3 ms·
In this snapshot of a moment, yes. But consider these things: 1. Space colonies, especially remote ones (e.g. not Moon, but Mars or Titan), are strongly motiva
by inglor_cz 6y ago
In this snapshot of a moment, yes. But consider these things:
1. Space colonies, especially remote ones (e.g. not Moon, but Mars or Titan), are strongly motivated to be maximally independent as soon as possible. Whoever leads them must think about the possibility that the supply ships stop coming, either for some temporary disruption (pandemics on Earth, cough, cough, or even a war back home), or permanently (something has gone seriously wrong on the blue planet). And imports from Earth are expensive, because they have to be lifted out of the Earth's gravitational well. This means that the colony will try to produce everything necessary in situ for good reasons; such a colony will not be easily brought to its knees by a blockade.
2. It is easy to block a colony physically, but they will still be able to communicate back to Earth and argue their cause in front of the rest of the humanity. This will undermine the will of Earthly powers to maintain the blockade.
3. We are now in a rare situation when only one nation (the U.S.) is approaching the capability to send ships to the rest of the Solar System. It is not unlike the situation when only the Portuguese mastered the carrack and were the only ones to sail regularly from Europe to India in the late 1400s. But this situation will not last and I would guess that by 2050, at least five or six sovereign entities will have the same capability. By 2100 for sure. And their political differences will be exploited. It is unlikely that all of them would decide to start a common punitive embargo against a rebel colony.
- ozim 6y agoFor the point number 3 you might be too much under influence of SpaceX marketing and launches. China is on their way to mars as well with Tianwen-1, India is ramping up their space program, ESA is launching their stuff with Ariane vehicle as far as Jupiter, Russians with Angara have plan for crewed moon flyby in 2029. So it is not like other nations won't have that capability soon after US and not like US has it right now or next year. Second part is that there is still not that much of commercial gain in going to Mars, Moon or other place. Most of the money is made in LEO with satellite communications, gps, utilities. Space mining is not going to be profitable for really long time into the future. Where going to India was profitable right away if you had a ship to carry spices you were really ahead of the others. Space ship capability is just the starting point and we still have to find something that is worth enough to send those ships there, even with SpaceX reusable rockets it is still not worth to mine rare earth elements somewhere else in the solar system.
- imglorp 6y agoNo marketing needed - SpaceX is a decade ahead of all other Earth agencies. Yes it's very hard to get a soft landing on Mars, and props to any agency that can do it. We expect great things from Tianwen-1. But it's many times harder to develop a complete process to soft land 100mt there, 100 times a year. This is the same engineering process that spanked ULA, who with a century of experience and head start, has yet to complete its commercial crew rating, plus they are single shot, not reusable.
- 0df8dkdf 6y agoIt is worth studying the East/West Indian Company model that the English used in India. The same is done know by US for space colonisation. Just look at the executive order signed by Trump to explore the moon. Seems like history may not repeat, just rhymes.
- pseingatl 6y agoThe US District Court for China is a better example. It operated in the American concession in Shanghai in the 1930's. Also see the Canal Zone; take a look at the Mars Colony Legal Code drawn from the latter: marslegalcode.org, an effort to answer the question: how much law do we bring with us?
- Daho0n 6y ago>3. We are now in a rare situation when only one nation (the U.S.) is approaching the capability to send ships to the rest of the Solar System. That is a very Americanized view of how things are. Unless something goes wrong CNSA will land Tianwen-1 on Mars a week before Percy gets there. Your comment is written in a tiny timeframe where the US is actually at or near the front but looking over time this isn't the case.
- tomatotomato37 6y agoThe ship analogy is funny too considering that Columbus discovered America with a Spanish carrack fleet 5 years before Da Gama was able to sail around the cape to India. And speaking of sovereignty & Spanish-Portugal colonization, I wonder what the interstellar version of the Treaty of Tordesillas is gonna look like.