8 ms·
> Look at Clojure. Weird parentheses, and yet it took the world by storm Am I on another planet ? I'd rate clojure slightly above haskell in terms of market sh
by agumonkey 6y ago
> Look at Clojure. Weird parentheses, and yet it took the world by storm
Am I on another planet ? I'd rate clojure slightly above haskell in terms of market share. Is my radar broken ?
- waffle_ss 6y agoThat raised my eyebrow as well. Semi-recently I was interested in learning Datalog so I wanted to kick the tires on Datomic (written in Clojure). I ended up getting stuck on some things; posted questions to StackOverflow and didn't get a response. I then realized the Clojure tag is very low volume + engagement. Then someone on Twitter told me that I'd be better off asking questions in the Clojurians Slack channel. So I go to sign up and... the signup link is broken. Had to flag down someone on Twitter or IRC to fix it. As an outsider I felt a whiff of decay from the Clojure community (no offense)
- agumonkey 6y agoThe whole article felt it's coming from a traditional / industrial OO (everybody happy about UML usually doesn't see the world as I do). broken slack links or not, the community is not as large as the author seems to convey.
- mxz3000 6y agoDo people actually use UML in industry? I've never actually seen it used (or mentioned for that matter) in the few years I've been a software engineer...
- agumonkey 6y agoffff .. fff most probably yeah, at least there are some informal uses whenever you make some diagram docs .. you'll end up aligning with uml 'vocab'. I helped a european project on a uml graph versioning between various industrial uml applications, but I'd consider these niche. IBM was heavy on UML since they bought Rational suite.. but I know IBM didn't use Rational for themselves (at least my department).. but surely Rational users did. I think heavily regulated sectors are the most prevalent users of UML.. they like having a standard, having a lot of documentation etc.
- travv0 6y agoYeah, it’s kind of mind-blowing to me that this post is so highly rated when to me it just seems like a bunch of unsubstantiated claims like this, as well as blatant misunderstandings of fundamental functional programming concepts.
- agumonkey 6y agoI guess haskell is just rarely enough on HN FP to get a boost just for that. Content is not worth spending much time IMO. To each his own, if the guy really suffers with Haskell then so be it, may he have a lot of fun with perl or js.
- iLemming 6y agoIf you try to set a google alert for "Clojure jobs" and "Haskell jobs", or just go through "HN: who's hiring" of the recent years and compare search results for Clojure and Haskell, you'd see that it's not "just slightly above". Clojure currently is the most widely used FP lang.
- haskellandchill 6y agoDoesn't Scala beat Clojure in industry? That would be my experience and it has higher number of jobs on Who's Hiring. My ranking for adoption goes: Scala > F# > Elixir > Clojure > Haskell > OCaml. F# doesn't make much of a showing on Who's Hiring but I think it has stronger adoption in industry than Clojure.
- iLemming 6y agoIt used to be that way. But it looks like Scala is slightly losing (not to Clojure), mainly to Kotlin: https://snyk.io/blog/kotlin-overtakes-scala-and-clojure-to-become-the-2nd-most-popular-language-on-the-jvm/ https://snyk.io/blog/kotlin-overtakes-scala-and-clojure-to-b... Note that I'm not bashing or defending any of the PLs mentioned. It is merely the fact - today, Clojure is the most popular FP language being utilized in the industry. Check the number of podcasts dedicated to Clojure https://www.fpcasts.com; https://www.fpcasts.com; the number of conferences: https://purelyfunctional.tv/functional-programming-conferences; https://purelyfunctional.tv/functional-programming-conferenc... list of companies using it, job listings, etc. It doesn't mean that this all makes the language better or worse. Also, the overall share of languages with strong FP semantics is still way too small compared to the use of imperative PLs. That fact doesn't make OOP better than FP and vice-versa.