7 ms·
"That's why education is the most important pillar of democracy. Education is everything. " The kind of people who get into positions of power - well, my impre
by inglor_cz 6y ago
"That's why education is the most important pillar of democracy. Education is everything. "
The kind of people who get into positions of power - well, my impression is that they think they know better. Even if they are aware of the fact that in 1930 someone fucked up, they will not entertain the fact that they themselves might do the same.
Also, some events are really complex. You can educate people about the 1929 or 2008 economic crises from very different perspectives, from far-left to libertarian, and the lessons will be very different.
- jsmcgd 6y agoI think that's why an education has to be broad. A selective education can be tantamount to brainwashing/propaganda. Give the students as many perspectives and hope that they will do something sensible as they process the information; knowing that not all will, but most. I believe that the more perspectives you are aware of, the less likely you are to be dogmatic and extreme in your beliefs and actions. You will be reminded how dissimilar real life is to simple ideas and rhetoric, that it is a shifting ocean of nuances and caveats. Or society can go the other route, assume you cannot trust the people and create a tyranny of disinformation and control.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y ago> Give the students as many perspectives and hope that they will do something sensible as they process the information I don’t know if you’ve gone to college recently but that was not my impression. It’s a woke monoculture. Discourse is gone.
- SantalBlush 6y agoDiscourse is narrower than you'd like; that doesn't mean it's "gone". When someone makes extraordinary claims like "Discourse is gone," that is a red flag that they are not viewing the situation objectively.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoPrecisely demonstrating my point: a hyper-sensitivity and censorious attitude against any advocacy for unmitigated debate.
- SantalBlush 6y agoYou are calling my disagreement a "censorious attitude." Sorry, but I am allowed to disagree with you.
- squidlogic 6y agoSo perhaps a better claim would be that the new discourse is unduly confined and the older modes of discourse are gone.
- SantalBlush 6y agoThat's a better starting point for a productive discussion, but still hyperbolic. Moreover, do you notice that my comment is being grayed out as people who disagree are downvoting it? A lot of people who claim to value discussion really don't; not on Hacker News, and not elsewhere.
- cbozeman 6y agoYou're being downvoted because discourse should never be narrowed, period. Ideas should be thrown into the public square, in the full light of day, and judged on their merits.
- SantalBlush 6y agoHopefully you realize the hypocrisy of graying out my comment in the name of promoting discourse, but I doubt it. Ideas should absolutely be judged on their merits; here we agree. Too bad that's not how humans work. Instead, they tend to choose whichever truth they like best based on how it makes them feel; politicians know this, which is why they don't bother crafting logically sound arguments backed with evidence. They play on peoples' emotions. Moreover, the university is not a public square. You attend as a student, which means you are there to learn, not to share your thoughts like it's a real-life HN thread. Don't want to learn the material? That's completely fine. The solution is to not sign up for the class, not to whine about how "discourse is gone" just because the teacher doesn't want to waste time on every edgy kid's opinions. People didn't pay massive sums of money to hear you talk. They paid to learn from experts.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zarkov99 6y agoPerspectives are important and so is a humble study of history as way to understand human nature. We are so in love with your technological prowess that we forget it all sits on top of wetware that is very close to what it was 10000 years ago. Recognizing we are driven largely by instinct, some of which we can inhibit some we cannot, would help all of understand what works and what does not in a human society.
- mrfusion 6y agoThe most educated people I know seem the most partisan right now and most likely to parrot main stream media talking points. It’s making me question my assumptions about education. On the other hand Im just one data point.
- rblatz 6y agoMainstream media talking points vary from Trump and his family are breaking norms and traditions in a very dangerous way to our country, all the way to the Biden crime family is going to ruin this country. With major undertones of a lot of hurt, anger, and feeling like there is no hope among minorities or rural whites depending on which sources you choose to consume. Both are true, both need addressed. And it’s likely not a coincidence that both groups think the other’s movement is their enemy.
- undoware 6y agoI get routinely modded down on this site for pointing out issues that are ostensibly too political, like workplace discrimination. But on this same site, somoene can literally carry on a discussion echoing the (proven false) propaganda points ("biden crime family"? dear lord) and it stays up without downvote for (checks watch) an hour and counting. Everything this past week has been a chest x-ray of our collective spirit, and it came back solid white. This is vastly smaller in degree but not in kind. Time for some introspection, dear readers.
- afuchs 6y agoThis is a bit of a meta discussion, but there does seem to be a marked difference between what the moderators do (most recently, pruning entire threads) and what users using the "flag" button and down voting does. The last couple of days have been particularly hellish, with many threads that descended into flame wars which drifted far away from whatever the original post was about. I agree that there have been many threads that were far from being good faith discussions and turned into shouting matches with too many posts made in bad faith (such as citing bad sources that did not contain anything directly relevant to the point being argued, or links to sources that just repeated the original unsubstantiated allegation without presenting any evidence). Actions taken by users in these threads seemed to reflect preexisting biases rather than anything resembling a good faith debate. With that I want to express my appreciation for the moderators who's job I do not envy but who are very necessary to keeping this site functioning in any way.