20 ms·
To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-and-dumps (2018)
- ipnon 6y agoThis seems like a weak paper on the face of it, especially considering it is coming from a criminal justice journal and not a quantitative finance journal. The existence of pump and dumps, I would say, is obvious, in and out of crypto. But this paper fails by lacking a method to confidently detect pump and dump schemes. They successfully detect 2 of 4 schemes, no better than a coin toss. You might say this is better than nothing, but 50% is not really enough to either protect or extend your portfolio in the face of an impending pump and dump. Assuredly there are many crypto hedge funds able to predict pump and dumps with much higher accuracy, but they are keeping the methods to themselves to protect their intellectual property.
- dgellow 6y agoFor a better approach, you can check this paper from 2020: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2005.06610.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2005.06610.pdf. Quote from the paper: > Not only our performances are considerably better than theirs, we score 93.1% of precision and 91.4% recall against their 50.1% precision and 75.0% recall, but our detector is also faster.
- sosuke 6y agoMakes me wonder what they would say about the current market.
- arcticbull 6y agoWell, if it found a pump and dump it would say "call the SEC." Thing is, the stock market may be erratic on smaller timescales but it is a legitimate and fair place to trade, and people roughly speaking all have access to the same information when making those trades. Speculative mania is not a pump and dump. It's poor decision making, and generally speaking, that's not illegal. On the other hand, if I start a stable coin, let's call it Anchor. Then I get a bunch of un-banked exchanges to use it in lieu of dollars because they can't get legitimate banking and don't want to bother with AML, KYC, the sanctions list or enabling international terrorism. I then start printing 750 million totally un-backed Anchors per day. I then use them to buy Bitcoin to drive the price up parabolically. I then sell all my Bitcoin for dollars to the most recent institutional clowns invested, and flee from the island I currently reside on to a different island. That's crime.
- rglullis 6y agoStarted reading a comment full of false equivalences and trying to put all projects and people working on crypto as criminals and yes, of course it is the guy with the inappropriate username. I am not going to defend Tether, I truly wish they disappeared into a ball of fire and took every crook with them. However, you could avoid the hyperbole. There are ~14 billion USDT minted, and BTC alone is going for a market cap of 500bi. The top 3 "serious" exchanges are all averaging $1bi+ in daily volume (and if you believe they are doing wash trading, Uniswap alone is in the same ballpark and wash trading there would be very costly). Tether is bad, but to think they are able to prop BTC (and crypto in general) to this bubble is delusional. Also, it's interesting how you downplay the fact that the Fed printed 22% of the dollars in circulation in 2020 alone with the majority of it destined to bail out banks and surely to end up under control of Wall Street. Also interesting how you seem to be so bothered by the lack of KYC/AML of some exchanges and pull the "enabling terrorism" card, yet you see no problem in the Stimulus Bill having 10 million dollars for Pakistan. Perhaps if the crypto projects start saying that the funds are going to gender studies your worries will be eased?
