6 ms·
Some Tesla Model 3 rear windows shatter spontaneously
- jibcage 6y agoFrom my armchair, it sounds like the glass manufacturing might be rushed. How frequent is this a problem with other car manufacturers?
- tsomctl 6y agoI'm sitting in an office chair, not an armchair, but I'm thinking the steel frame it was glued to flexed. The inside pressure theory doesn't make sense. Modern cars are well sealed, but you still have flaps at the back of the car to let air out, and they are loose enough to let air in.
- nexuist 6y agoMight be interesting to see if this phenomenon applies to Model X and S, as they should theoretically be totally sealed to enable the Bioweapon Defense Mode.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> they should theoretically be totally sealed to enable the Bioweapon Defense Mode. Isn't bioweapon defense mode HEPA filter plus overpressure, not a totally sealed cabin?
- ericd 6y agoNot an expert, but my understanding is that tempered safety glass (which the rear/side windows are made of, vs laminated like windshields) is under a lot of internal pressure/strain. And that that's one of the reasons that when it goes, it really goes.
- mnd999 6y agoSeems unlikely Tesla make their own glass, probably just buy it from the same place other manufacturers do.
- guerby 6y agoTesla glass is made by Saint-Gobain: https://electrek.co/2019/09/26/tesla-model-3-body-in-white-gigafactory-3-production-start-oct-14/ https://electrek.co/2019/09/26/tesla-model-3-body-in-white-g... "Saint-Gobain, a long-term glass supplier for Tesla, established a factory in the Lingang industrial zone to supply Tesla for the Chinese-made Model 3 vehicles and it plans to start mass production on October 14 to match Tesla. Ma Jun, head of Saint-Gobain Sekurit’s Lingang factory, commented: (...)" Also found in the USA: https://www.linkedin.com/in/stephanvoisin/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/stephanvoisin/ "Stéphan Voisin Business Director TESLA at Saint-Gobain Sekurit Los Angeles Metropolitan Area"
- reportingsjr 6y agoIt wasn't common until the last few years according to sources in other comments here. Since 2016 it has become more common in a variety of brands.
- glaberficken 6y agoIs that snow in the background? Probably a temperature thing? (lack of enough testing in low temperatures?) Can be that the glass is fine but that the frame surrounding the glass is contracting too much or twisting in the "wrong" direction when cooled. Causing the glass to shatter.
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoAlso my thoughts are about temps differences between inside and outside, or the window was getting very cold for the first time, the tolerances were too tight and krack... it's a supposition.
- jdxcode 6y agoConsidering the other video has the reflection of a palm tree I'd guess it's not a significant contributor.
- mdorazio 6y agoThis happens to non-Tesla cars as well. My friend's Ford Fusion side window randomly shattered without an impact when we were driving on the freeway. The glass repair guy that replaced it wasn't even surprised.
- bwanab 6y agoWhen it happens to Tesla, it’s news. Otherwise, it isn’t.
- merlinscholz 6y agoA one-off case isn't news. If it happens repeatedly to the same model, then it is news
- falcolas 6y ago> When it happens to Tesla, it's defended [by Tesla's volunteer PR department]. Otherwise, it's not. Feels slightly more accurate.
- FireBeyond 6y agoIf it happens regularly, it leads to a recall, and lawsuits, class actions (see link to many of these, above) Or if it happens to Tesla, it's "normal", "expected" and probably "the shorts".
- jdxcode 6y agoWhy would a glass repair guy be surprised about broken glass? I know the point here is that it was spontaneous, but if anyone is regularly hearing about spontaneous breakages it would be the people repairing them.
- approxim8ion 6y agoI've noticed that Tesla tends to get away with a lot of QC issues and lack of some creature comforts because it allows people to feel like they are part of "the future", but also maybe because the ride/drive experience is perhaps good enough to gloss over any imperfections.
- danhak 6y agoMore to do with the fact that Tesla is under a microscope and QC issues and mishaps with other automakers are usually not newsworthy.
