3 ms·
> In the world of immigration policies, letting some specific people in is better than letting no one or everyone in. The middle ground is better than the extre
by arcticbull 6y ago
> In the world of immigration policies, letting some specific people in is better than letting no one or everyone in. The middle ground is better than the extremes.
I've actually long wondered if this is true.
Freedom of movement obviously works at the city level, up to 1 million or so. It obviously works at the megacity level, up to 10 million. It obviously works at the individual state/province level up to 40+ million. It obviously works at US scale (350M). It obviously works at EU scale, 800 million. It obviously works at India's scale, 1.3 billion people.
Why is it that if you tried to open the border literally any wider than it is right now, it would all fall down?
It's never made sense to me.
There are huge disparities in wealth and income within America, right? America's poorest state has a median income of 45K (Mississippi) and it's richest state has a median income of 80K (Maryland). Why doesn't everyone just move to Maryland? Or better yet just move to San Francisco (median 112K). Obviously there's factors other than economics keeping people in place.
- AlgorithmicTime 6y agoSo the obvious answer is that you can either have welfare programs or you can have open borders, you can't have both.
- gspr 6y agoWhat's your logic here? Many European countries have generous welfare programs, and have open borders with other EU countries with far less generous ones. It works. One common approach is to mandate having worked at least one day in the country in question in order to be able to use welfare programs, and keeping things like unemployment benefits proportional (with a cap, of course) to previous income in the same country.
- twblalock 6y ago> Many European countries have generous welfare programs, and have open borders with other EU countries with far less generous ones. It works. Actually it has caused a lot of resentment in the richer countries and it was one of the contributing factors to Brexit, as well as the rise of new far right parties in France and Germany. It's also notable how Europeans reacted to non-European migrants who attempt to enter the EU while fleeing the war in Syria. I wouldn't say the EU has migration very well figured out.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gspr 6y agoResentment, perhaps, but the original claim I'm countering was something else. The goalposts seem to be moving.
- harimau777 6y agoI think it could be because labor laws differ much more between nations than they do between states. There's more room for corps to drive down wages by outsourcing labor to nations that don't have labor laws.
- nicoburns 6y ago> There are huge disparities in wealth and income within America, right? America's poorest state has a median income of 45K (Mississippi) and it's richest state has a median income of 80K (Maryland). Why doesn't everyone just move to Maryland? Or better yet just move to San Francisco (median 112K). Obviously there's factors other than economics keeping people in place. That's still a relatively small difference compared to places where incomes can be $100/year or much less. I definitely think there's room for more experimentation in this area, but it's probably not as simple as "just open the borders".
- rorykoehler 6y agoCompletely agree. The first step is to make everywhere in the world baseline ok to live.
- nicoburns 6y agoYes, although it's interesting to note it that one interesting effect of opening borders would be to create a massive incentive for wealthy countries to establish this baseline. I don't think just opening would work because the short-term shock would be too great (+ nobody in those countries would agree to do it), but I do think eroding borders in some way may be necessary to get people in wealthy countries to take the needs of those elsewhere seriously. Currently we tend to have some level of wealth redistribution within countries, but very little between them.
- rorykoehler 6y agoI think we should commit to opening borders completely by 20XX, like we have the Paris Climate Accord. That will force us to act.
- bluedino 6y ago> Why doesn't everyone just move to Maryland? Maryland has Baltimore. One of America’s poorest cities. Moving to Maryland won’t solve someone from Mississippi’s problems.
- bserge 6y ago[deleted]
- woopwoop 6y agoSo would you favor making it illegal for talented people to leave regions of the United States that are unusually dysfunctional? Should people born in Detroit have to stay there to rebuild the region?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zwkrt 6y agoI disagree that people should be disallowed from leaving a warzone because if they were allowed to leave all that would be left is the warmongers. That outcome seems like the most humanitarian and egalitarian in a warzone. I wouldn’t want to describe to an about-to-be rejected asylum seeker that everyone is actually better off if they are left to die in their place of birth as opposed to living freely in any other part of the globe.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hyko 6y agoYes, you’re right it doesn’t make any sense, there’s no real reason it wouldn’t work. You’d have to rethink national and supranational government at that point though.
- megameter 6y agoIt's the ghost of merchantalism, really. What matters to a nation or empire historically is putting more stuff - goods, ships, people - "on the books", and calling that the wealth, but annexation and political incorporation as the way of accomplishing this gradually fell out of favor as we entered the modern period and turned towards productivity metrics. But you can create a scenario where your accounts - you being "whomever holds political power" - are inflated relative to others by enforcing favorable borders and terms of trade, so that you wield more productive forces relative to everyone else. And that's been the strategy of industrial-colonial countries. If you are for global productivity, rather than local wealth, then open borders are the way, but they come with all kinds of other political challenges since they put the world on a course to unification more generally.
- michaelscott 6y agoI've wondered this for some time too, and I think the issue is culture. Ask anyone who's moved continents (or even say from somewhere like Manhattan to New Mexico) and they'll probably tell you there's a culture shock that requires adjustment, even sometimes in the little things. Everything from how the banks operate, what days and times grocery stores are open, and how to get around with what transport all the way to bigger things like ease of socialising with locals or a new language (not to mention nearby family help/responsibility). In areas with easy migration I think there's less of a cultural shift that a person has to go through in order to make it work. That's why it works within cities and states/provinces, and Europe and India could fall into this as well. Even when it is legally and logistically possible, how many people actually do make the move from NY to New Mexico or how many French decide to work somewhere like Germany?