- arcticbull 6y agoI didn't realize a synonym for a muskox was an inappropriate name lol. Just wait till you hear what other animals are named! For your reference I've attached a photo of the eponymous magnificent beast in question [0]. There are ~14 billion USDT minted, and BTC alone is going for a market cap of 500bi. $14B my dude, that information is stale as all heck. They're printing $700 million dollars worth per day right now. Their market cap just reached $24B. Remember just days ago when microstrat announced a blockbuster $400M investment? Tether prints that every 12 hours. See the way market cap works is you only have to control the most recent trade to set the market cap. That means literally nothing. The old trope goes if you print 1 trillion of your own crypto and sell it to a buddy for $1, that's a $1T market cap. $24B of cash, with $700M new printed every single day buying up Bitcoin is absolutely enough to control the price. That's simple economics, and you can find an explanation anywhere. I can of course provide you with an article if you find yourself unable to obtain one. > Also, it's interesting how you downplay the fact that the Fed printed 22% of the dollars in circulation in 2020 alone with the majority of it destined to bail out banks and surely to end up under control of Wall Street. This is utterly irrelevant. The inflation rate is trending around 2% per annum. If that goes up, they'll print less or claw back more. Supply is not the only factor in the determination of inflation, velocity of money is critical. I suggest you learn more about the money supply before trying to reinvent it. In fact if we pretend for a moment that bitcoin is a currency, you can see that while the supply is flat-ish, the price is skyrocketing. This is massively deflationary for a currency, and this is in fact, in part, due to a reduction in velocity of money (aka HODL BRUH). > Perhaps if the crypto projects start saying that the funds are going to gender studies your worries will be eased? I have no idea where you're going with that and I won't be following you. This has nothing to do with social policy and everything to do with the North Korean government collecting hundreds of millions of dollars to fund their nuclear weapons program. [0] https://www.alaskaphotographics.com/alaska-photo-articles/muskox-photos/ https://www.alaskaphotographics.com/alaska-photo-articles/mu...
- dorkwood 6y ago> They successfully detect 2 of 4 schemes, no better than a coin toss. How would you go about detecting a pump and dump scheme by flipping a coin?
- mckirk 6y agoThat's simple! You think "this is probably a pump-and-dump", then flip a coin and go post about it on Twitter if it comes up heads.
- alexpetralia 6y ago1. Assign pump-and-dump scheme to heads 2. Flip coin 3. Evaluate results
- dorkwood 6y agoKind of seems like you detected it at step 1.
- ethn 6y ago50% is a bit better than you think. If you were to do a coin toss on each as a basis of determination you would only have a 25% chance of getting 2 correct. As n-schemes becomes larger, the coin toss does much worse in respect to the Bayesian probability.
- fsdfgsfsdfsdfsd 6y agoBut they were detecting 2 out of 4, not 2 out of 2. I think you are incorrect.
- LukeShu 6y agoI think they're both incorrect. They ran the model on historical data. Of 4 a priori known P&Ds, the model detected 2 of them. To say that they've got accuracy of a 50% or "no better than a coin toss", ignores all of the non-P&D events that it correctly didn't identify as a P&D. If you did a coin toss, you would flip the coin much more than 4 times.
- fsdfgsfsdfsdfsd 6y agoTrue
- rossdavidh 6y agoYou really would also want to have some sort of loss function, or at the very least a general idea of whether you most need to avoid false positives or false negatives. If it was most important to avoid incorrectly saying it's NOT a P&D, then this is not good performance. If you need it to nearly always avoid saying something which is not a P&D (and thus might be a great investment opportunity), but given that you want to avoid as many as you can, 50% might be good.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- analyst74 6y ago
- boublepop 6y ago> They successfully detect 2 of 4 schemes, no better than a coin toss. Let’s be real here if I developed an indicator that identified murderers and I showed you that out of the last 4 murders happened in US, I identified 2 of them using this identifier, would you say that I did no better than a coin toss? There is a lot more to this than just going yes/no when presented after the fact with a situation that you feel that you know for sure is a pump-and-dump.
- Calamity 6y agoThe thing that has surprised me the most with the current crypto-craze is the number of people that I consider generally quite rational/thoughtful who could nonetheless not resist the temptation to jump onto the bandwagon. I'm left thinking that they must know what they're doing and that they simply enjoy the thrill of a game of musical chairs.
- randomopining 6y agoIt’s a deflationary store of value, it does make sense to invest some into it.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoHello there, retard. Tell us what you’ve learned throughout all the research you’ve done on Tether. Oh, nothing? Kill yourself.
- HarryHirsch 6y agostore of value The value comes from being able to manipulate the price, one would suppose.
- fsdfgsfsdfsdfsd 6y agoHow can you manipulate the price? I suppose there are now some whales, including governments that seized BTC from criminals, that could induce a crash by selling thousands of BTC within a short frame of time. But that may be true for many stocks as well.
