3 ms·
Sorry if it’s obvious, but why don’t people think Wikipedia should work in theory? Isn’t it just tapping into the need to tell people things you know and feel g
by kortilla 6y ago
Sorry if it’s obvious, but why don’t people think Wikipedia should work in theory? Isn’t it just tapping into the need to tell people things you know and feel good about how smart you are?
Or is the concern not around how content is submitted but more around how disputes are resolved?
- bawolff 6y agoIn the early days most people outside of wikipedia assumed that nobody would contribute to such a project without being compensated, that wikipedia is a communist pipe dream etc. The quote is meant as a play on the quote how communism works in theory but not in practise.
- kortilla 6y agoWhy would it be called a communist pipe dream? It’s not mandated by the government and doesn’t use tax revenue. Open source already existed and was thriving so I’m still not getting why there was any doubt. Seems like it would have just been FUD from the encyclopedia industry and people who didn’t know about open source.
- bawolff 6y agoWell for starters some americans think biden is a commie, so its not like logic really comes into play when americans use "communist" as an insult. That said, i dont think tax revenue supported infrastructure is really the definition of communism either.
- kortilla 6y agoCommunism usually requires social ownership. Wikipedia is not owned by “the people”.
- goto11 6y agoI would have expected it to be destroyed by vandals, marketeers and trolls, and that nutcases and people with alternative facts would have crowded out actually knowledgeable people. For every person with a deep insight in a subject, there are fifty people who think they have a deep insight, and it is hard to tell the difference from the outside. My concern was not that nobody would contribute, but that the wrong people would contribute. Also "neutral point of view" is impossible, as any writer knows. It is surprising and amazing the Wikipedia works so well. Although I'm sure they use a lot of resources on combating trolls and manipulation.
- hutzlibu 6y agoI suspect it might have to do with the early adopters, who were not shitheads and as far as I learned, they are not soft on protecting their turf against vandals and other idiots. That created also lots of collateral damage and criticism, the loudest critic on wikipedis I usually hear is that they are too strict and eager on banning and locking articles.
- canofbars 6y agoWikipedia has a bunch of power user tools that are not very clear to the average user. Power users also have the ability to lock hot topic pages so only other power users can touch them.
- chalst 6y agoNeutrality in context really means covering all the significant points of view that are supported by reliable sources. The tricky concepts are the notions of undue weight (you really can't document everything anyone has ever said about Aristotle, for instance), and where to draw the line on what sources are regarded as reliable.
- tshaddox 6y ago> For every person with a deep insight in a subject, there are fifty people who think they have a deep insight, and it is hard to tell the difference from the outside. If it’s hard to tell the difference from the outside, how do we know which one we got?
- jessriedel 6y ago> Isn’t it just tapping into the need to tell people things you know and feel good about how smart you are? As I said: this putative explanation predicts we would have all sorts of great free things that we don't have, e.g., free reliable news, free trustworthy product reviews, good documentation for python libraries, etc., etc. Yes, it's possible to tell a bunch of just-so stories, but the number of free parameters you need always exceeds the amount of data explained.
- ghaff 6y agoReally just generally how Wikipedia works relatively well. And you're right. It's never been entirely clear why Wikipedia succeeded vs. others although there are various theories.[1] Certainly there have been failures: Goggle Knol and, at this point I think it's fair to say, Quora. [1] https://www.niemanlab.org/2011/10/the-contribution-conundrum-why-did-wikipedia-succeed-while-other-encyclopedias-failed https://www.niemanlab.org/2011/10/the-contribution-conundrum...