7 ms·
> even things like allergies and sexualities which one would expect to be more biological in origin. It doesn't seem to be well-known, but concordance for homo
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> even things like allergies and sexualities which one would expect to be more biological in origin.
It doesn't seem to be well-known, but concordance for homosexuality in identical twins is very low (if memory serves, around 40%) compared to concordance for virtually anything else you can measure.
This is pretty unsurprising looking at the biological fundamentals -- a quick naive approach would be to predict "genes will never code for homosexuality, because it is such a crippling failure for the organism" -- but it does tend to undermine the idea that homosexuality is biological in origin.
- selestify 6y agoJust because something isn’t 100% determined by genetics doesn’t mean genetics doesn’t play a heavy role still. A concordance of 40% is still really high compared to random chance by sampling from the general population, so it arguably supports biological causes for homosexuality.
- vagrantJin 6y agoHow? If we dont have evidence for it should we just conclude that it exists because our maths does not say it doesn't. Lets make witchcraft a part of medicine then. A statistically significant part of the human population belives in it. Lets get that into a 4 semester course in a 6 year medical degree.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoBut we can see that the role of genetics is miniscule compared to its role in any other trait, since identical twin concordance for homosexuality is so low compared to concordance for anything else. Genetics affects everything including the environmental influences you are subject to. But your genes are trying as hard as they can to ensure you are heterosexual.
- creata 6y agoSorry, I've only taken statistics 101. What's "concordance" in this context?
- stdbrouw 6y agoCorrelation but with categories rather than continuous variables, for example as used in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kendall_rank_correlation_coefficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kendall_rank_correlation_coeff... -- so "has the same sexuality as their twin" would be concordant, or I think what the parent comment is referring to is more specifically "is homosexual and their twin is too". In the general population, you'd expect a concordance of at most 10% (a high-ish estimate of the prevalence of homosexuality in the population), though of course that's conditional on the first person in the comparison being homosexual, otherwise it'd be much higher.
- trianglem 6y agoOf course genes don’t code for homosexuality. Just look at the percentage of gay people in prison.
- lldbg 6y agohttps://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02585-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02585-6 25% of the variance in sexuality is genetic or heritable. Compared to approx. 80% for intelligence. A small genetic component, but it seems as if experiences are the major deciding factor for sexuality.
- andy_ppp 6y agoI’m very skeptical about intelligence being as high as 80%, how do they remove environmental factors it seems almost impossible.
- lldbg 6y agoBy having lots and lots of good data. 80%+ is what the current corpus of scientific knowledge says. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4270739/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4270739/ Here's a somewhat good primer on the topic, but the wikipedia page on heritability of intelligence (and it's sources) is also somewhat good.
- greatgirl 6y agoThere is no wikipedia page on heritability of intelligence, only heritability of IQ. It makes me consider whether the rest of what you've said is actually incorrect since you made such a conflation. Intelligence is a notoriously hard thing to define and measure, and I think it's more easily predicted by environmental factors than genetics. The idea that smart people breed and have smart children and that's why some people are smart and others are dumb, is more of a cop-out, since predictors of success that tests like IQ try to explain are more accurately explained by socio-economic factors. Basically this has no real world implications. I realise this isn't the argument you were trying to make necessarily, you were just pointing out a perceived 'fact', but it lacks a lot of nuance that could lead to dangerous assumptions about the real world, especially since you related it to sexuality.
- LudwigNagasena 6y ago
- beerandt 6y agoHow about that male birthing order study that they've been trying to disprove for years? [1] the odds of having a gay son increase from approximately 2% for the first born son, to 3% for the second, 5% for the third... [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_male_sexual_orientation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_ma...
- arnoooooo 6y agoThere are theories for how a low percentage of homosexuality might be selected for. I have heard at least of the idea that a non reproducing sibling can help you raise your own offspring, who will have mostly the same genes. This is corroborated if I recall correctly by findings that each new child in a family has more chance to be homosexual than their already born siblings. There is also the idea that there might be genes that are most of the time favorable to reproduction, but once in a while (through crossing or mutations) result in homosexuality.
- vagrantJin 6y ago> This is corroborated if I recall correctly by findings that each new child in a family has more chance to be homosexual than their already born siblings. Very radical approach, seemingly against the grain of what we observe in the wild. It's such a leap of logic, you may very well have been talking about how santa claus' reindeer achieve thrust for their impressive levitation.