- strathmeyer 6y agoThe more dumb stuff people say about Bitcoin, the more room you know it has to rise.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoWhy is the comment dumb?
- dgellow 6y agoIf people are interested in the topic, a more recent paper from 2020 is "Pump and Dumps in the Bitcoin Era: Real Time Detection of Cryptocurrency Market Manipulations", available at https://arxiv.org/pdf/2005.06610.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2005.06610.pdf. The researchers got some very good results (their detection tools has a precision of 93.1% with 91.4% recall), and made their data set publicly available on github.
- mistrial9 6y ago.. reading through this paper, the researchers apparently listened in to, and joined, groups on chat media that were called pump and dump `in their names`, and advertised advances and payout by the measured number of others they bring in to the groups !! So its not that hard to detect that ! however, the research actually watches transactions in real time, and predicts events in real time, which is slightly different to my ear.. This paper cites ".. to the moon" as published in Crime Science journal.. and uses it as a baseline to show performance characteristics of their own filters. The authors claim various measureable advances in their filters.
- geraldbauer 6y agoFor a best of crypto quotes incl. pumping up the gigantic Bitcoin ponzi, see https://github.com/openblockchains/crypto-quotes https://github.com/openblockchains/crypto-quotes SCAM ALERT! SCAM ALERT! SCAM ALERT! > The U.S. Dollar is no longer a reliable store of value. Cameron and I (Winklevoss Twins Capital) make the case for $500 000 Bitcoin. Number go up! To the moon! > When Elon Musk puts the Tesla balance sheet into Bitcoin, we'll have to change the Bitcoin rallying cry from "to the moon!" to "to Mars!" -- Tyler Winklevoss, Bitcoin Billionaire or > There are 3.5 billion smart phones on the planet. All of them can hold bitcoin. None of them can hold gold. Bitcoin is the future. Number go up! To the moon! -- Cameron Winklevoss, Bitcoin Billionaire Given the challenge of how to invest $600 million in treasury reserves, after a lifetime of experience and months of analysis, I decided on an allocation of 100% Bitcoin, 0% Bonds, 0% Stocks, 0% Real Estate, 0% Gold. Seems rational to me. Number go up! To the moon! -- Michael Saylor, Business Intelligence Billionaire and on on.
- classified 6y agoBernie Madoff went to jail when he couldn't sustain his scam any longer. When the crypto bubble pops, the prison-as-a-service industry might experience a boom since they won't have enough cells to house all the scamsters.
- bagels 6y agoIs there a market for put options on bitcoins?
- geraldbauer 6y agoA little to the moon gem from the best of crypto quotes [1] via SEC Investor Education: > New Year's Financial Resolution: Ponzi scheme "red flags" - Avoid too-good-to-be-true "investments" with claims like: - "To the moon! To the mars!" - "Number go up!" - "Yearly return of 300+% in 2020!" - "Could quadruple in 2021 and rally to $100,000!" [1] https://github.com/openblockchains/crypto-quotes#sec-investor-education https://github.com/openblockchains/crypto-quotes#sec-investo...
- f430 6y agoPaul Le Roux as awful as he is for the stuff he has done, is truly a rare breed. Built E4M, a prototype to Truecrypt, was his first cryptographic software he put out. Using his knowledge, he was able to catapult himself to the lucrative international drug/weapon smuggling market. Finally, the Australian fellow who claimed he was Satoshi has been trying to unlock several million bitcoins from genesis that supposedly belonged to Paul before his capture and incarceration. If you follow this theory, essentially a money laundering drug lord coded the bitcoin, for unknown purpose but we can probably take a guess. Bitcoin's biggest utility isn't for small individual traders rather it is a vehicle for laundering massive amounts of money. Snuff films with children, drugs, humans, and other depraved ways of making money are the entirety of bitcoins usage. source: https://news.bitcoin.com/the-many-facts-pointing-to-paul-le-roux-being-satoshi-nakamoto/ https://news.bitcoin.com/the-many-facts-pointing-to-paul-le-...
