9 ms·
Intel Talks with TSMC, Samsung to Outsource Some Chip Production
- ogre_codes 6y agoGiving up manufacturing would be terrible. It really feels like Intel is ceding any hope of leadership to focus on milking their IP for cash. That would be incredibly frustrating and sad. I hope it's not true or just very limited scope.
- Alupis 6y agoIt's worked out extremely well for AMD... and recall everyone was saying it would be the end of AMD when they spun off their FAB into Global Foundries. Fabricating, and design are very different businesses.
- ogre_codes 6y agoWell yes, but while AMD has great technology, their success as a CPU maker has always relied on the success of the x86 platform. The assumption is x86 will remain competitive for years to come, but that seems a lot less clear now. It feels like what ARM is doing right now is quite similar to what x86 did to mini computers and mainframes. ARM has become a competitive pressure that will prevent Intel and AMD from cashing in on that platform the way they have in the past. Chromebooks and the iPad have been nibbling at the low end for a few years now. Now Apple's M1 is taking a big chunk out of Intel's lucrative ultrabook market. Microsoft and other OEMs are going to start pushing harder on ARM just to stay competitive. Though being the sole licensee of x86, maybe AMD can pull a weird rabbit out of their hat.
- Alupis 6y agoAMD also has ARM irons in the fire[1]. [1] https://www.amd.com/en/amd-opteron-a1100 https://www.amd.com/en/amd-opteron-a1100
- ogre_codes 6y agoI didn't realize AMD had ARM CPUs. I was trying to hint that AMD might make some weird hybrid x86/ ARM beast that could have the advantages of ARM much of the time, but could run x86 native. I'm not sure that's even possible. AMD might do well in a post x86 world. It's just a broader playing field.
- Alupis 6y agoThat would indeed be an interesting setup, kind of like the big.LITTLE configuration popular on a lot of high-end ARM processors. I'm sure it could be done... but probably would have some interesting effects on software (unless you do full x86 emulation on the ARM cores... but then what's the point). It's far more likely we'll start seeing ARM processors with hundreds or thousands of cores in the server market first. These would be particularly interesting to virtual server providers like Amazon, Google, Digital Ocean and others.
- owowow 6y agoAMD stopped building these in 2016 and Amazon hired away most of the AMD team that worked on this chip.
- perfopt 6y agoThis was several years ago. They never really launched their ARM line. I believe they no longer have an ARM license. They certainly dont have a product ARM line
- yread 6y agoExtremely well? The split happened 12 years ago - AMD was struggling almost bankrupt until last year or two. Global Foundries is also not doing so well - they also gave up on chasing the latest process and focus on specialized 12nm stuff
- Alupis 6y agoExtremely well, yes. AMD, in fact, did not go bankrupt. Keeping their Fab arm was quite literally going to bankrupt them back when they made the decision to spin it off. They could not afford to sink the R&D cost into newer, smaller process fabing and recognized maintaining their own Fab would (a) bankrupt AMD attempting to push into newer processes and/or (b) prevent AMD from ever being competitive in the x86 market due to using old process. In hindsight, it was a brilliant move, and now has allowed AMD to partner with any Fab that has the technology AMD needs.
- jjoonathan 6y agoIt was brilliant -- but it reduced the number of leading-edge fab players from 3 to 2. Intel pulling the same move would reduce the number of leading-edge fab players from 2 to 1. See the problem?
- Alupis 6y agoWhat? Intel hasn't been a "leading-edge" fab in years and years at this point. And that is exactly why they've lost their "advantage" over AMD. Intel got bogged down in very expensive R&D, and failed over and over to produce yield good enough to mass produce retail chips. As far as I know, TSMC and Samsung are both considered leading-edge.
- jjoonathan 6y agoSamsung is burning money to produce chips a node behind TSMC. They are a leading-edge fab right now like Intel is a leading-edge fab right now. You're right that they are a contender, but the fab market is always going to be this way: one player will be the best, the others won't be. If you design CPUs but don't manufacture them, your supplier will always have a natural monopoly, meanwhile your customers have more options every day. Ditching the monopoly market to focus on the competitive market is not a good long-term strategy.