- arnoooooo 6y agoI'm not sure what you mean. Humans have been social animals for a very long time, so it stands to reason that they would be genetically different from non humans, although i'd expect similar results in other social animals.
- yorwba 6y agoAn example of similar results in other social animals are worker/soldier ants/bees/termites. They don't reproduce, but by contributing to the survival of their hive of relatives, they still end up spreading their genes.
- vagrantJin 6y agoAre they homosexual or asexual? Let's not confuse the two. They "cant" reproduce is quite a leap away from "can produce but won't" because as far as I am aware homosexuality has nothing to do with sexual reproduction and the required 'machinery'. Unless you have some solid papers or anecdotal experiences that say otherwise I'm willing to change my stance.
- m12k 6y ago> but it does tend to undermine the idea that homosexuality is biological in origin. Not genetic and not biological are two different things. E.g. the differentiator might be hormonal influence during the fetal stage. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epigenetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epigenetics for a long list of things other than DNA that can affect how organisms develop.
- pydry 6y ago>genes will never code for homosexuality, because it is such a crippling failure for the organism It's not necessarily a failure for the gene just because the organism doesn't reproduce. Genes extend beyond the organism to the family. It would be more surprising that it persisted in less social species.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> It would be more surprising that it persisted in less social species. It does.
- throwaway2245 6y ago> such a crippling failure for the organism This is just a homophobic mischaracterisation of sexuality. I recognise and don't appreciate how much of an effort you made to fit this homophobia into your point. Also, 40% heritability is informally considered to be a high genetic component, not "very low", and e.g. heritability of eyebrow thickness is 37%.
- 0x737368 6y agoI'm very certain the parent meant it in an evolutionary sense that the individual will not pass on their genes to offspring - nothing to do with homophobia.
- brodie 6y agoIt seems like a very individual natural selection-based idea. I’ve personally always wondered if there could be tribe-level selection for tribes with some non-heterosexual members. But I also have personal experience, and I’ve met others who do as well, with life experiences that make me wonder if they could somehow affect sexuality. I know it might be presumptuous of me to consider the idea, but it’s only just an idea—one I usually keep to myself.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoIt seems obvious to me that your childhood and especially adolescent experiences would impact what you find sexually attractive as an adult. Is this considered a radical position?
- brodie 6y agoIt’s a sensitive subject for some, I think.
- throwaway2245 6y agoThe parent could have made the claim (that you believe they meant) without saying "crippling failure of an organism", and I would still think it was mildly homophobic: - there's literally nothing to stop a homosexual person from biologically reproducing, - it assumes that the only value of an organism is in its Darwinian fitness (its ability to reproduce), which is pretty gross. I reject this assumption. The parent appears to be applying this heuristic of value only so far as it implies a moral failure of homosexuality: it's not a typical measure of value. Humans value other animals more highly than this, without regard to whether they have reproduced.
- eecc 6y agoWell no. I’m stupidly in love with my male son and I assume homo-sexuality is just a behavioral generalization into sexuality of same-sex “aggression de-triggers” and “attachment triggers”. It’s underpinnings are built into successful parenting (don’t murder your pups.) Besides, close relatives in the animal kingdom (Bonobo) use significant amounts of sexual behavior in their sociality, including same-sex interactions. Unfortunately we evolved from chimpanzees, who have strongly abusive and hierarchical social structure. Whence, nasty homophobic comments.
- vimy 6y agoWe didn’t evolve from chimpanzees. Bonobos, humans and chimpanzees have a common ancestor. While chimpanzees are violent psychopaths, bonobos are peace-loving hippies who have sex all day. Humans seem to have a mix of both these traits. It’s quite astonishing how much bonobos look and act like humans when they walk upright or when they play with their babies.
- bsanr2 6y agoHomosexuality is potentially bad for the perpetuation of an individual's genetic line (sexuality is a spectrum, and a percentage if not a majority of homosexual men and women would be open to procreation given a suitable social framework), but for communities, has the potential to be a net positive for survival; for example, it may reduce competition for procreative mating partners, and provide childless adults who can share rearing responsibilities. In fact, one could say that the benefits of such an alternate sexuality were so recognized that some societies sought to produce it artificially through the creation of eunuchs.