3 ms·
> So AWS is now the arbiter of what actions are supposedly harmful to the fabric of democratic society? No, everybody is. In a democratic society, it is the re
by crazygringo 6y ago
> So AWS is now the arbiter of what actions are supposedly harmful to the fabric of democratic society?
No, everybody is. In a democratic society, it is the responsibility of every citizen and corporation to act in accordance with democratic values.
At the end of the day, democracies aren't built out of laws written on paper -- they're built on the everyday decisions people take such as voting, arguing over issues, and condemning non-democratic bad actors.
Just as people can protest in the streets against undemocratic abuses of power, so corporate entities can and should deplatform people and organizations that explicitly, violently threaten our democracy.
It's up to every person and corporation to be their own arbiter. That's the ultimate safeguard of democracy.
If AWS waited for a court order, it could very well be too late.
- Fellshard 6y agoThe exact same argument could be applied regarding free speech, mind. While the government is the only entity /legally bound/ to not restrict speech, it is also untenable to have a government that cannot touch it presiding over an oligarchy of corporations that are wholly censorious. If free speech is critical to a democratic society (which it is), it is necessary that corporations do what they can to uphold it.
- hypersoar 6y agoThe actual solution is to not allow the existence of enormously powerful mega-corporations. The problem is that we have these companies, each able to influence hundreds of millions to billions of people with virtually no accountability. Facebook and its subsidiaries comprise the most far-reaching media apparatus in history, and the whole thing is under the control of a guy. The same is largely true of Amazon. We shouldn't have let this happen.
- agiroth 6y ago> No, everybody is. In a democratic society, it is the responsibility of every citizen and corporation to act in accordance with democratic values. Exactly, everybody is. In a democratic society, everybody decides together what the rules for things like this are, not 2-3 tech CEOs. I say, draft laws around this and let the people vote on them. Then at least we'd have some basis for doing things like this.