- Traster 6y agoI think this is the wrong way of looking at it - and actually the way that Intel themselves describe it. Intel think of themselves as a manufacturing company whose designs drive demand for their fab. But in truth, most of their value comes from x86 which could be produced by any fab. To stay competitive, their high end designs need to be on the absolute bleedge edge process. Which up until now has been Intel fabs. But it's not giving up on Intel fabs to get their stuff produced by TSMC. They need to do both - they need to make money by producing the best designs in the market no matter what the process in the high end space, as wl as sinking investment into their fabrication side to make sure that in 5 years time they're the leading fab. At which point they can turn around and say F-U to all those TSMC customers, produce only Intel chips and use that to capture market share.
- reader_mode 6y agoAnd the way I see it that's probably the reason why TSMC won't allocate any significant capacity to them, they already have more demand than they can produce. Maybe if they spun out the fab part but they have so much stuff under the corporation that probably makes no sense.
- muricula 6y agoAMD spun out global foundries, and they're not competitive at the bleeding edge today. I fear the fab-only part of Intel would be the same.
- iforgotpassword 6y agoSo then AMD switched to TSMC. Otherwise they would have been stuck with an inferior process and fallen even more behind during the last decade.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> But in truth, most of their value comes from x86 which could be produced by any fab. This is why I suggest it's a profit taking move. If they ditched all manufacturing, their profitability will certainly go up in the near term. But then how does Intel fend off increasingly competitive ARM CPUs? So long as Intel had a hand in manufacturing, they at least have a chance of maintaining an edge through their processes. I'm also deeply frustrated that yet another manufacturing giant is leaving the US. But that's more or less another issue.
- agumonkey 6y agoIt might be a short term move just to sell, until they reintegrate in-house manufacturing. It would avoid fab being a comparison spot. But it would also devalue the brand to the eyes of consumers potentially.
- dlevine 6y agoIntel has whiffed their 10nm process node to the point where it may never launch in any scale. Their 7nm node is significantly behind schedule. Their only solution in the near-term is to keep increasing the TDP of their chips, which won't work for long. This might be their only good option. Sure outsourcing manufacturing is a risk, but it's probably one they need to take. They will catch back up if they can get their 7nm node back on track, which isn't a given.
- ogre_codes 6y agoI just think it stinks of desperation and suspect once they go down this path it's going to be very difficult to reverse course.
- CountSessine 6y agoStink or otherwise, they are actually very desperate!
- iforgotpassword 6y agoIntel is intel because of x86, not because of their fab. 10nm is what, 4 years behind, does anyone feel confident 7nm will be ready in the next 5 years? Having a superior architecture (which they don't anymore) can only compensate for so much regarding node size. Intel isn't going to pull that one around. Having your fab in-house only makes sense if you're state of the art. At some point, not admitting defeat and just keep increasing TDP is false pride.
- ant6n 6y agoIntel is what it is because of fab. For many years, they were way ahead. 5 years ago AMD also had x86 but was very much behind and almost went bankrupt.
- qppo 6y agoThe federal government has identified semiconductor manufacturing as a critical piece of national infrastructure. If it comes to it, Intel can get subsidized like Boeing.
- u678u 6y ago> It really feels like Intel is ceding any hope of leadership to focus on milking their IP for cash. AMD/Apple/Nvidia gave up manufacturing took all the cash and left Intel a long way behind. Its manufacturing is causing their problems and losing leadership.
- ogre_codes 6y agoI don't think Apple/ Nvidia have ever manufactured their own CPUs before. Apple has certainly been fabless their entire run as CPU makers. > Its manufacturing is causing their problems and losing leadership. Certainly. But not long ago they were top dog. Ceasing manufacturing their own CPUs would mean they could never be more than a peer among equals. I suppose that's a step up from their current state, but they can kiss their 30% margins goodbye.
