3 ms·
> Their BATNA is Android, which allows sideloading Android is not an alternate for iPhone. They are not interchangeable. I don't know why people keep saying
by jedberg 6y ago
> Their BATNA is Android, which allows sideloading
Android is not an alternate for iPhone. They are not interchangeable. I don't know why people keep saying this.
Maybe for some people they are interchangeable, but they are sufficiently different that they are not true substitutes.
- criddell 6y agoIs Ford an alternate for Toyota?
- jedberg 6y agoNo, not really. That brings up a good point. Would people complain if all the car dealerships decided you could only buy American cars from now? Would they say "why are you complaining, you can just get a Ford instead of a BWM"?
- tomrod 6y agoPeople would complain at first, and then either ship their cars or build a new car company. In fact, this is exactly what folks did to Tesla in the beginning. Of course the difference here was that Tesla owners were not seeking to overthrow democracy in the US.
- jedberg 6y ago> Of course the difference here was that Tesla owners were not seeking to overthrow democracy in the US. I'm not sure how that is in any way relevant to the discussion of Android and Apple being substitutes or not. You keep bringing that up in your other comments too. To be clear, I don't support people who want to rise up against the US, quite the contrary. But they still bring to light an important point -- why does Apple get to say what apps I can install in my phone?
- Bud 6y agoBecause Apple is running the store. It's their store. And users have voluntarily and intentionally bought into an ecosystem that Apple moderates and curates, because that curation has substantial benefits. Could we stop feigning ignorance about this?
- jedberg 6y agoI'm well aware that they curate. I can still complain about it try to fix it though, since I like all the other things Apple does. I don't want to switch, I just want my device to be better.
- Bud 6y agoNo, it doesn't bring up a good point, and your analogy is poorly drawn. The situation with Parler and Apple is analogous to expecting a Ford dealership to sell, and promote, Tesla's products, or another car-maker's products.
- crocodiletears 6y agoNot if you're comparing a Prius and an f350. They both do the same task of 'people moving' but have very different appeal and featuresets. Most people could get away with either, regardless of their situation. But there are edge cases where their differences shine.
- criddell 6y agoPrius and F350 are specific models. Android and/or iOS can be on small phones, big phones, tablets, Televisions, etc... So I think the analogy is broader - Ford and Toyota.
- jedberg 6y agoOk fine, let's go with your analogy. If build quality is my main factor, than Ford is not a substitute for Toyota. If having a Hybrid SUV as big as the Highlander, Ford is not a substitute. There are lots of reasons people want a Toyota, and Ford doesn't have all those things.
- tomrod 6y agoIt is either a substitute or a complement as they both are in the automotive industry. A complement is like peanut butter and jelly -- buying both makes life that much better. Clearly this isn't the case here. So let's drop the misapplied definition for "substitute" and move on. Your point is better made by identifying perhaps unjustified cost increases in purchasing (i.e. Toyota unionizes and causes a 0.002% increase in the car price, analogous to the increased difficulty in communication these insurrectionists now have in communicating with their proto-terrorist cells).
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoFor the HN demographics? No. For HN's landscaper? Sure.
- graeme 6y agoIt is, if one of your highest use cases is “Parler we an app on my phone” One of the main features of buying an iphone is “Apple guarantees my privacy and security”. If you are choosing the former it strongly suggests you don’t care as much about the latter. Being on a system that allows sideloading is a serious step down in security especially for the non technical majority.
- jedberg 6y ago> It is, if one of your highest use cases is “Parler we an app on my phone” That is not my highest use case at all. I have an Apple Watch. An Android phone works very poorly/not at all with it. I have an iPad. An Android phone does not easily sync between them. I have a Mac laptop. An Android phone does not sync well between them. I think the UI on the iPhone is much more intuitive. I can't get that on Android. There are a bunch of apps that are only available on iPhone. The iPhone has better apps for my kids. I could keep going on, but my point is, there is a lot my iPhone can do that an Android can't, for me. > If you are choosing the former it strongly suggests you don’t care as much about the latter. It doesn't in any way suggest that. > Being on a system that allows sideloading is a serious step down in security especially for the non technical majority. I agree. So make it hard to do. Put it behind a set of options. Make me have to install a text file on a BSD machine and then sync my phone to enable it. Just make it possible and let me assume the risk.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI like that your position offends both iPhone users and Android users equally. (I really do.) Ultimately, is there anything that can be done? If you had to pick one specific world-changing action, what would it be, in detail? Your original premise was interesting, but perhaps difficult to codify.
- jedberg 6y agoIf I could change anything, I would codify interoperability and access equality into law. If you have an API on your device and any app has access to it (1st party or not) than all parties should have access to it. It's fine if you want to have private system APIs, but if you're publishing apps for your platform than all apps should have access to the same APIs. Maybe even specially call out that anyone can install any app they want on their mobile device, and this must be made accessible. You could even add in some weasel words like "after reasonable precautions have been taken" so that Apple can make you jump through some hoops to install an "unapproved" app. Let the courts sort out what is reasonable or not.
- tomrod 6y agoIphone offers no common services that Android cannot provide. This is why they are saying it. [X] Phone [X] Text [X] Compute Applications [X] NFC or other near items I guarantee the vast majority of consumers aren't using more than an extremely limited feature set that both phones happily share with their customers. Are they produced by the same designer? Nah. But that really doesn't matter for functionality purposes.
- jedberg 6y agoThere are many "compute applications" only available on iPhone.
- tomrod 6y agoSo? There are still alternatives on good old laptops/desktops. What application of computing (not specific compiled binary, but rather generic spreadsheet, ssh, chat, etc.) is not available on Android? You may have found your next business opportunity if you get moving. You'll simply be responding to capitalism as Parler did when they started, and as Google and Apple are doing now.
- jedberg 6y ago> So? There are still alternatives on good old laptops/desktops. I can't carry a laptop in my pocket. > What application of computing (not specific compiled binary, but rather generic spreadsheet, ssh, chat, etc.) is not available on Android? I'm not sure how that is in any way relevant, but regardless you know very well that it is completely disingenuous to suggest that someone just "build a new app" for another platform. Not every spreadsheet is the same. Not every chat app is the same. Someone isn't just going to go out and build another Fortnight because you can't get Fornight on the iPhone anymore.
- tomrod 6y agoIt is not disingenuous, Iphone legitimately offers no major feature you can't get from Android. You're arguing that feature parity is required for subsitutition, and that is an addled argument. It's not even temporally consistent, as you have prior versions of applications with features removed. You can carry a laptop in your pocket. Sony VAIO had a mini edition around 2007. You can also use a bag, which has big pockets, and you can connect to networks and even cell networks. Point is -- your argument here is very weak that the two platforms aren't substitutable, and there really is nothing left to say. Have a pleasant evening or morning, as the case may be.
- zaroth 6y agoA substitute need not be identical or equivalent. What you’re describing is a commodity. Neither Apple or Android are a commodity. They are a differentiated good, but they compete in the same market and are substitutes for each other.