3 ms·
Network connections are getting faster... Peoples typing/reading speeds are not... One day it will be feasible for someone's phone to receive all messages s
by londons_explore 6y ago
Network connections are getting faster... Peoples typing/reading speeds are not...
One day it will be feasible for someone's phone to receive all messages sent by every other person on earth. They can then try to decode every message till they find one that their private key can decode.
You've now made the perfect privacy messaging system - by sending all messages to all users, no quantity of network packet sniffing/timing analysis/evil nodes can figure out who is talking to who.
- londons_explore 6y agoThought experiment: There are 7e9 people on earth. Say they send 10, 100 byte messages per day, but that compresses 10x (modern text compression using big neural networks is amazing). That works out to 7e11 bytes per day, or 8 Megabytes per second. That is nearly feasible today...
- generalizations 6y agoHowever, that's also 21 Terabytes per month. It'll be a while before that's feasible. Hopefully the population doesn't grow with our bandwidth capabilities.
- cmrx64 6y agothe square kilometer array produces a terabyte a second. 21tb/mo is peanuts. we’ll get there :)
- XorNot 6y agoBattery life is a problem though. Your phone running hot the entire time trying to decrypt every message in the stream becomes the new limiting factor.
- rhencke 6y agoYou may find https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Numbers_station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Numbers_station interesting.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoThis is exactly how bitmessage worked. The problem was that spammers would be able to flood the network with crap so to counter that it was added that proof of work must be completed to have your message forwarded on. The problem with this is it means you could not send a message from a mobile device because the PoW required was too high. Also a method to reduce the amount of traffic required was called streams. Instead of reviving all messages, you would be able to know what stream the receiver is on and then the receiver would just listen to all messages on stream 5. This scales up infinitely since you can just balance the network so all streams have hundreds of thousands of users on them.
- generalizations 6y ago> spammers would be able to flood the network with crap Would there be a legit motivation to do that? I get that it's a threat, but would it be possible to gain anything from DDOSing that network? Seems like either a) you come up with a system for banning spam IPs, or b) the spammers improve the anonymity of the rest of the network by creating more noise for the messages to hide in.
- londons_explore 6y agoWhen you design a system for users to send short messages for free, there is always someone who says "I could split my hard drive into billions of tiny pieces and send them all!".
- jakear 6y agoAny state actors who like to snoop would be incentivized to cripple the snooping-free network for the low low price of a few high capacity links. (Or better yet very many low capacity links)
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoIf its easy and annoying then there does not need to be a motivation. Someone somewhere in the world will pump out terabytes of junk just to ruin the system for others. And banning spam IPs is a kind of crap solution. Spammers would be running on home network IP spaces mostly so as those addresses shuffle around you end up banning most legitimate users as well. I have found my self banned from many sites I am only visiting for the first time due to someone else who was on my IP address before.
- oivey 6y agoI wouldn’t call that perfect because if your private key is ever compromised, all of your communication ever is compromised. Ideally data would be destroyed after a while, which isn’t really possible to do if everyone ever has the data. Broadcasting all messages everywhere would also be an incredible waste of resources, even if it was theoretically possible.
- sarakayakomzin 6y ago>I wouldn’t call that perfect because if your private key is ever compromised, all of your communication ever is compromised When did forward secrecy stop existing?
- rakoo 6y agoThat's why you rotate keys, the best way being whatever Signal does
- rakoo 6y agoThis has already been done, and it uses bitcoin code (but no blockchain): https://wiki.bitmessage.org/ https://wiki.bitmessage.org/ Of course there are scalability issues but they have a plan for that.
- Ninjinka 6y agoI think Signal should do something similar to this, just at a smaller scale. I've messed around making a game using this concept... An infinite 2D open world where people's chat messages appear over their heads. If they're speaking using the encrypted chat and they haven't shared their private key with you, it's gibberish. All messages and player locations are sent to all players, and you can zoom visibility in and out so you can't correlate location to find out who's talking to whom since everyone can theoretically see the whole map.
- ciex 6y agoI think this is exactly how scuttlebutt private messaging works.