4 ms·
In other forms of engineering, the culture is very clear: simplicity is an achievement. Solving an easy problem with a big, expensive solution is not an achieve
by userbinator 6y ago
In other forms of engineering, the culture is very clear: simplicity is an achievement. Solving an easy problem with a big, expensive solution is not an achievement. It's unskillful. The best engineers come up with solutions that make you see the problem as an easy one. Solving easy problems with difficult solutions proves you aren't qualified to take on the problems that need those solutions. How do we establish this as a standard belief in software engineering as well?
My experience with things like foreign automotive components suggsts this is not exactly true in general... but it's true that monsterously complex solutions seem to be far more common in the software world.
- tome 6y agoCan you elaborate? Are you saying foreign automotive components are needlessly complex?
- closeparen 6y agoGerman sport / luxury cars are renowned for excessive "because we can" capability, and the complexity to go with it. A cynic would say the complexity does not even have to bring extra capability; frequent and costly maintenance is an important part of the status signaling. This is diametrically opposed to e.g. Toyota's simple, traditional, robust, and scalable transportation appliances.
- tome 6y agoThat's interesting. In the UK Audi, Mercedes and BMW (to a lesser extend) have a reputation for reliability. Is that misplaced?
- closeparen 6y agoThe German car situation in Europe is a bit different, several popular explanations: - Lower spec versions are available and common; the brands themselves are not inherently special or upmarket - This means mechanics who work on the brands do not automatically command a premium - Parts are not subject to import duties and supply chain cannot get away with as much markup (after Brexit who knows?) - Culture of better compliance with scheduled maintenance - Depending on location, better maintained roads and milder weather Also they have invested a lot in reliability in the 2010s and some of the reputation is a holdover from previous generation models. Problems will still be outrageously expensive to fix compared to Japanese cars but are not so disproportionately likely to occur. My dad briefly owned a BMW as his midlife crisis car. The bi-xenon headlights looked better than any I had ever seen. But when one burned out it was $1500 between the part and the labor to remove practically the whole front end. This is considered a characteristic, “classic BMW” kind of problem.