3 ms·
Did he also design AArch64? Because I've noticed it can be used to design very fast processors, yet abandons most decisions in ARM7 and Thumb. I was just curio
by astrange 6y ago
Did he also design AArch64? Because I've noticed it can be used to design very fast processors, yet abandons most decisions in ARM7 and Thumb.
I was just curious about how SIMD worked in RISC-V so I looked it up… and apparently RISC-V doesn't have SIMD, instead it brings back microcoded large vector operations from the 70s, and the RISC-V designers called SIMD bad and compared it to the opioid crisis because it means there are too many instruction opcodes?
https://www.sigarch.org/simd-instructions-considered-harmful/ https://www.sigarch.org/simd-instructions-considered-harmful...
So I'm now even less impressed and also slightly offended. This is not realistic, short vectors are important and easy to do in hardware.
- nickik 6y agoMany codes can be expressed much better with Vectors and there is also much ability to further extend it in the future. You can do short vectors with the RISC-V Vector extension and you can implement them in a simply way as well. Have you worked with both or did you just form your opinion based on what you are used to? Again, RISC-V is not one thing, its modular. The 'V' extension is considered to be the right thing for most serious processors. However there is also the 'P' extension, for embedded that does Packed SIMD.