4 ms·
Basically the whole proposition of parler was that it was a refuge for alt-right/proto-fash/actual-fash who perceive moderation on other platforms to be stiflin
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
Basically the whole proposition of parler was that it was a refuge for alt-right/proto-fash/actual-fash who perceive moderation on other platforms to be stifling. Yeah, I’d wager the vast majority of Parler users are either involved in the kinds of shit that finally tipped the scales or giving it safe haven.
Even if not, why is Apple or any other organization obligated to host them?
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoNo, that was not the proposition of Parler, and it was specifically against the TOS and still is.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoAnd yet, it’s where the people who value that proposition keep flocking. It’s almost like they understand some subtext about the service and its intent.
- conception 6y agoTOS doesn’t mean anything if they aren’t enforced.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoThey are. Go ahead and report something, then let us know how long it stays up. People organize violence on twitter almost every single day.
- Barrin92 6y agoIf they actually enforced their TOS 90% of their extremist userbase would leave, which is why a post about shooting Mike Pence by one of their most followed users could stay up for days until Apple threatened them.
- lawnchair_larry 6y ago“Hang Mike Pence” was trending at the top of twitter. Now what? They’re a pre-series A startup with a very small staff. If people don’t report things, it’s not feasible to expect that they’ll all be actioned. Instead of reporting the post, activists with an agenda thought it better to cherry pick them and attack platforms. A more honest test would have been to report the content and see if they acted on it. But let’s not kid ourselves, this campaign was disingenuous from the beginning. The real goal is to shut down a perceived enemy in the culture war.
- dashundchen 6y agoDidn't stop the attack on the Capitol being organized there. In fact there is another attack being organized there for the inauguration. There are many far-right watch groups tracking this.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Didn't stop the attack on the Capitol being organized there. If it were organized on Telegram would you ban Telegram? If it was organized by phone would you ban phones? This is just silly.
- dashundchen 6y agoPerhaps telegram should crack down on these channels during this crisis, yes. Parler made no attempt to turn down the temperature by removing calls for murder, assasination, or civil war. These platforms are at this moment currently being used to mass hype up an increasingly armed and paranoid segment of the population hyped up on years of cult-like propoganda, conspiracy, and dehumanizing of their imagined enemies. It was a stroke of luck they did not take out Congress the other day, I'm sure some will try again. If you want a clue where this ends up unabated and exploited, I encourage you to look into the 1994 Rwandan genocide.
- smsm42 6y ago> Yeah, I’d wager the vast majority of Parler users are either involved in the kinds of shit You lost your wager. Majority of Parler users are not. If you dig enough, you can find shit - just as easy as on Twitter or Facebook, which hosts hundreds of violent groups and thousands of stupid comments which can be interpreted as advocating violence, though in 99.9% of cases it's just people being stupid on the internet - but majority of the users aren't that. It's just regular people who happen to be to the right of Jack Dorsey politically.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoThis is Hacker News. Do I really need to explain that sentences clearly delineated with punctuation, with clause-joining words like “either” and “or” are an atomic thought meant to be consumed in full? You even quoted “either” and cropped off “or”.
- smsm42 6y agoI have no idea what "giving it safe haven" in the context of social media site means (am I "giving safe haven" for everybody that ever posted on HN? am I responsible for every comment ever posted on HN?) so in the interest of sanity I answered the part which is not obviously nonsensical, since X or false == X.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoOn a site like HN, those kinds of behavior are moderated and known to be unwelcome. On Parler, it’s well known that they’re tolerated and implicitly welcome. Participating without challenging that is giving it a veneer of legitimacy, sheltering it, and lending plausible deniability to a platform clearly designed for them. Even a completely galaxy brain position on speech that promotes private platforms which must allow completely unmoderated content actively promoting and organizing violence... hanging out with the people doing that is tacit endorsement.
- smsm42 6y ago
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoMaybe try reading some actual postings on Parler? It might surprise you.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoBunch of good apples happy to coexist with the bad ones? I accounted for that.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Yeah, I’d wager the vast majority of Parler users are either involved in the kinds of shit that finally tipped the scales or giving it safe haven. Where is the data please, instead of wild guesses?