3 ms·
MAD basically assures no hot war, it will be infrastructural hacks, IP theft, economic warfare, etc. moving forward.
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
MAD basically assures no hot war, it will be infrastructural hacks, IP theft, economic warfare, etc. moving forward.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- patagonia 6y agoHypersonic weapons changes that. Hypersonic weapons are very difficult to confuse with nuclear weapons. Combine that with cyber warfare and drone/robotic warfare... And it is now possible to have an all out conventional warfare style war again. MAD no longer applies here. MAD was relevant when "destruction" required nuclear weapons. It didn't really mean "you destroy me I destroy you." It meant, you launch nuclear weapons (which will destroy me) and I have enough left over to destroy you. That warfare no longer presents the likely scenario as would unfold between two superpowers.
- nytgop77 6y agoI dont understand. Both ear sides want to win. If loosing side has nuclear weapons, they will use them eith the goal to win. Why would they NOT use it?
- CogitoCogito 6y agoThere are different degrees to losing a war. The end result of losing a conventional war could be (IMO "would be") much better than the result for that same side if it let loose nukes. A direct war between two nuclear powers need not lead to the use of nuclear weapons. Of course it's only rational to fear such a result.
- nytgop77 6y agoIf tou could give an example (hipothetical scenario), maybe I would get what you mean. How I see it. Let's say, russia dared to enter a real multi-battle direct war with usa, to take alaska, and is winning a bit more each day. When would usa say "we give up, please take the alaska, we will not use our nukes?". - Immediately after the start while there are no casualties? - after 1k casualties on both sides? - after going to total war mode, when each side bombs industry complex'es and later cities on the other side? Backing down would say "nukes are not deterant anymore. Same thing can be done to us again." btw. Nukes can be used, not only on cities, but also on fleets and divisionsand camps. So the only way nukes would be not used if victory would be very instantaneous and total, which does not seem probable.
- baybal2 6y ago> MAD basically assures no hot war Wait, wait, wait. That's not a fact, and in fact a known piece of propaganda. First. Even, an all out nuclear exchange in between superpowers, in an unrealistic scenario without counterstrikes, and zero nuclear attrition, a superpower like US, Russia, or China will "only" loose a low single digits of population. Communist countries not only wouldn't hesitate to do so, but have a history doing that to themselves. USSR killed at a minimum 10% of its own population with fully intentional punitive starvation. Mao did the same, and Pol Pot have beaten both. Second. Even after a nuclear exchange, both superpowers would have at least a half of its military functioning, and very, very angry. Third, after exhausting all nukes, and high-tech weaponry, both countries would proceed to a long, and exhausting conventional war, which will kill way more people than any nukes can.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoAmerica has enough nukes to take out every population center in Asia before the day end tomorrow. It’s sad but true that nuclear power is so incredible that people haven’t dared move against it.
- baybal2 6y agoThat was not possible even with cold war number of missiles in service, let alone now.