3 ms·
"This is a complex situation that few or none of us are properly equipped to resolve." This is, in fact, not a complex situation. Law is not a magic, unknowna
by patio11 16y ago
"This is a complex situation that few or none of us are properly equipped to resolve."
This is, in fact, not a complex situation. Law is not a magic, unknownable realm populated by wizards who have the sole ability to understand what it means. Hard questions in law are hard questions, like hard questions in engineering are hard questions, but this is not a hard question. It's only a hard question if you are ignorant of the law or are intellectually committed to law not working the way law actually works.
Printing a check which exceeds one's granted authority is, with absolute certainty, a crime. You seem to be hung up on the notion that the payroll company can print one check and, therefore, if it prints two checks, check #2 is kinda grey-area authorized. The law does not see things that way: if you're knowingly printing extra checks to with the extent of stealing from their account, it is screamingly illegal.
I mean, want to look at an actual law? Here you go, MA General Law Chapter 267 (Forgery and Crimes Against the Currency) Section 1 (False or forged records, certificates, returns, attestations and other writings)
"Section 2. Whoever, with intent to injure or defraud, falsely makes, alters, forges or counterfeits a railroad ticket, railroad mileage book or railroad pass, or a ticket, badge, pass or any written or printed license purporting to entitle the holder or owner thereof to admission to any exhibition, entertainment, performance, match or contest of any kind, shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for not more than three years or in jail for not more than two years, or by a fine of not more than five hundred dollars."
This is really not ambiguous. Was it unpredictable that this was the law in MA? No.
If one hypothetically believes that this case does not qualify as "falsely makes" or that the bad actor here didn't have "intent to ... defraud", one is wrong. One is not just a little wrong, or arguably wrong, or sort of grey area wrong.
- ynniv 16y agoI think that we have a fundamental misunderstanding here. My stance is that the wrongdoing is not "fraud" because the passes which were sold were in fact valid passes for which the MBTA was not compensated. You seem to be interpreting my statements as claiming there was no wrongdoing, which isn't my claim. Law is not a magic, unknownable realm populated by wizards who have the sole ability to understand what it means. Law is not magic. But I am not a lawyer, and I don't think that many lawyers, let alone those who specialize in criminal prosecution or even intellectual property read Hacker News. Hence my claim that this is a complex issue for "us" to engage in, for which "we" are not fully qualified. My interest in this stems from the notion that we should be informed of the society we live in, and that Hacker News comment threads are places of philosophical discussion. Also, the Hacker News article uses the term "forged" instead of the article's "fake", and I think that both of these are incorrect. The passes produced were clearly valid, but unauthorized. If one hypothetically believes that this case does not qualify as "falsely makes" or that the bad actor here didn't have "intent to ... defraud", one is wrong. One is not just a little wrong, or arguably wrong, or sort of grey area wrong. I apparently lack your swagger. Given that the MBTA could not differentiate these passes from the ordinary pass, I claim that these passes are not "falsely made". In every way they behave as stolen passes, but not fake ones. Why does this matter? I suppose that I care because the headline "Forged Subway Passes" is the only reason this article belongs on Hacker News. But given that these are more "stolen" than "forged", there is nothing technically interesting about this event and it doesn't really belong here. But our discussion has been interesting, because you have presented compelling arguments that this is actually fraud. I still believe that it is not, but the process of arguing has made me develop my intuition of something that I wouldn't normally have cared about. I certainly wouldn't have realized that I thought the event was theft and not fraud.