3 ms·
> will the gullible and not-so-gullible-but-partisan accept actual, material evidence when it's presented? What is being presented is not evidence. It's absenc
by pdonis 6y ago
> will the gullible and not-so-gullible-but-partisan accept actual, material evidence when it's presented?
What is being presented is not evidence. It's absence of evidence, combined with blunt assertions. That's not what we should be getting from a truly secure election system.
Years ago, the kernel.org servers that host the source code to the Linux kernel were hacked. Lots of people and lots of corporations use Linux, so the security of the source code of the kernel is a serious issue. So what did the owners of the kernel.org site do? Did they shout over and over that there was no problem? Did they make a huge effort to argue against people (and there were plenty of them) who claimed this showed Linux was just not a serious OS, as compared to those other OSs owned by large corporations? No.
What the kernel.org owners did was much simpler. They just showed the security measures they already had in place, and explained how and why they worked. And since those security measures were good ones, based on cryptographically secure methods of signing and verifying code and detecting tampering, and since they were open, so anyone who wanted to could check and verify them, that was all they had to do. All the accusations and speculations about insecurity simply evaporated.
That is the kind of security we should have for elections. And it's blatantly obvious that we don't. And until we do, given how divided the country is, we will continue to have close elections that the losing side, or at least a significant portion of it, refuses to recognize as legitimate. This problem cannot be handwaved away, and it cannot be solved by shouting louder, the way Americans do in foreign countries in the hope that it will cause the natives to start understanding English. It can only be solved by implementing a secure, and transparently secure, election system, where nobody has to take anybody else's word that nothing questionable happened.
- jariel 6y agoThis isn't going to work. 1) There is an incredible amount of legitimacy and transparency in the system already. Your linux analogy simply doesn't apply. There are tons of 'eyes on the system', there are literally election observers. The rules are decided ahead of time etc.. With the 'Dominion' system there is literally a paper record of each ballot - there were recounts that validated the electronic counts perfectly. The 'voting and ballot' part of the election is very secure, and there's no way to systematically defeat it. 2) If there is an issue with the elections, it's related to 'who can vote'. States are in a constant war over this, the rules over 'how to purge voter roles' (look into recent Georgia rulings). Those things, are today 'grey areas' not well defined by anyone so it means conflict. 3) "And it's blatantly obvious that we don't. " Just the opposite, it's blatantly obvious that the elections are in fact secure - you've provided zero evidence to suggest otherwise. But you're missing the issue - the perception of election of integrity has nothing to do with election integrity. This has nothing to do with the facts. This has to do with whatever Trump tells people (i.e. Cargo Cult). If Trump had won the election, there would be zero concern over election integrity because it's entirely derided from his populist narrative. The elections are as secure as they were in 2016 and 2012 - and there wasn't some big uproar over 'ballot counting' then, was there? Why not? Because 'some populist figure' wasn't screaming 'Fraud' 'Fraud' 'Fraud'. And even if the election were 'mathematically secure' it still would not matter because this has nothing to do with reality, it has to do with narrative. A populist figure will say 'The Election Was Stolen' - and his Cargo Cult followers will believe him, irrespective of the facts.
- pdonis 6y ago> there are literally election observers Who are placed far enough away from what is happening that they can't usefully verify anything. What we should have are election workers from each party, paired up, with transparently verifiable means of confirming that they both agree on every action taken. > The rules are decided ahead of time And then those rules, established by the State legislatures ahead of time in accordance with the Constitution and Federal election law, are changed by State executive branch officials and judges. That is clearly unconstitutional. > With the 'Dominion' system there is literally a paper record of each ballot Printed out by a computer system with known vulnerabilities and laughable "security" precautions. > there were recounts that validated the electronic counts perfectly By counting ballots which were printed by the same machines that gave the electronic counts, so this so-called "check" is meaningless. > If there is an issue with the elections, it's related to 'who can vote'. Yep. The way to solve that is obvious: voter IDs with simple, objectively verifiable rules for eligibility and a requirement that every eligible voter must be issued one. Other countries have this. Mexico has this. Why can't we? > If Trump had won the election, there would be zero concern over election integrity because it's entirely derided from his populist narrative. Excuse me? Trump won the 2016 election and for four years we've been hearing concerns over election integrity from the side that lost that one. Sure, those concerns weren't coming from Trump supporters, because Trump won. And now, as you yourself illustrate, Trump opponents have no concerns whatever despite multiple issues at least as blatant as any of the ones Trump opponents complained about in 2016, because Trump lost. In other words, the winning side will never complain and the losing side always will, because the system is broken.
- pdonis 6y ago> A populist figure will say 'The Election Was Stolen' - and his Cargo Cult followers will believe him, irrespective of the facts. s/A populist figure/The losing candidate/. Hillary Clinton and her Cargo Cult followers still believe she won the 2016 election.
- perl4ever 6y agoThe belief that Hillary won the popular vote overall is pretty widespread. But isn't that true and uncontroversial? Beliefs about Russian interference are also widespread, but they are also true/well documented and unconnected to the actual voting. There was no movement that I know of, like we see now, saying that the swing states that went to Trump had subverted elections. Once or twice recently I may have seen someone idly saying "hey, Republicans tend to project, I wonder if we should investigate the 2016 and 2020 elections to see if they were up to something". I ran across the claim that Republicans won in almost all of the states that don't have proper paper trails for voting, which could be suspicious. I don't know if that's accurate, and I don't know of any movement pursuing that.