3 ms·
> It wasn't even close to a coup You'd never say that if it wasn't "your people" in there. Never. Don't claim to be a patriot ever again if you think dismiss
by ajross 6y ago
> It wasn't even close to a coup
You'd never say that if it wasn't "your people" in there. Never. Don't claim to be a patriot ever again if you think dismissing the first successful attack on a congressional session (hell, the VP was in there too) in the history of the republic is a good argument to make. Hell, five people died. That's more than at the Reichstag fire (I checked with Godwin, by the way, he approves).
This was a moment of deep shame. And comments like yours make it worse.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoI am interested in the truth. The truth is that the events at the capitol were not a coup. This is deliberate propagandist language. >This was a moment of deep shame. And comments like yours make it worse. The people turning their back on our civil liberties are far more shameful.
- ajross 6y ago> The truth is that the events at the capitol were not a coup. This is deliberate propagandist language. You say so only because it failed. If the tunnels didn't exist? If the mob had been faster or better armed? How would it have ended? Would Pence and Pelosi still be hostages? (Edit: not worth continuing. But I bet anything if I kept going you'd eventually pull out a thesaurus and zing me with BUT it's REALLY an "autogolpe!")
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoIt's not a failed coup. It's just not a coup at all.
- pqhwan 6y agoNow you’re just helplessly denying. I just want to remind you that you’re free to change your opinion, no one will think less of you if you do. I’ve done it before, it can be pretty exciting to turn your world around and re-evaluate things every now and then.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoI'm willing to change my opinion as soon as someone provides me some evidence that this was actually a coup, and not a riot that's being inflated to order to justify sweeping authoritarianism.
- pqhwan 6y agoIt’s possible you’re underestimating the sheer practical and symbolic significance of the building they broke into (and the people who work there). Which, actually, is kind of the whole problem. Can you provide an example of an evidence that would make this a coup for you?
- Udik 6y agoThis is a good analysis of why it was not a coup: https://theconversation.com/was-it-a-coup-no-but-siege-on-us-capitol-was-the-election-violence-of-a-fragile-democracy-152803 https://theconversation.com/was-it-a-coup-no-but-siege-on-us... In short, a coup is an organised action to seize power. For that, it's essential to have secured the support of at least part of the armed forces, and a plan to replace the top of the power hierarchy. Nothing like that was seen in the Capitol riots, which seemed disorganised and essentially demonstrative in nature. Once entering the building, the rioters proceeded taking selfies.
- pqhwan 6y agoThat actually is a pretty good argument. I have indeed been playing fast and loose with the terminology; yes, it wasn’t a military coup, but it is still an unprecedented attack on the federal government, a riot.
- pseudalopex 6y agoSome took selfies. Some proclaimed themselves in control of Congress. Some entered the Senate chamber with weapons and handcuffs. The authors said a coup has 3 criteria. > 3) Do the plotters use illegal and unconstitutional methods to seize executive power? The authors said yes. > 2) Is the target of the insurrection the chief executive of the government? The authors said yes. > 1) Are the perpetrators agents of the state, such as military officials or rogue governmental officials? The authors said no because Trump can deny meaning to incite it. They're extremely charitable. And this isn't part of the common definition of a coup anyway.
- dang 6y agoPlease do not take HN threads further into flamewar hell like this. HN's rules apply regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are, and the fact that the site is burning uncontrolledly in 17 places right now is reason for established users like you to stick more to the intended spirit, not less. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html