6 ms·
It isn't censorship. No one is telling Parler they're not free to do what they want. AWS is telling Parler they don't want them as a customer. That is not censo
by onion2k 6y ago
It isn't censorship. No one is telling Parler they're not free to do what they want. AWS is telling Parler they don't want them as a customer. That is not censorship. Whether a business should be able to refuse a customer is an interesting question. People on the political right have historically believed they should (refusing to make a wedding cake for a gay couple is often cited as a case of such freedom).
There is also an argument that AWS is now so big and important that they should be treated like a utility, and then refusing customers is something that they shouldn't necessarily be allowed to do. I'm not sure how I feel about that argument though.
- techfoolery 6y agoThe day big tech companies learned that democrats would chair all the congressional committees that oversee them, these kinds of actions started happening. If that doesn't concern you, I don't know what to tell you.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoIt is entirely telling what they could get away with under Republicans.
- dagmx 6y agoIt's also the day there was an insurrection/invasion of the capitol to prevent the Democratic process. This was fueled by the unfettered calls to violence on Parler. If you're going to pick the events of the day, it's best to mention both.
- throwaway201103 6y agoAfter a summer of riots, looting, and violence all across the country, fueled by calls to violence on Twitter and Facebook
- dagmx 6y agoWhat calls for violence, that weren't moderated? What organized looting? What riots that weren't instigated by police brutality? Did any of these try and overthrow the Democratic process? Please provide examples or you're just providing false equivalencies and whataboutism.
- lliamander 6y agoPoliticians, including the incoming VP, did encourage and even bailed out the rioters, and did nothing to curb the violence directed at innocent civilians. Let me be clear, even if you believe police brutality is a real problem, there can be no justification for the torching of homes and livelihoods done last summer. Escalating to violence at the capitol was wrong, but I have little sympathy for the politicians that did not use their influence to curb that massive harm done communities across the country by the riots.
- dagmx 6y agoThe rioters that were bailed out, were they involved in said looting and violence? What were they guilty of? Do you have links to people who took part in criminal activities that were bailed out by the VP or other politicians? Did the VP encourage and incite violence?
- lliamander 6y agohttps://thefederalist.com/2020/08/31/meet-the-rioting-criminals-kamala-harris-helped-bail-out-of-jail/ https://thefederalist.com/2020/08/31/meet-the-rioting-crimin... This information is not hard to find.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dagmx 6y agoTwo of the three listed people are for crimes unrelated to the protest. The only one related to the protest has no body cam footage made available. It's currently an allegation and should be treated as such, especially given the protests revolve around police brutality and several events of police fabricating events (Breonna Taylor). Regardless, you claim the VP encouraged rioters. Did she encourage them to commit violence? Did she or any of her close affiliates say to hang other members of government? Did they say there should be trial by combat? This is a clear shifting of goalposts and false equivalencies between a (then senator) donating to a charity and a current president and his affiliates fomenting violence. Did Kamala tell the rioters that they're special and she loves them after they stormed a government building with pipe bombs and zip ties?
- QuizzicalCarbon 6y agoTo elevate that mob of miscreants and their raid to an insurrection or invasion will only give them more legitimacy and notoriety. They are criminals, period, who never had a chance to cause fundamental damage to the function of government (by their own actions, anyway). Don’t give them more power.
- MiscIdeaMaker99 6y agoIt's also right after Trump sent a mob to attack Congress.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ripdog 6y agoI'm a LOT more concerned about the rise in hateful, violent rhetoric being bandied about by self-described 'patriots' who seem hell-bent on bulldozing their way into political power as soon at it became obvious that they could not win by legal means. These people stormed the legislature of the US to attempt to install their cult leader as dictator. If that doesn't concern you, I don't know what to tell you. And Parler will find another web host. If the daily stormer can find one, these clowns will. They're not disappearing.
- cutitout 6y agoOf course it's concerning, but it's also concerning how quick people are to dehumanize and call for censorship, putting a lot of energy into discussing endlessly just how evil or stupid or unreachable those other people are, rather than root causes [0]. The mainstream is whipping itself into hysteria just as much as QAnon does, and it really does seem like circus all around. Just for some perspective: > The capitol has been the site of multiple bombings, shootings, assassination attempts, and stormings for centuries. Pretending its an unbespoiled sacred Church which has never been penetrated so vulgarly is just ahistorical. -- https://old.reddit.com/r/stupidpol/comments/kt0xpm/in_1954_4_puerto_rican_nationalists_opened_fire/ https://old.reddit.com/r/stupidpol/comments/kt0xpm/in_1954_4... [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiCeqySVhCE&t=20m55s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiCeqySVhCE&t=20m55s edit: clicking a button doesn't constitute an argument. You can only ignore Chomsky, neither tie his shoelaces or address his points. Shame on you.
- joe_91 6y agoThis is also because learning to live with each other is harder than just denouncing the other side. We need to help people understand that the root cause needs to be examined as you said. This looking for the root cause usually works well in big companies - for example on the Toyota production line but in politics people tend to look for easy answers. Examples like the war on drugs, getting overly tough on crime or defunding the police altogether do nothing but exacerbate the underlying issues. Apart from calling this out and trying to vote in people who can think deeper I'm not sure what else to do. Living in close nit community/larger families you need to learn accept people for who they are and that seems to be going out the window with the increased focus on the individual in modern western culture. There's no one size fix all unfortunately...
- onion2k 6y agoIt doesn't concern me at all. It didn't concern me in 2016 when all these companies helped Trump and his campaign, and when none of them banned him despite repeated violations of their T&Cs. Now that it serves the companies to act they're all starting to act. Companies are largely bipartisan. They do what they need to do to stay in business and maximize their profit. That means playing politics and shifting from one side to the other when the wind changes. The time to be concerned would be if these companies choose politics over profits.
- Barrin92 6y agoIt concerns literally everyone that large tech companies are opportunistic and only start taking violent threats seriously the moment the bully in chief is out of office, but you have it the wrong way around. This type of content should have never been tolerated to begin with, the only reason they're only starting to do something is because they don't fear political retribution any more.
- nautilus12 6y agoWhen you are the main defacto means of deploying web platforms it essentially does amount to cencorship. The irony of the comparison to twitter is that parlor IS trying to be a twitter competitor thus preventing twitter from falling into the same classification of being too big to be non competitive
- ehsankia 6y agoExcept that's not true. Just because they have around 50% (a bit less actually) doesn't mean there aren't hundreds of other options. Hell, you can literally host a website from your own computer from your own house. If it was an ISP blocking, where more Americans have access to 1 or 2, then you'd have an argument, because it's also near impossible for people to spin off their own personal ISP. But there are hundreds if not thousand of hosting platforms online, and you can spin up your own pretty easily.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- diveanon 6y agoThere are posts on this site almost daily talking about rolling your own infrastructure. If you want to be a sensationalist go back to reddit, because you are speaking to the wrong audience here.
- ehsankia 6y agoI'm tired of it being "[website] is censoring Y", when in reality it's "[website] is not giving free megaphone to Y". Posting on these websites is a service they provide, it's a platform allow you to use, and they have zero obligation to give it to you.
- genera1 6y agoAWS is nowhere near big enough to be treated as utility, there are heaps of alternatives, big cloud providers (Azure, GCP, Oracle), hundreds of smaller cloud hosts, then there is self-hosting. What should be treated as utility is tier 1 networks, and I haven't heard about Level 3 or AT&T refusing to carry someones traffic.