5 ms·
Maybe it would help if someone on the internet condescendingly pointed out to them that the first amendment doesn't apply to private platforms. I mean I know th
by karaterobot 6y ago
Maybe it would help if someone on the internet condescendingly pointed out to them that the first amendment doesn't apply to private platforms. I mean I know that's not what they're talking about at all, but it's what always seems to happen in these discussions.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoAt what point do these massive corporations effectively become a government? They govern what you can say, think and buy.
- Grimm1 6y agoI don't want businesses to be forced to do business with people it doesn't want to there are many avenues to address grievances with that already. For instance in this case, the Trump admin can sue and have the concern addressed in court. No business in the world can currently stand up to a government that wants to curtail it by the way.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoThis is not just "we don't want to do business with you". This is "we don't you want to have a platform anywhere". I start caring when several tech monopolies co-ordinate to take down alternative platforms like parler.
- zepto 6y agoParler can be sideloaded on Android.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoWhat happens when Amazon drops them from AWS?
- zadokshi 6y ago> "I don't want businesses to be forced to do business with people it doesn't want to " But we are not talking about forcing general businesses doing business with general people. We are taking about allowing publicly elected representatives of the people having a voice on the platform that the majority of the country uses for communication. You are generalising, then building your argument on the generalisation.
- zepto 6y agoThe generalization is a good principle to uphold, wouldn’t you say? Should newspapers be forced to publish the presidents tweets for those who are not on Twitter?
- Grimm1 6y agoSo? Hold a press conference or something. These platforms aren't even close to the only communication tool they can use why should one tool be forced to suffer them. My life is certainly better without seeing Trump's asinine and sometimes dangerous commentary on Twitter if I want it I'll go check my NewsNation app. This right here is part of the problem. It's the government they can post commentary on a us.gov twitter clone or blog or whatever. I don't even agree that outside of government funds we should provide special treatment for our elected officials. We certainly have the resources to establish any communication tool they could possibly conceive of outside of private business.
- tomatotomato37 6y agoWhen they start getting serious anti-trust lawsuits brought against them seems a good point. I feel like that's something that's been forgetten I this situation, we aren't talking about normal companies, we are talking about companies that are so freaking big that the government has to go and actively prune them to prevent them from crippling their own markets.
- neogodless 6y agohttps://www.dictionary.com/browse/government https://www.dictionary.com/browse/government > the political direction and control exercised over the actions of the members, citizens, or inhabitants of communities, societies, and states; direction of the affairs of a state, community, etc.; political administration > the form or system of rule by which a state, community, etc., is governed Social media corporations influence what they'll allow to be said through their platform, and by means of their algorithms and the effects it has on your feeds and advertisements, they influence what you think and buy. They do not rule your actions. They do not control laws, enforcement, government spending and military command. Certainly at the size and wealth of many corporations, they do heavily influence legislation though, and that certainly is worth examining. But individuals have a choice whether or not to use social media. I'm just one person: I use Instagram but only follow a few people that post photos I like (I'll unfollow if a lot of posts diverge from photography), I avoid Facebook feeds completely and mostly avoid Twitter although the past few days have been an exception - I only visit one or two tech-related subreddits. This is just right now at a moment in time. Five years ago I would've said I use Facebook daily and Twitter extremely rarely and what is Reddit, and I've posted a few photos on Instagram but it doesn't really interest me. It's always a shifting landscape. (I once had a Google+ profile...)
- karaterobot 6y agoWhen other governments recognize you as a government, then whatever else is true about you, you are a government. Usually this is because you have a military with certain capabilities, but I guess in this new century there could be other options, like money or information.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> At what point do these massive corporations effectively become a government? When they exercise a monopoly on the legitimate use of force within some geographic domain. > They govern what you can say, think and buy. No, they don't. They govern what can be published and sold on their platforms, which aren't the exclusive venues for sale or publishing.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoI love how this is 100% a liability issue and everyone jumps to the First Amendment like automatons. Twitter and Facebook are each gonna blow hundreds of millions of dollars dealing with litigation from the fallout of the other day. They have zero obligation to host insane seditious rhetoric or the people who have encouraged it.
- giantg2 6y agoIs it a liability issue? Section 230?
- MisterBastahrd 6y ago(2)Civil liability No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be held liable on account of— (A)any action voluntarily taken in good faith to restrict access to or availability of material that the provider or user considers to be obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable, whether or not such material is constitutionally protected; or (B)any action taken to enable or make available to information content providers or others the technical means to restrict access to material described in paragraph (1).[1] Section 230 doesn't protect you from everything. It is a band aid. Specifically, it says that you have to show that you have tried to prevent malevolent content in good faith. You can't just let it sit there and fester on your servers and pretend that you're covered. Section 230 essentially requires moderation of content. They knew what was going on. They let it happen anyway. They are liable. They don't want to be liable again.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Specifically, it says that you have to show that you have tried to prevent malevolent content in good faith. No, it doesn't, for the type of liability for hosted content, rather than its removal/restriction, that it applies to at all. > You can't just let it sit there and fester on your servers and pretend that you're covered. Yes, you can. 230 has more than one area of protection. Two of them are: (1) You (as a service provider or another user) aren't liable as a publisher for user-generated content that you aren't the origin of. 47 USC Sec. 230(c)(1) (2) As a provider, you also aren't liable for good faith efforts to restrict access to offensive content or enable content providers the ability to restrict access to offensive content. 46 USC Sec 230(c)(2) But, notably, Section 230 doesn't apply to criminal liability at all, and there is a real risk of criminal liability under the law against material support for terrorism for knowingly providing any service that you know is supporting some of the acts that have occurred or which have been reported to be now being publicly planned on social media platforms.