- totalZero 6y agoSemiconductors are in massive demand right now. If Intel can offload some production, it will surely use the freed-up capacity to produce other chips.
- trianglem 6y agoI’m so sad.
- meragrin_ 6y agoIntel is supposed to be releasing their Xe-HPG this year and they've already announced it was going to be manufactured externally. Is this supposed to be specifically about the CPUs?
- tracker1 6y agoI have really mixed feelings on this. I'd prefer to see Intel work with TSMC and/or Samsung to build/operate joint fabs or some kind of co-ownership over completely outsourcing. I'd prefer to see a few more diverse production locations that include an EU fab, and updated US fab locations. I'm concerned about instability with China stretching its' elbows in the region and I think having more geodiverse locations would be better for everyone involved. It's kind of the end of an era and sad to see in a lot of ways. I do want to see Intel be more competitive as they'll probably be treading water in mindshare for the next couple years. Aside: I want to know how much Intel is paying laptop mfgs to keep higher end memory and GPU options out of AMD powered laptops.
- newsclues 6y agoYour concern about China is Taiwan’s leverage with TSMC to remain independent and pro Western.
- tanseydavid 6y agoCould you expand what you mean in your comment (just a little bit) by any chance? I am very interested in this line-of-reasoning.
- fgonzag 6y agoTSMC guarantees that every western country has a stake in Taiwan's sovereignity. As long as they manufacture most of the worlds advanced silicon, western countries will continue to protect and arm taiwan.
- kungito 6y agoWell EU just recently announced some multizillion EU fab plan
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- baybal2 6y agoYet another Bloomberg "bombshell" without a single named source? Rumour were going on for at least 3 years, but they are rumours. Except for the fact of Bob Swan being sighted visiting Xinzhu, there was no other facts supporting that whatsoever in a those years.
- meragrin_ 6y agoHow is this a bombshell? They have already announced some of their new GPUs are going to be manufactured externally and due for release this year.
- NonEUCitizen 6y agoThe city's name is romanized as Hsinchu in Taiwan, ROC, not Xinzhu as PRC pinyin would romanize it.
- knolax 6y agoThe ROC officially adopted Pinyin a couple years back. http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2008/09/18/2003423528 http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2008/09/18/2...
- vnqwerty 6y agoWell, in the U.S. and Europe people who actually produce something are hindered by bureaucrats and ideologues. It is no wonder that valuable knowledge moves to Asia.
- princekolt 6y agoFunny, ARM, AMD, and Apple seem to be having no issues. Maybe they should change the company name to Antel?
- reader_mode 6y agoTo be fair to OP all of these companies outsourced production to Asia.
- NonEUCitizen 6y agoARM takes it further and just licenses its IP, leaving to its licensees the decision of whether to outsource production to Asia. Not all necessarily outsource to Asia. I think STMicro and Infineon still produce some ARM microcontrollers (microcontrollers; these are not smartphone CPUs) in Europe.
- welterde 6y agoNot exactly.. ARM doesn't really produce their own chips and there are manufacturers that use ARM cores that produce chips in the EU (ST, Infinion and NXP as well I think) and US (TI). AMD still has GlobalFoundries produce things for them (and they have fabs in the US and in Germany).
- delfinom 6y agoOr you know, look at the pattern. All the companies that are succeeding are run by engineers at head, be it AMD, ARM, Apple, Google, Microsoft (soon to be going full speed into their own chip designs on the down-low because qualcomm is sputtering), etc. The companies like Boeing and Intel are failing because MBAs with no engineering backgrounds completed their coups in the last decade and have purged any engineering promotions in their orgs. They are entirely 100% profit milking companies now.
- addled 6y agoConspiracy theory: Intel is using their deeper pockets to buy up TSMC fab capacity in an effort to slow AMD production. Doing so gets them breathing room to improve their own manufacturing process before TSMC can bring on enough capacity to serve both of them fully.
- tpmx 6y agoDeeper pockets than Apple?
- striking 6y agoDeeper pockets than AMD. All other assumptions holding true, Intel doesn't need to outrun the bear...
