4 ms·
> not an existential threat to the republic. Because it wasn't. Not even close. Snowden materials demonstrated a threat to the republic. This is nothing by co
by paulddraper 6y ago
> not an existential threat to the republic.
Because it wasn't. Not even close. Snowden materials demonstrated a threat to the republic.
This is nothing by comparison.
Inexplicably lax security allowed a mob to get access to the Capitol building and break the windows and fight and take selfies with police (including a few tragic deaths), a bad situation that was corrected within hours.
It's like saying the protests of Summer 2020 put Minneapolis in existential danger, or Seattle in existential danger.
> If they even TRY to replace RBG we burn the entire fucking thing down.
> Sep 18, 2020 https://twitter.com/rezaaslan/status/1307107507131875330 https://twitter.com/rezaaslan/status/1307107507131875330
You could make such wild claims (and many on the other side HAVE), but hopefully most people understand that for what it actually is.
---
There's so much exaggeration and hyperbole on all sides, and this just proves provides more evidence for conspiracy theories. It might be your moral right to fan the flames of this fire, but I wish you wouldn't.
The solution to bad speech is more speech, not less.
EDIT: And let's say you're right, that there's large amounts of open unironic sedition in the US. I doubt forcing it onto Gab or elsewhere is really a net win.
Revolutions happen when people believe they do not have a voice. It's mindboggling to think that removing people's ability to speak is going to make people less violent.
You're taking away their peaceable recourse and leaving them with unpeaceable options. What do you think is going to happen??
That just so backwards from what should be the goal. Proponents of free-speech intuitively realize this.
---
WHAT WAS WORSE: The Reichstag fire, or the reaction to it?
- three_seagrass 6y agoWhat do you think an existential threat to the republic would look like?
- temp8964 6y agoIs Osama Bin Laden really really bad? Yes. Was he an existential threat to the U.S. He wishes. Were the mob capable as Osama Bin Laden? Not even close. Even if they did explode the whole congress building, it is far far far far away from an existential threat to the republic.
- paulddraper 6y ago1. Nuclear capabilities by North Korea or Iran. 2. Snowden-ish conspiracies by unelected, unaccountable intelligence agencies. 3. Large-scale conflict with China. 4. High-fatality disease: SARS or similar (COVID but more deadly) Terrorism, foreign or domestic, doesn't even scratch the list of "existential threats." Terrorist acts don't win heats and minds and unless aided by state actors (dirty bombs, etc) are tiny in the numbers game, even for sometime like 9/11.
- three_seagrass 6y agoIf you were to end the republic without the usual mass murder (nuclear war, pandemics, etc.) How would you do it? If you took out the Senate and legislature, would that work? What if you could guaranteed their protection was understaffed when you attempted it?
- throwaway201103 6y agoIt would be a big problem, but I don't think so. It wasn't in the realm of possibility on January 6, but for sake of argument.... Say the entire Sentate and House is wiped out somehow. They are not essential for day to day governance. State Governors would make emergency appointments to replace them as a first response. It would be hugely disruptive and chaotic, but I think the republic would survive. The republic is the states. The people in Washington are just the representatives.
- edmundsauto 6y agoThis could have led to Trump's appointment, depending on how the states were allocated votes (allocated by whom?) That would have been a very bad situation that I wouldn't want to see how it played out.
- ModernMech 6y agoThey wouldn't wipe out the entire US House and Senate. They would wipe out only those who didn't agree to object to the certification of the Biden's election. They would eliminate Senators and Representatives until Trump was appointed. Now you have an illegitimate president. As you say, the republic is the states, and I don't see how e.g. the Republic of California continues in the Union at that point. > They are not essential for day to day governance. Remember that states are not allowed to print their own money as the federal government is. States are now spending vast amounts of money to combat Covid. The federal government is funding these efforts by literally printing dollar bills. If the federal government fails to prop up states, you're looking at states unable to fund hospitals, police, teachers, utilities, etc. If the entire House is eliminated, there's no one to vote on federal budgets, and governors cannot just appoint Representatives as they can Senators -- Representatives must be elected in a special election in their districts according to the constitution. Meaning money from the federal government would just dry up without the House. Obviously the framers never anticipated this edge case.
- DonHopkins 6y agoOrange.
- throwaway201103 6y agoConducing a fradulent vote count to elect a president that the people didn't really want.
