3 ms·
No full forward secrecy. >All traffic is encrypted using a symmetric key, meaning that anybody who has the cabal://abcdef key can read cabal network traffic.
by snvzz 6y ago
No full forward secrecy.
>All traffic is encrypted using a symmetric key, meaning that anybody who has the cabal://abcdef key can read cabal network traffic.
If you're even considering this, look at https://tox.chat/ https://tox.chat/ instead. That one's been around for a while (thus mature) and actually has full forward secrecy.
- mempko 6y agoProblem with forward secrecy is that it doesn't really work well for a use case like cabal. You want to be able to join a cabal and read all the past conversations.
- snvzz 6y agoThat's desirable for some rooms, not on every room and definitely not on private conversations. Matrix handles that well, by having a setting per-room regarding handling of room history.
- Multicomp 6y ago(never tried cabal, it could be worse) tox was accused of having a poor crypto implementation / playing silly buggers with libsodium. I've tried it on android, works ok but most apps at the time seemed older. not sure where tox stands re community liveliness but its certainly a good start on p2p messaging, my claims notwitshtanding.
- snvzz 6y ago>tox was accused of having a poor crypto implementation The actual flaw: If _your_ *private* key is stolen, your friends can be impersonated to you. Hardly worth the infamy. There's a bug open on this, the solution is known, the opportunity for a fix, and when it will be made live, will be the next time a protocol break ("flag day") is necessary for other reasons.
- Multicomp 6y agoI will be trying tox again after that event then.