- tpmx 6y agoPlease expand.
- dogma1138 6y agoThe pockets aren’t deep enough... TSMC knows Intel is a competitor which AMD isn’t so any deal they’ll sign will be temporary at best. They aren’t exactly struggling to find customers as every wafer they have is spoken for 6 times over. If anything at least as far as TSMC goes Intel would have to pay through the nose for any capacity.
- TakuYam 6y agoI’m mildly irked by this but only because there will be more than a few people who will believe this to in response to the dreadful letter from Third Point.
- mhh__ 6y agoIf the play is to use a different fab for about 5 years maximum then plough forward with their own, then I think it's a good strategy. If Intel can get a good design onto 5nm relatively quickly, they can at very least curbstomp AMD's current single-thread lead until their new nodes come online. Intel are something like 20% behind in single-threaded work now, despite being still stuck on lithography somewhere between 4 and 5 times less dense. Moving away from fabrication is really dangerous, forcing yourself to pull your trousers down and face the music is a good thing in the long run. Ultimately this is a question of whether the leadership have got the bottle.
- jonplackett 6y ago> despite being still stuck on lithography somewhere between 4 and 5 times less dense That seems a bit high, I know it's 14nm vs 5nm but they're not real numbers anymore, and even that would only be 3X. Don't get me wrong though, Intel are still screwed. Even if they get 5nm in 5 years, where will TSMC be then?
- mhh__ 6y agoYou can (and should, I'm slightly surprised it's so uncommon "even on HN") look up the actual transistor density on Wikipedia - Intel are still stuck on 37.5 MTr/mm^2, TSMC cutting edge is much more than that and Intel 10nm is about 100 MTr/mm^2. So the actual number is between 3 and 5 depending on if you compare with AMD on Apple. You have to realize that all the fabs (and Intel) have multiple nodes on the go at any given time, the progression isn't completely serial - they've basically failed this generation but that doesn't mean that they won't be back up there if they nail the next one.
- wmf 6y agoIntel's 7 nm process has also essentially failed; it's years behind schedule.
- jonplackett 6y agoI stand corrected! For reference, TSMC's 5nm is 173. I almost feel bad for Intel. Almost.
- bgorman 6y agoWhy doens't Intel just pay Samsung a lot of money to license their methodology for the latest nodes? This worked for Globalfoundries back in the day.
- bcrl 6y agoMy biggest fear of fallout from something like this is that Intel could flex their financial muscle with TSMC and squash AMD just as they're pulling ahead. It wouldn't take much for Intel to buy out all of TSMC's available wafer starts...
- pengaru 6y agoTSMC has some say in the matter. If they view Intel as a competitor and AMD as a long-term customer which would seem rational, why would they blindly auction their capacity to the highest bidder of the two? Frankly I'm more concerned with Apple's deep pockets continuously monopolizing TSMC production.
- bcrl 6y agoI think Apple is in some ways a better customer for TSMC than AMD is. Apple has far longer lead times than AMD since they're producing a fully assembled system. AMD seems to be short on supply with the launch of every new generation, and it feels like they have been underestimating demand. It's a good problem to have, but difficult to handle without having piles of cash on hand.
- pengaru 6y agoFor TSMC? perhaps. For customers? Absolutely not. I have zero interest in a future where Apple produces the only general purpose computers containing state of the art silicon.
- CameronNemo 6y agoI would think TSMC also wants a diverse CPU design market. The higher competition decreases design margins, leaving more profit margin for the comparatively monopolized fabrication.
- davrosthedalek 6y agoIt would be terrible news if a new CPU/GPU is not in short supply at launch. The short-term short supply generates the long-term short supply :)
- icefrakker 6y agoIt's funny how people never learn. It is absolutely imperative that Intel continue manufacturing. You people are making the exact same arguments American companies used when they outsourced manufacturing to China. Now China is the world's factory and they call the shots as the west kowtows. I don't understand how users here can have such a fear of Facebook or apple while blithely supporting policies that would make you slaves to foreign interests. Y'all are so myopic.