- carlhjerpe 6y agoI've never heard of the kind of issues people have with Teslas before, two of my bosses had Model X's that needed extensive repairs after delivery because mostly everything was misaligned. It's not that theyre under a microscope, It's that the quality is worse than many other brands while being valued like they are. Elon said himself the hard part was mass manufacturing the damn things, and they're clearly failing to do so properly.
- cptskippy 6y ago> It's that the quality is worse than many other brands while being valued like they are. It's an interesting situation certainly. You hear a lot of people comparing Teslas to Audis and BMWs to point out how poor their paint is, awful panel gaps, and how lacking their interiors are, but I've never heard anyone compare powertrain reliability or quality. The value of a Tesla comes form the advanced telematics and EV powertrain, the later of which is more expensive to produce than what's found in an Audi or BMW. In terms of how well the interiors hold up over time, I don't think that any of them hold up any better or worse. My 2+ year old Model 3 looks just as nice inside as the day I got it, I'd say the same of my friend's BMW 5 Series that was about 2 years old when she sold it. In terms of maintenance costs, a Tesla requires maintenance ever 2 years at around $150 a visit. BMWs typically get free service for the first 3 years, but after that you're looking at something like $250 every 5000. So if you're expecting to keep your car for more than 3 years there's certainly value in that respect. The high reliability and low maintenance costs of Teslas also increase their resale value compared to other vehicles. Personally, I find the interiors or Audis and BMWs to be a lot of pomp and circumstance to help their owners justify the price. There's a lot of lights, noise, and different material finishes to make them look impressive but is that better? I don't think so.
- einarfd 6y agoI have a Model 3 where the rear window developed cracks and the integrated heating in it stopped working. Tesla exchanged it under warranty, and I haven't had any problems with the new one. I'm not an expert, but my impressions is that these things happens from time to time. Safety glass doesn't like to be under tension and if you mess up the mounting of it, and do that, it can crack or break.
- fergie 6y agoSpontaneous shattering of safety glass is more common that you might think: https://www.google.com/search?q=shower+door+spontaneously+shatter https://www.google.com/search?q=shower+door+spontaneously+sh...
- tomcam 6y agoI'll be damned. Happened in my house a couple years ago and I realize now I had unconsciously blamed my kid who was taking a shower at the time. Thank you.
- Closi 6y agoThe last post on Tesla quality had people stating that real consumers didn’t care about the quality issues and it was mostly car snobs whining about panel gaps. I expect similar quotes in here about how it’s totally normal for glass to shatter within 2 minutes of delivery. Before everyone else says it - no Tesla won’t make its own glass - but it will specify it and should be QC testing it. Maybe glass occasionally does the same for other vendors, but this does seem to be another data point in the weekly series of ‘Embarrassing QC issue that gets defended’.
- FireBeyond 6y agoJust look at the title of one of the references linked in the article: > Owner Says Tesla Model 3 Window Shattered By Itself, Accused Of FUD I'm sure she was short $TSLA ...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shiftpgdn 6y agoIt /is/ totally normal for large sheets of safety glass to shatter. Ive owned lots of enthusiast cars and in the enthusiast pickup truck world it's completely normal to have your rear glass or sunroof explode. I think people get so wound up about this because they've driven budget cars their whole life and a Tesla is their first big purchase and don't have any contextual understanding of advanced car parts going wrong.
- cosmodisk 6y agoHow is this normal? In my 36 years I've never heard of anyone ever mentioning this happening to them,even though people have gone through multiple cars,etc. Is that a thing with the American cars?
- jdxcode 6y agoOf course it's not normal. Well, unless you park on the street in the mission district.
- WalterBright 6y agoI was driving my Mustang one day when the windshield suddenly shattered. Turns out some kid threw a brick at it.
- primitivesuave 6y agoHopefully you intervened on that kid before he starts throwing things off highway overpasses. https://abcnews.go.com/US/teen-threw-rock-off-highway-overpass-killing-man/story?id=66631347 https://abcnews.go.com/US/teen-threw-rock-off-highway-overpa...
