5 ms·
I have one issue with this article. Section 230 certainly encouraged centralization of the internet. Without it, platforms would be liable for content they ho
by hedora 6y ago
I have one issue with this article.
Section 230 certainly encouraged centralization of the internet. Without it, platforms would be liable for content they hosted, which would be financially unviable.
Instead, people would have to self-host their own content on their own infrastructure. (230 provides no protection for people that do that.)
In addition to preventing the big monopolies from arising, this would have made censorship and surveillance much more difficult.
As it is, we’re in a situation where even the speech of the POTUS is beholdent to corporate censors.
The rest of the DMCA drastically shifted the balance of power toward copyright holders (and was also designed to increase consolidation of the industry); section 230 was necessary to offset that. I’d be happy to see the whole law repealed, though it would have the side effect of shattering the business models of the big tech monopolies. Repealing 230 but not the rest of the DMCA would be madness.
- root_axis 6y ago> we’re in a situation where even the speech of the POTUS is beholdent to corporate censors This is not true. The POTUS has the most prominent platform in the world, he could walk out to any random street corner and anything he says will be broadcast to every corner of the planet, he is not in any way beholden to "corporate censors".
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoThat’s not true any more though. All of the media networks have shown examples of cutting away from the Presidents speeches when they detect he’s going to say something they don’t like. If you were Trump right now and want to directly address the nation, you know calling CNN and Fox and NBC are going to be a mixed bag at best. FAANG has given the indication right now that for two week no one should be giving the President a platform. I fully expect him to use the national broadcast system. https://www.westernjournal.com/cnn-cuts-away-trump-coronavirus-briefing-calling-propaganda/ https://www.westernjournal.com/cnn-cuts-away-trump-coronavir... https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/cnn-msnbc-cut-away-donald-230651373.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly9kdWNrZHVja2dvLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAADw7rrRBKXn4sBkNYPXLDfKFK2AhitQrICMlQrv5mqSFS8jOMUURjXnC_nVAruwxmWG6ddNAEIpQ4pdzHfyt7L9zivjDcfEh7mEG0wyl_Lgx1vMELCJ8uBsBjVIySwcFp_gSMHBUAXLumkfsHN3UialE7eKdaRLOlitDhQ8I82Ow https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/cnn-msnbc-cut-away-donal... https://apnews.com/article/election-2020-donald-trump-entertainment-brian-williams-elections-8159feee1f7539e0bd4815092c11952f https://apnews.com/article/election-2020-donald-trump-entert... https://heavy.com/news/2020/07/fox-news-neil-cavuto-trump-speech-fact-check/ https://heavy.com/news/2020/07/fox-news-neil-cavuto-trump-sp... https://www.msnbc.com/deadline-white-house/watch/watch-nicolle-wallace-cuts-away-from-trump-we-hate-to-do-this-but-trump-isn-t-telling-the-truth-69905989594 https://www.msnbc.com/deadline-white-house/watch/watch-nicol... https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/fox-news-cuts-away-from-trump-campaign-press-conference-cant-in-good-countenance-continue-showing-this/ar-BB1aQCUY https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/fox-news-cuts-away-f... https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2020/nov/06/msnbc-cuts-away-from-trumps-address-after-he-again-falsely-declares-election-victory-video https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2020/nov/06/msnbc-...
- mrlala 6y ago>when they detect he’s going to say something they don’t like. Give me a break. You act like they have been cutting out on him for years. It's only been recently this year when he literally lying and calling covid a hoax, telling people to do dangerous things like gather for his rallies during a pandemic / actively saying not to wear masks, and finally this election bullshit. The networks have gone above and beyond his bs for years- there is a time to take a stand and the last few months have proven that.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago> Give me a break. You act like they have been cutting out on him for years. You may want to check the date on the links I posted. This has been going on since 2017. The search term I used was “cut away from Trump”. > The networks have gone above and beyond his bs for years- there is a time to take a stand I promise you the pendulum will swing and so will your reaction.
- root_axis 6y agoThe narrative you're trying to present is completely false. Any "cutting away" of Trump is utterly inconsequential compared to the complete domination of the media Trump has commanded since the beginning of his presidential campaign. Trump is literally the most famous man in the world, you're simply in denial if you can't admit that.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoI’m not in denial of that at all. The topic is can the media and tech silence the President of the USA, and the answer is apparently yes.
- benlivengood 6y ago> As it is, we’re in a situation where even the speech of the POTUS is beholdent to corporate censors. We've always been in that situation. Aside from the presidential alert system there is no government-controlled communication channel from the president to individuals, and there never has been. It's always been up to citizens to inform themselves of governmental goings-on. Finally, the president of the United States is a citizen holding a political office. No more, no less. The sitting president deserves no special treatment in a country of equals. If a citizen breaks the rules of common decency then fellow citizens are less likely to repeat those words for others to hear.
- waheoo 6y agoTrump had a 47% approval rating on the 6th and a 49% approval rating on the 7th. Nobody is asking for special treatment, they're asking that he and the 50% of Americans that voted for him get the same uncensored ability to share their views as the other 50 who commonly emote the extreme views in the other direction with thout such censorship.
- tonyztan 6y ago> "The rest of the DMCA drastically shifted the balance of power... section 230 was necessary to offset that... Repealing 230 but not the rest of the DMCA would be madness." Note that Section 230 is part of the Communications Decency Act (CDA). It is not part of the DMCA.
- LatteLazy 6y ago>Without it, platforms would be liable for content they hosted, which would be financially unviable I don't think that's true is it? YouTube could continue to operate exactly like today EXCEPT they couldn't moderate beyond the legal minimum (no CP etc). That would mean they were still shielded as your options WITHOUT s230 are Hard Moderate (and accept liability) or Not Moderate.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Instead, people would have to self-host their own content on their own infrastructure. (230 provides no protection for people that do that.) Without Section 230, hosting providers, registrars and ISPs would be held liable for your "self-hosted" content. It would be too much of a risk to host your content, unless you had deep enough pockets to assuage that risk.