4 ms·
> Doubtful Absolutely true. At least one whole generation grew up taught in school that singular "they" isn't a thing. I was on the tail end of that and read
by Izkata 6y ago
> Doubtful
Absolutely true. At least one whole generation grew up taught in school that singular "they" isn't a thing. I was on the tail end of that and read a lot of books written by the previous generation, so it never stuck strongly in my head, but that's what GP is referring to.
- kelnos 6y agoI don't think that's the case. I think many people (myself included) were taught only that "they" is plural, not that it explicitly cannot be singular. The distinction there may be too subtle to matter for some people, though. Either way, clinging to a frozen-in-time interpretation of a living, changing language is foolish for anyone who would like to easily understand and be easily understood. And not waste time in our too-short lives on pointless language nitpickery like we're doing here.
- staticassertion 6y agoI suppose I should have said it's doubtful that you lived at a time when the argument against singular they was legitimate. I'm sure many teachers are teaching students incorrect things all the time. But by modern English standards, which I would define through works like Fowlers', the legitimate argument against singular they is long over.