3 ms·
Wait so your criticism of wikipedia is it is too complicated to understand and you can't effectively criticize wikipedia if you dont understand it? That's cert
by bawolff 6y ago
Wait so your criticism of wikipedia is it is too complicated to understand and you can't effectively criticize wikipedia if you dont understand it?
That's certainly a criticism i haven't heard before. I suppose in a way its true - wikipedia has its own culture, norms, etc, both written and unwritten, which can be hard to penetrate for an outsider (i would argue that WMF also struggles with that). But i think any large online community is going to have that. Heck, actual anthropologists have written actual books on the culture of debian, i dont see why wikipedia would be any less complicated.
> Another issue is that Wikipedians probably won't want to associate their Wikipedia identity with their HN identity (and similar).
And that is an issue because? [For the record my wikipedia username is the same as my HN username, and i know other people for which that is also true]