4 ms·
What does illegal content look like? What jurisdiction? Does Parler need to hire a lawyer to make content decisions? When Trump says "we need to fight hard!"
by jedberg 6y ago
What does illegal content look like? What jurisdiction? Does Parler need to hire a lawyer to make content decisions?
When Trump says "we need to fight hard!", is that illegal? What if he says, "Go back to the Capitol and start shooting!"? Is that illegal?
FWIW that was our policy at reddit for a long time too. There is a whole lot of nuance to it that is really hard to deal with.
- guscost 6y agoSo do we need a DMCA type thing for courts to file injunctions against illegal content? What is the solution? The fact is any moderation will be subjective and imperfect. How can making more complicated subjective rules help at all?
- matz1 6y agoIt is always subjective, the entity in power get to decide the rule, in this case google is the entity in power. Its not enough to have rule that says 'illegal content not allowed', in the case of play store it has to be 'illegal content (according to google) not allowed'
- guscost 6y agoSurely there must be a way to let the courts determine legality in every single controversial case. It’s just an optimization problem. We sent fourteen people to walk around on the moon, twelve of them made it, and all of them made it back.
- matz1 6y agoAs long as that way, whatever it is, still involve more than one human, you can't avoid the subjectivity problem. Its not technology problem. Its human problem.
- guscost 6y agoMy point is that there is an age-old institution to solve this problem, called a court. We all participate in a social contract where the court's decisions about subjective matters have the force of law. Where it gets weird is that Twitter also has an explicit user contract with the underlying USA social contract/courts as a dependency! If you could physically live in Twitter apartments, and somehow remain safe from war, why not only depend on the Twitter contract and its moderation system? And that's how we get to the future world of Snow Crash.
- CodeWriter23 6y agoUnbelievable you’re getting downvotes @jedberg, probably one of a handful of people in this conversation with actual hands-on experience.
- jedberg 6y agoThanks. Sometimes people don’t appreciate real world experience. It’s ok, I’ve gotten used to it. I appreciate when others speak up for me.
- driverdan 6y agoI'm downvoting you because you know the answer to those questions. You know exactly what speech is protected by the 1st and what isn't. Parler is not removing illegal speech, therefore their apps are being taken down. It's pretty simple.