6 ms·
his non-fiction needs more reading. I honestly don't think his fiction is that good in comparison. One of my favourite pieces of criticism is still Asimov's fai
by Barrin92 6y ago
his non-fiction needs more reading. I honestly don't think his fiction is that good in comparison. One of my favourite pieces of criticism is still Asimov's fairly snarky review of 1984.
http://www.newworker.org/ncptrory/1984.htm http://www.newworker.org/ncptrory/1984.htm
- watwut 6y agoHonestly, after attempting to read it, I read much better criticisms of books then that one. He takes forever till he even get toward book criticism part. Plus, Asimov complaining about Orwells female characters is kind of rich.
- samatman 6y agoIt's a good essay, in the narrow sense that it unequivocally identifies Asimov as a Communist and apologist for Stalin. This aspect of the Futurians is often memory-holed, I thank you for bringing it to everyone's attention. His critique of the science fiction, that screens which watch you back is a poor prediction (because how on Earth could Google watch people at scale?!) is particularly hilarious, if a bit sad.
- gtsop 6y ago> it unequivocally identifies Asimov as a Communist and apologist for Stalin. Scroll to the bottom of the article. > His critique of the science fiction, that screens which watch you back is a poor prediction (because how on Earth could Google watch people at scale?!) is particularly hilarious, if a bit sad. > Orwell was unable to conceive of computers or robots, or he would have placed everyone under non-human surveillance. I guess this answers it
- watwut 6y agoI think that last implication is more of Asimovs weakness then Orwels one. It is 2021 and we don't actually have those robots. We have cheap workers. It is also stretch - not making robots did not mean you are not able to imagine them. It means they are not necessary for story. Asimov was not too good with humans, which would be fine. But the idea that it must be robots is weakness of his critique.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> it unequivocally identifies Asimov as a Communist and apologist for Stalin It critiques 1984 for it's narrow focus on the Stalinist form of totalitarianism, but I see no actual apologia for Stalinism. (The closest is the acknowledgement of the role the USSR under Stalin played as an ally against the Nazis.) It does argue that 1984 misses the internal instability of totalitarianisms like Stalinism, which besame evident after 1984 was written. > His critique of the science fiction, that screens which watch you back is a poor prediction (because how on Earth could Google watch people at scale?!) is particularly hilarious, if a bit sad. The critique isn't of screens that watch you back, but of the failure of imagination of Orwell envisioning only screens by which a human watches you in real time rather than one that does so by some automated, scalable means.
- inglor_cz 6y ago"It does argue that 1984 misses the internal instability of totalitarianisms like Stalinism, which besame evident after 1984 was written." Instability compared to what? Stalin's USSR survived major natural disasters and wars, expanded its territory and the leader died in office. Multiple democracies in contemporary Europe were destroyed from the same influences. Only UK, Sweden and Switzerland could be said to be at least as stable as Stalinist USSR. I despise and hate Stalin, but his regime was fairly stable compared to contemporaries.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Instability compared to what? Instability compared to what Asimov sees as Orwell's perspective that Stalinism is impervious to internal erosion (including death of the leader.)
- watwut 6y agoCommunism survived Stalin death untouch. In fact, it became more stable as Stalin was driver of instability at the top.
- 6y ago
- Talanes 6y agoHe snidely denigrates socialism and communism constantly throughout. Is anything that talks about communism with any nuance apologism?
- mrob 6y ago"One person cannot watch more than one person in full concentration, and can only do so for a comparatively short time before attention begins to wander. ... Consequently, the system of oppression by two-way television simply will not work." I find it strange that a widely read author with a known interest in history had apparently never heard of the panopticon. Orwell outright states that the telescreens work on the same principle: "There was of course no way of knowing whether you were being watched at any given moment. ... You had to live—did live, from habit that became instinct—in the assumption that every sound you made was overheard, and, except in darkness, every movement scrutinized."
- inglor_cz 6y agoSounds like Twitter. Except that Orwellian tech did not have the ability to search your actions back ten years ago. At least the Orwellian invisible guards were paid employees. On contemporary Internet, there is no shortage of unpaid volunteers digging in other people's activity just for the thrill of getting someone punished. The difference is that the state apparatus may run out of money; the USSR did. You never run of enthusiastic volunteers, as long as you reward their actions with what they want, in this case, a public spectacle of a virtual guillotine.
- hobby-coder-guy 6y agoDoesn’t sound like Twitter at all.
- chongli 6y agoThere were plenty of enthusiastic volunteers in 1984. Children in the story were trained as spies and rewarded for denouncing their parents. Friends denounced friends. Orwell understood that in order to create an atmosphere of total oppression there could be no loyalty between anyone. This is why the party criminalizes sex for pleasure. It’s the recognition that the loyalty within families is the greatest threat to the totalitarian state. The government in Brave New World recognizes that as well but seeks to eliminate the threat by other means (taboo and superficial pleasure).
- inglor_cz 6y agoI grew up behind the Iron Curtain. The entire Orwell canon was banned, of course, but you could still hear it on BBC broadcast from abroad (the authorities tried to jam the signal, with various levels of success). We liked 1984. Forbidden fruit tastes the best, but it also spoke to us. Those empty slogans and lingering fear of the Secret Police did translate fairly well into real life behind the Curtain.
- canjobear 6y ago> Orwell was unable to conceive of computers or robots, or he would have placed everyone under non-human surveillance. Our own computers to some extent do this in the IRS, in credit files, and so on, but that does not take us towards 1984, except in fevered imaginations. Computers and tyranny do not necessarily go hand in hand. Tyrannies have worked very well without computers (consider the Nazis) and the most computerised nations in today's world are also the least tyrannical. I'd go with Orwell over Asimov as far as predictions of the future...
- jokethrowaway 6y agoWhen I think of Orwell I group him together with Ray Bradbury (Fahrenheit_451) and Ayn Rand (Cloud Atlas) Great ideas, great concept, definitely food for thought - but painful to read. Narrative is a different art.
- grzm 6y ago> "Ayn Rand (Cloud Atlas)" Cloud Atlas is David Mitchell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_Atlas_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_Atlas_(novel) I suspect you mean Atlas Shrugged. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_Shrugged https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_Shrugged (And now I've got Tom Hanks as Hank Reardon in my head. Didn't see that coming.)
- jokethrowaway 6y agoIndeed, I meant Atlas Shrugged, thanks for the correction!