- dgellow 6y agoHow is that relevant to the shared article?
- ur-whale 6y ago>essentially a money laundering drug lord coded the bitcoin, To quote Hitchens: "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence and what can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence".
- f430 6y agoWe have coincidental evidence at best but until Paul is released and he can prove his identity with his private key of course Hitchens is going to be unhappy. But the lack of evidence simply isn't enough to suggest he isn't the creator. You can use whatever academic term to justify against this.
- ur-whale 6y agoI posit the existence of a giant duck living on Uranus. The lack of evidence to the contrary simply isn't enough to suggest that it isn't the case.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoStep 1: Open coinmarketcap.com Step 2: It's all of them. This system is quick, easy and 100% effective.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoBitcoin itself is currently undergoing something not completely dissimilar to a pump-and-dump. Because of the difficulty of transacting USD for cryptocurrency purposes, a pegged currency called “Tethers”, specifically USDT, is being used as a substitute. It's supposed to be backed 1:1 by USD reserves, but it's clear at this point that the amount of USD reserves do not match the number of USDT in circulation and they're just printing money to buy BTC. The markets using real USD are then matching the USDT price and this allows the printers to cash out. Once regulators strike, many investors will realise they have a lot of useless paper money (USDT) and suddenly much less valuable BTC. Or so many allege, at least: https://amycastor.com/2020/11/21/are-pixie-fairies-behind-bitcoins-latest-bubble/ https://amycastor.com/2020/11/21/are-pixie-fairies-behind-bi...
- woah 6y agoTether definitely seems very fishy, but they've been around for a pretty long time. People were saying this exact thing in the 2017 bull market but then there was a savage bear market the next year (~10x BTC price drop) and Tether is still fine. What is the event that will reveal that the emperor has no clothes?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoThe New York Attorney General is currently on Tether's case and its latest deadline is 15 January 2021 for Tether to produce documents, but that deadline may slip again…
- FireBeyond 6y agoFor the longest time, Tether claimed a 1:1 backing. They referenced audits that didn't exist, and so forth. Finally, their own lawyer admitted in a court briefing that they had less than 74%. No-one has heard from their CEO or CFO in over a year. Next significant court date is next Friday, 1/15.
- seibelj 6y agoI have been working in crypto / blockchain for years. Crypto projects simply cannot find engineers, it is impossible to hire people with these skills. You will make more money as a software engineer in crypto than you will anywhere else other than FAANG. And one major benefit is crypto companies are decentralized and almost always remote - as a developer in a foreign country you can make multiples what you could in a standard software firm. Don’t listen to the HN haters and nocoiners who have been telling lies for years. This is one of the most exciting and interesting industries you can work in. Keep an open mind and see what positions are available at the top coins on coingecko.com.
- bitcoinmoney 6y agoCan you give us example of how much money there is?
- seibelj 6y agoI provide services to a top 15 crypto exchange named Poloniex. Check out https://Poloniex.careers https://Poloniex.careers We are fully remote and hire people all over the world. We do not care where you live. We want talented people. But even outside exchanges, looking at projects, I know people who wrote code for posted projects and were paid in tokens that became very highly valued. My recommendation is to get involved in a project and see what they can pay. If you are skilled you will be rewarded. In the US it’s standard rates plus token payments which are liquid much sooner than stock options.
- tchalla 6y agoIf you are fully remote, you may want to change the location part of your Careers page. There are some options that feel like they are based out of a location.
- elevenoh 6y agoTruth. Though >50% of the smartest/most competent engineers I've ever worked with work in crypto.
- cratermoon 6y agoHow to detect a cryptocurrency pump-and-dump: 1. Is someone trying to sell cryptocurrency? 2. You found it.