- WalterBright 6y agoI called the cops, but it was night and there was no way.
- Hamuko 6y agoThere was recently a local news story where someone threw a log at a car from an overpass. Nasty work. https://www.iltalehti.fi/kotimaa/a/59ccdab0-e9aa-486e-88da-9366af16afbb https://www.iltalehti.fi/kotimaa/a/59ccdab0-e9aa-486e-88da-9...
- syspec 6y agoThe power of Elon Musk is having had convinced people these are high quality luxury cars even through a constant stream of issues such as this, cars catching on fire, the makeshift Home Depot repaired before being shipped out issue, or the random misalignment issues, etc
- FireBeyond 6y ago> these are high quality luxury cars Maybe they've got better. But in 2017 I spend a good amount of time in a Model S, and the impression I got was distinctly "high tech", but not "luxury". The dash was more flimsy, creaky than my old Altima, the fit and finishings were similar, and even my entry level Audi blew past it in interior quality and refinement.
- aejnsn 6y agoNot news. Tempered glass pops all the time. Its purpose and manufacturing process are indicative as to why this happens.
- specialp 6y ago"Although the video is somewhat grainy, the fact that they burst outward, rather than inward, would seem to suggest that the inciting force wasn’t a pebble or other object striking the window from outside." That is actually not true with vehicle windows. They often are tempered and layered so they usually pop back with the force of getting something hit and blast out. Not saying this isn't spontaneous but my experience with car windows breaking is most of the glass ends up on the outside when struck from the outside.
- jhayward 6y agoGuess what? Ford F-150 rear windows shatter spontaneously too. It's a known problem, truck owners hope it happens before the warranty runs out because otherwise they're on the hook for a $1000 replacement. Why is this on HN?
- FireBeyond 6y agoBecause with the F-150 there's recalls, a class action, and a lawsuit around that exact issue. With Tesla? There's "FUD!", "this is normal", "to be expected from time to time", "overblown issue".
- jhayward 6y agoI have a 2018 F-150. There are no class actions or recalls related to the rear window that I can find via Google or the NHTSA recall registry. Can you provide the information you describe above?
- nabilhat 6y agoWhen door windows (that go up and down) randomly pop it's typically a regulator that's gone out of alignment. Sometimes one side of the regulator has jumped off track, or one side gets sticky and hangs up. The whole raising and lowering the window mechanism provides lots of opportunity to put a kink in some tempered glass - especially when that window is designed to fit tightly to shut out wind noise or improve aerodynamics. A quick search suggests that Tesla's had intermittent window regulator problems in the model 3 and others, and there sure are a lot of ads for replacement/rebuilt Model 3 rear door window regulators.
- gxqoz 6y agoCoincidentally, today I read an interesting article on the Gatwick drone scare that contained this anecdote: "In April 1954, a strange phenomenon swept across the town of Bellingham, Seattle, and other communities in Washington state. People began to observe “windshield pits” on their cars – minor damage that, when magnified, can look like a tiny crater in the surface of the glass, usually caused by sand or other small debris colliding with the windscreen at high speed. As the phenomenon was reported in the press, more people noticed marks and chips on their screens. A few weeks before the sightings began, the US had exploded a huge hydrogen bomb in the Pacific Ocean, and many blamed these nuclear tests. Others believed a nearby navy communication tower was warping the glass. Residents panicked. By 15 April, almost 3,000 windscreens had been affected, and the mayor asked for assistance from President Eisenhower. Today, the Seattle windshield pitting epidemic is often cited as an example of mass panic, in which people attributed a sinister cause to something that had been there, unnoticed, all along. Two days after the appeal to the president, Seattle police issued a statement saying that the pitting epidemic was “95% public hysteria”. Sightings suddenly stopped." https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/dec/01/the-mystery-of-the-gatwick-drone https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/dec/01/the-mystery-...