4 ms·
The man literally has a press office and a press staff. There are any number of outlets who will cling to his every word in order to praise or criticize it. I
by gumby 6y ago
The man literally has a press office and a press staff. There are any number of outlets who will cling to his every word in order to praise or criticize it.
I don't use twitter and seem to learn what is said.
It is difficult to see what the problem is.
- mech422 6y agoI don't do social media at all (well, HN and imgur) and unfortunately, still hear it all. Crap is all over the news, its here on HN...it's everywhere. Also, I tend to think a lot of this has to do with avoiding wrongful death suits for not policing their platforms.. edit: formatting, don't post before coffee
- ballenf 6y agoThat was kind of the point of the article — the precedent once set is hard to limit to those with press offices. There was no argument with the particular action in this case.
- jmull 6y agoI wonder what the precedent is supposed be here? Twitter and facebook have been banning people all along, for all kinds of reasons. I thought the precedent set for Trump was the high level of leeway given to a government leader compared to regular people. I think if he weren’t the President he would have had more tweets removed and been suspended earlier and more often.
- dwpdwpdwpdwpdwp 6y agoWere any laws broken by Twitter? Don’t businesses in the US have nearly every right to arbitrarily deny service to people (with a few exceptions when it’s explicitly denying on the basis of race, etc.)? Twitter literally didn’t exist 15 years ago. How can a lack of access to Twitter be an an infringement on free speech then?
- iijlasdjkfj 6y agoThe internet literally didn't exist 50 years ago. How can a lack of access to internet be an infringement on free speech then? Television literally didn't exist 100 years ago. How can a lack of access to television be an infringement of free speech then? Written language literally didn't exist ~5000 years ago. How can a lack of access to written language be an infringement of free speech then?
- CharlesW 6y ago> The internet literally didn't exist 50 years ago. How can a lack of access to internet be an infringement on free speech then? So the 14% of households with school-aged children in the United States without internet access don't have free speech? https://www.ntia.doc.gov/blog/2018/digital-divide-among-school-age-children-narrows-millions-still-lack-internet-connections https://www.ntia.doc.gov/blog/2018/digital-divide-among-scho...
- iijlasdjkfj 6y agoWell CharlesW, if you were a member of those 14% of households without internet access could you have written your comment on HN sharing your viewpoint with other readers of HN?
- jwalton 6y ago> Were any laws broken by Twitter? Yes, but not the ones you think. The FAANG companies are basically all illegal monopolies.
- verroq 6y agoYes but do you? When Twitter suspends your speech do you have a press office to get your word out? If they dare to do it to the president you think they have any reservations about censoring anyone else?
- gameswithgo 6y agoyes, because if they censor too much then parler or any other startup can easily rise up and compete. the barrier to entry is very very low here if there are pissed off users ready to flee. parler being a prime example
- verroq 6y agoSure looks anti-competitive when Parler is deleted from all the app stores now doesn’t it? And we have people vocally calling for Cloudflare and AWS to deny them hosting services.
- zadokshi 6y agoNo, Apple is trying to ban the alternative product that has been created.
- true_religion 6y agoParler has banned all liberal, communist, and eco friendly speech. It’s an alternative to Twitter but it got there by being more restrictive.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dgellow 6y agoThat's literally what is said in the article.
- rhino369 6y agoThe problem isn't what happens when tech companies censor a very power man. It's that if they can censor a very power man, then there is no bounds on what they can and will do for less powerful people. For social networks, the root of the problem is their quasi-monopoly status. We wouldn't accept Comcast deplatforming people. It's a bad idea to set policy based on the worst examples. I can't see any harm in kicking Trump off twitter. He was basically begging for it. But should Trump's extreme actions be used to justify banning BLM protests because they sometimes turn violent? How about Hong Kong demonstrations? Didn't they storm a legislature? How about WSJ? They print people who believe in election fraud. It's like using 9-11 to set all terrorism policy. IMO--these actions should be an "emergency only" policy rather than Big Tech deciding it needs to police what we all hear and think. It's really not clear which its going to be.
- acdha 6y agoThe way you’re using “censor” doesn’t accurately describe the situation. It evokes images of people being sent to the gulag for sharing samizdat but he’s not exactly silenced when he can have full coverage by the international media any time he chooses, and Trump’s accounts were not disabled for spreading conservative ideas but for inciting deadly violence. A private company exercising its rights under the contract he voluntarily made with them does not seem like something conservatives should be complaining about.
- rhino369 6y agoI strongly dispute that censor evokes gulags. A person of ordinary education would understand the Hollywood Blacklists of the 50's as censorship. It's a quintessential example of censorship. To extent you want to redefine censorship as only government actions, there is a pretty plausible argument that elements of the US government pushed for this. https://www.politico.com/story/2018/03/19/angry-democrats-facebook-424456 https://www.politico.com/story/2018/03/19/angry-democrats-fa... It might not be a coincidence that Big Tech waited until Trumps defeat looked certain to finally start censoring his posts in Oct 2020. They were probably afraid of what a Democratic DOJ would do. Democrats have blamed Trump's win on big tech for years.
- throw0101a 6y ago> It is difficult to see what the problem is. No one seems to be angry that Rubert Murdoch, owner of Fox News, gets to decide who is a host/anchor and who isn't, who is a guest that is interviewed and who isn't, who goes on air and who doesn't, etc. If Fox New (and CNN, OANN, etc) get to decide who to broadcast or not, I'm not sure what's so special about Twitter as a platform deciding as well. Arguing the contra: if Twitter "must" allow Trump, shouldn't Fox News "have to" allow (e.g.) Noam Chomsky to have his own show?