4 ms·

So with Coca-cola, the ingredients are fully known, it's just the process that's secret?

chrisseaton 6y ago
> No one has figured out their recipe to date > So ... the ingredients are fully known ... ? No... because nobody has figured out their recipe. They just said that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_formula https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_formula
laoganmaplz 6y ago
Also the proportions. While (in the US at least) manufacturers are required to list their ingredients in the order of greatest proportion to least proportion, they are not required to disclose what those proportions are, which also adds some difficulty to reverse-engineering the recipe.
- sgerenser 6y ago
  I think the biggest catch is being able to throw potentially thousands of different substances under the generic “natural flavorings.” Read the Coca Cola ingredients list and you certainly don’t see “coca leaf extract” on it.
fitzroy 6y ago
Also, perhaps, difficult to come by: "...Though the company removed cocaine from the carbonated concoction over 100 years ago, coca leaves are actually still used to flavor Coke. The soda brand has an exemption with the government allowing them to import coca leaves into a decocanization plant in New Jersey where cocaine is removed so the leaves can be used in Coca-Cola for their natural flavors." https://www.foodandwine.com/drinks/55-million-worth-cocaine-showed-coca-cola-plant https://www.foodandwine.com/drinks/55-million-worth-cocaine-...
klodolph 6y ago
The ingredients for the Coca-Cola flavor are listed as "natural flavors". That's the extent of disclosure. Trade secret just means that they don't share the recipe and make efforts to keep it secret. Calling it a "trade secret" is really a marketing strategy as much as anything else. Just like the rumors that coca leaf extract are an ingredient... something that is "neither confirmed nor denied". A marketing strategy. I think that it's basically flavored with vanilla, cinnamon, a few essential oils (orange, lemon, lavender), and some spices (nutmeg!). One you start adding that many flavors to a recipe, the exact flavors are no longer important, and I'm sure you could replicate something similar at home if you were willing to do enough experimentation. There are a few recipes online that you can use.
- tims33 6y ago
  A trade secret is a type of intellectual property and has a place in law.

> No one has figured out their recipe to date > So ... the ingredients are fully known ... ? No... because nobody has figured out their recipe. They just said that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_formula https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_formula

laoganmaplz 6y ago

Also the proportions. While (in the US at least) manufacturers are required to list their ingredients in the order of greatest proportion to least proportion, they are not required to disclose what those proportions are, which also adds some difficulty to reverse-engineering the recipe.

sgerenser 6y ago
I think the biggest catch is being able to throw potentially thousands of different substances under the generic “natural flavorings.” Read the Coca Cola ingredients list and you certainly don’t see “coca leaf extract” on it.

fitzroy 6y ago

Also, perhaps, difficult to come by: "...Though the company removed cocaine from the carbonated concoction over 100 years ago, coca leaves are actually still used to flavor Coke. The soda brand has an exemption with the government allowing them to import coca leaves into a decocanization plant in New Jersey where cocaine is removed so the leaves can be used in Coca-Cola for their natural flavors." https://www.foodandwine.com/drinks/55-million-worth-cocaine-showed-coca-cola-plant https://www.foodandwine.com/drinks/55-million-worth-cocaine-...

klodolph 6y ago

The ingredients for the Coca-Cola flavor are listed as "natural flavors". That's the extent of disclosure. Trade secret just means that they don't share the recipe and make efforts to keep it secret. Calling it a "trade secret" is really a marketing strategy as much as anything else. Just like the rumors that coca leaf extract are an ingredient... something that is "neither confirmed nor denied". A marketing strategy. I think that it's basically flavored with vanilla, cinnamon, a few essential oils (orange, lemon, lavender), and some spices (nutmeg!). One you start adding that many flavors to a recipe, the exact flavors are no longer important, and I'm sure you could replicate something similar at home if you were willing to do enough experimentation. There are a few recipes online that you can use.

tims33 6y ago
A trade secret is a type of intellectual property and has a place in law.