salawat 6y ago>Now we have half the software, no manual and often it still confuses users :-) I was going through the contents of a storage unit and came across one of those old digital executive day planner things from the 80's, still bundled with the manual. I cannot describe the sudden surge of childlike happiness. I loved reading about how to use things as a kid, and the little fold out pamphlets giving you a roadmap into efficiently using a device/software filled me with many hours of happiness and confidence as a child. I now do my best to WTFM (Write The Frigging Manual) where I work. It's amazing how quick something can be picked up with a little bit of guidance.
- tkuraku 6y agoThis is the most maddening behavior. I don't really care about the thumbnails not being there, but this irks me evertime I save a file.
- kristopolous 6y agoInstead of fixing old problems that the entire community agrees with wild consensus, they insist on spending time creating new problems. Perhaps we should stop whining and start fixing them. And then if the developers refuse to accept things people have been wanting for well over a decade then we can fork it and simply abandon them like any other archaic unusable thing of the past. We've all asked very politely long enough. This is open source, we don't have to put up with this, that's the whole idea behind it. Closed source solutions from 23 years ago shouldn't still be running circles around the current stuff. We should all be embarrassed.
- wruza 6y agoYou can fork code, but neither a development, support nor maintenance process. The truth is that there is no fork, Neo.
- kristopolous 6y agoSo someone implements all the features that a massive number of people want, people use it, but then you think there will be no interest in maintaining it? Sorry, I don't buy that.
- selfhoster11 6y agoIf the fork is closer to the final result that most people want, it's a no-brainer that developers, maintainers and the community will follow. There's no incentive to stay behind. It's worth studying the case of OpenOffice.org and MySQL. Both of these weren't satisfactory to the community for <reasons>, so the community forked them and did all the high-demand feature implementation on the fork. Now the original projects that were forked from are near-ghost towns.
- akerro 6y agoLike Mint failed to fork Ubuntu? Or Ubuntu failed to fork Debian? Or LibreOffice failed to fork OpenOffice? MariaDB MySQL?
- akerro 6y ago>This has somehow gotten worse in recent years I used to contribute bugfixes to Gnome2 in months before Gnome 3 was released. I observed product plan for Gnome 3 and was joking Gnome 3 will be just a red button that farts. So many functionalities removed, slower response time, regressions and defects everywhere, broken user experience worse than what Window 10 gave us later. I moved to XFCE and then to Plasma.
- tim1994 6y agoYes this super annoying. Its almost daily I run into that issue. The contents of filename input are even selected.