- mopsi 6y agoHaving lived through the collapse of the USSR, the key events could be: 1. New leaders emerge. Industrialists, generals, university professors, even shipyard electricians. They obtain enormous influence through their personal charisma, leadership skills and the political platform they advocate for (think Martin Luther King). 2. Local municipal authorities stop recognizing the central government. They establish democratically-elected councils to temporarily run things in the power vacuum. 3. Security apparatus flips - police and military will stand by, do nothing and just wait to see how the situation develops. Each battalion and police station aims to maintain reasonable peace in their own district (in cooperation with local authorities) and ignores other orders. 4. Having lost all support and control, the central government collapses under its own weight. They may issue orders, but no-one's following them. 5. A grassroots, national assembly type institution with universal popular support emerges to prepare major legislative reforms such as a new constitution to formalize power transfer to new institutions (new government, new parliament). A referendum or general election seals the deal. In contrast, a bunch of rednecks breaking in for a few hours, taking selfies and stealing minor items is nowhere near this. They have no real leaders, no platform, no support.
- TameAntelope 6y agoI think this is a good response, but I do urge you to consider that there is not one specific form a failing Republic will take. Also, I would argue that many of these things did take place. America is fortunate there was a competence problem, but I identify many of the items you listed here as having transpired. A failed <thing> is still an attempted <thing>.
- legutierr 6y ago> Each battalion and police station aims to maintain reasonable peace in their own district (in cooperation with local authorities) and ignores other orders. Well, considering that this is how domestic police and national guard already operate in the US—with police operating under municipal authority, or under the authority of the local elected sheriff, and with national guard operating under the authority of each state governor—I don't think observing this would give you any indication that the republic is under threat. In fact, your points 1, 2 and 3 seem to describe the normal operation of American democracy for the past 200 years or so, with regards to most domestic affairs.
- awb 6y agoLet's take it for what it is: a completely unacceptable act of violence by a few people instigated by the constant delivery of blatant lies. At first the lies were shocking: "Biggest inauguration ever? What the hell is he talking about? Didn't he see the pictures? Oh, alternative facts.. LOL. Well, good thing they're incompetent and not dangerous." Now the lies are dangerous. So many were complaining 4 years ago because this arc seemed inevitable. Let someone lie and verbally attack anyone who slightly disagrees with them without repercussion and they'll keep pushing to see where the line is. So many thought: "I'm sure he's learned his lesson this time!" In reality, you'd have to be blinded by naiveté or something worse to think he was going to change or moderate his behavior or tactics. It's not that people are scared that a few hundred people storming the capital will actually overturn our almost 250 year old democracy. It's that if we don't respond with intense rejection of this behavior, this behavior could easily become an existential threat to the republic. What's to stop the next President from bringing an armed secret service or a willing FBI SWAT team into a Senate proceeding? The line should have been drawn long before this incident. But now, for sure, if you violently attack the halls of democracy you should be banned from far more than a few private digital platforms.
- paulddraper 6y ago> if you violently attack the halls of democracy you should be banned from far more than a few private digital platforms Not many take issue with that. It's banning the hundreds of thousands other people that's the more problematic thing. > violently attack the halls of democracy What makes the "attack" on the Capitol any worse than the "attack" on the White House in Sep 2020? Mostly just how well security worked. That's it. If security had done it's job on Jan 6, this would be done. The currents exist either way. It boggles my mind to think that censorship is how to handle dissent.
- awb 6y ago> What makes the "attack" on the Capitol any worse than the "attack" on the White House in Sep 2020? Those protesters didn't have bombs and guillotines. And they were being beaten and gassed by police, they weren't killing police officers. I hear you that if that mob killed someone it would be just as bad, 100% agree. > It boggles my mind to think that censorship is how to handle dissent. Because you have the right to be a jerk in your own house, but not in mine. Twitter is not Trump's house, it's Jack's and his shareholders. Trump's being a jerk so them kicked him out. Some things that will get you banned on Twitter, FB will let slide and visa versa. If people don't like their policies, they can leave. It's a free market, which is a traditional Republican position. It's never been a Republican position to force a company to allow someone to create their own Terms & Conditions or User Agreement or force companies to accept someone as a customer until this modern "free speech should apply to private companies" movement. And dissent is different than lying. It's clear his ego can't handle losing and he will desperately resort to pressure folks to "find votes" in Georgia, or pressure Senators to not certify electoral votes that withstood every legal challenge. This isn't normal and this isn't OK. It's not like this is a healthy debate or a passionate dissent that someone's getting deplatformed for. This is a dangerous, self-indulgent, completely self-serving game of lying to the public that's already resulted in multiple deaths. If Trump gets arrested for speaking his mind in a public park then we have a huge problem. Until then, he can build his own platform and spout his ideas there. No one is stopping him and no one should.
- SirHound 6y agoMore speech is what got us here in the first place
- dimgl 6y agoTHANK YOU.
- arrrg 6y agoWhy are you ignoring that the President instigated the insurrection? Is that irrelevant? The president does have actual power …