6 ms·
Ars Technica Investigates the State of Malware on the Mac
- wiredfool 16y agoPerhaps "Slipping a Norton" will become the new mickey.
- Kylekramer 16y agoI assume Gruber is talking about engineers in Cupertino never using Norton, while Ars is talking to Genius Bar employees. It is that far fetched to assume Apple trusts the former more than the latter?
- hahainternet 16y agoTo me this seems like Gruber doing damage control for Apple again. There's no doubt that simple scams like this will increase as marketshare does, and pretending like it's not already happening is fooling nobody.
- joebadmo 16y agoYeah, I really don't understand Gruber's position on this. It seems fairly obvious and inarguable that as Macs become a bigger target, there will be more and worse malware on them. Is he saying that there's something inherent to Mac OS that makes malware harder? If so, what?
- rimantas 16y agoGruber wrote more then once in the past about market share argument. It's been going on for years. And there were more viruses for Mac OS versions prior to OS X with even smaller market share. I think one advantage OS X always had compared to Win < 7 that users never had a habit to run with administrator rights all the time.
- joebadmo 16y agoSure, that's one advantage, but it doesn't seem like a decisive one, really. I must have missed his arguments re market share. I've only ever seen him post the historically periodic articles about how people have always been saying it's about to happen. What are his actual arguments? If anything, I feel like Mac OS X will potentially be more vulnerable. To make the anatomical analogy, Windows has always had a lot of exposure to malware, and as a result there's a fairly robust anti-malware ecosystem, like anti-bodies in an immune system. OS X, on the other hand, hasn't. It's evolved in the absence of many attacks, and has a proportionally weaker immune system. Ok, I'm not sure I buy that completely, but the market share argument seems like a straightforward one.
- wtallis 16y agoMost iterations of the "market share argument" I've seen imply that at some time in the future, Mac market share will reach a tipping point and writing viruses for OS X will be lucrative enough that there will be a dramatic increase in the amount of malware being flung at Macs. It has the same problem that plagues every other apocalyptic argument: the world keeps not ending. Nobody ever says how much market share OS X needs to reach this tipping point, which makes it pretty hard to falsify. Meanwhile, the Mac market share keeps growing, year after year, with only minor increases in the prevalence of malware, and no major botnets or worms of the sort that were rampant on Win9x and early XP. Claiming that OS X is (or will be) a soft target also serves to further undermine the market share argument: Windows has been getting more secure over time, which should help make OS X a more attractive target if it really is a softer target than Windows.
- joebadmo 16y agoYou're totally right, that market share argument is often vague and probably unfalsifiable, but there's at least a clear logic to it. "It hasn't happened yet," on the other hand, is not an argument at all. An analysis charting data of total malware vs. market share would be more interesting, but an argument for why it hasn't happened yet, and will continue not to would be the most interesting to me. I'm not sure I follow your last point.
- Anechoic 16y agoIs he saying that there's something inherent to Mac OS that makes malware harder? No, he's saying that everytime there is a virus/trojan/rootkit/malware found in the wild that targets MacOS X there is a chorus of articles in the tech media essentially proclaiming that the end is nigh for safe computing on the Mac. There is malware/etc that targets Macs. There will always be malware that targets Mac. I doubt Gruber doesn't believe this. However the existence of particular piece of malicious software is not the same as a widespread practice that will bring down the platform as is seemingly presumed by the various tech articles that talk about Mac malware.
- joebadmo 16y agoI agree that one instance of malware doesn't necessarily mean anything, but growing market share does. And what the ars article points out that's really pernicious is Apple's response to the issue, which is not a good sign for how they might deal with the growth of malware as a reaction to growing market share. Especially in light of Apple's marketing re security of Mac OS. And Gruber doesn't seem to be making an argument in this post. He agrees with the reporting but quibbles with a tertiary, almost irrelevant graph.
- ROFISH 16y agoActually I wouldn't be surprised to find Norton on a Genius Bar Mac, mostly because an anti-virus is required for PCI compliance to handle credit cards.
- wtallis 16y agoLast time I bought something at an Apple Store, my credit card was swiped through an iPod Touch, not a Mac. Do you think that the iPod was running a virus scanner?
- tzs 16y agoPCI requires anti-virus on "all systems commonly affected by malicious software". It is not required on every system involved in credit card handling.
- ansy 16y agoOriginal source: http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2011/05/malware-on-the-mac.ars/ http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2011/05/malware-on-the-mac... From the Hacker News Guidelines[1]: "Please submit the original source. If a blog post reports on something they found on another site, submit the latter." The fact Mac OS X is a security pushover is pretty well known[2]. I wouldn't be surprised if more macs weren't rooted with something much stealthier than Mac Defender. Disclaimer: I use a mac. [1] http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html [2] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/faster-forward/post/ie-safari-iphone-blackberry-fall-at-pwn2own-chrome-firefox-android-windows-phone-7-escape/2011/03/14/ABjqQGV_blog.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/faster-forward/post/ie-s...
- bdhe 16y agoThe fact Mac OS X is a security pushover is pretty well known[2]. That raises the question then, why aren't we seeing more Mac viruses and malware? Is it purely a question of economics that market share answers? Is it because there's more technical "know-how" and experience floating around about Windows vulnerabilities? Is it because it is easier to profit off of Windows vulns? These are genuine questions to which I'd love to hear some answers. Edit: The fact that OS X Lion was shared with security researchers in advance[1] is a good move on Apple's part. Does Microsoft do similar things? [1]http://news.cnet.com/8301-1009_3-20036218-83.html http://news.cnet.com/8301-1009_3-20036218-83.html
- shawndumas 16y agoThis link included information that the other didn't.
- tzs 16y agoYour second link does not support what you are citing it for.