3 ms·
How is WebP better than JPEG XR (HD Photo) which already has an ISO standard?
by protomyth 16y ago
How is WebP better than JPEG XR (HD Photo) which already has an ISO standard?
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoJPEG XR appears to be aimed at being a less resource intensive alternative to JPEG-2000 for camera manufacturers and semi-pro photographers. WebP seems to be setting itself up to be used to deliver images via the web. Currently XR has a lossless mode, 4:4:4 color support, tiling and alpha which make it more featureful than WebP but those have all been announced for future versions with some features having experimental implementations already. On the other hand XR, at least the currently available encoders, seems to perform very well under PSNR tests but fails compared with even JPEG in SSIM tests. http://sites.google.com/site/dlimagecomp/ms-ssim-results http://sites.google.com/site/dlimagecomp/ms-ssim-results It also worth noting that being an ISO standard holds far less status ever since Microsoft bent the procedures beyond breaking point for OOXML.
- protomyth 16y agoI don't see an ISO standard as being less than it was. I think the big win for JPEG XR is that their are some pretty good people who built it. If camera manufactures adopt it, then I think it is going to be the default. I don't see any real advantage to WebP.