11 ms·
Signal AMA on Reddit
- dyingkneepad 6y agoAfter installing the phone version, I just tried the Desktop version on Debian. It doesn't work: fails to connect because none of the machines I have (even the Windows one!) is able to trust the digital certificate from https://textsecure-service.whispersystems.org/v1/config https://textsecure-service.whispersystems.org/v1/config . I mean, I could try to add the certificate to the exception list, but when it comes to stuff like Signal I feel I shouldn't be doing any of this at all. And their website has no mention about adding certificates to my chain. I wanna try to move away from Whatsapp too, but when your "Secure" app fails to work because no one trusts your digital certificate, I inevitably start questioning your claims of both quality and security... Everybody will stick to the old product if the new one isn't polished....
- TheChaplain 6y agoElementApp/Matrix might be a better option?
- driminicus 6y agoThe matrix signal bridge is pretty great too!
- kitkat_new 6y agoMatrix definitely would fit more into the world of Linux: independence, decentralization & Community
- akvadrako 6y agoWhat are you doing? That is a self-signed certificate, so your computer shouldn't trust it. Yet the Desktop apps work fine. Maybe your version of Signal is too old?
- dyingkneepad 6y agoI just launched the Dekstop app from their Debian apt repository. It says "Something went wrong! Failed to connect to server." and then the Debug Log contains stuff such as: FetchError: request to https://textsecure-service.whispersystems.org/v1/config https://textsecure-service.whispersystems.org/v1/config failed, reason: unable to verify the first certificate
- vengefulduck 6y agoIt’s probably outdated, I know Debian is pretty conservative when it comes to package updates, have you tried getting it from signal directly?
- teekert 6y agoDistro repos are notorious for containing super out of date stuff (especially when it comes to these kinds of apps). It's why we now have flatpack, AppImage and Snaps. Always check the version numbers when using repo stuff.
- Joeboy 6y agoBit of a stab in the dark here, but are you sure the repo is enabled and you're getting updates? I just realized I was using an outdated version because Ubuntu disables third party repos when upgrading.
- m_b 6y agoThe Signal Desktop app you are trying to install must be somehow outdated, the desktop apps I use are working perfectly (both GNU/Linux and macOS) and I never encountered this issue. Maybe try to get some help from the community? https://community.signalusers.org/ https://community.signalusers.org/
- searchableguy 6y agoCould you check the version of signal desktop app? I installed signal desktop app just now. It's 1.139.4 - Do you have the same?
- Joeboy 6y agoJust upgraded mine and it says v1.39.4. Suspect you might have a spurious 1 in there.
- searchableguy 6y agoThanks for the correction.
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoDownload and install from here https://signal.org/download/ https://signal.org/download/ I use it on Debian. Works fine.
- Daniel_sk 6y agoQ: "Is there any plans to make user ID system, so that we can add friends without knowing the phone numbers?" A: Yes, we're working on it.
- ljlolel 6y agohe mentioned this when he was on Joe Rogan
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoHaven't Signal been saying that for something like three years now?
- hbhstx05q8tf 6y agoIt's certainly been a while. And I've never heard anything reassuring about what they're planning; I half expect if/when we get anything that it'll be just as useless to me as the existing system. I don't actually trust Signal to deliver the features I need, and the lengthy timelines certainly don't help. I don't think I know of any messenger at all that does what I want, and that's kinda sad.
- CarelessExpert 6y agoYes, though if you're paying attention to the protocol changes recently, you'll see it's actually true. There's been the introduction of a UID for user identifiers, a brand new group chat protocol, etc. So the work is happening. But it's pretty major surgery, so it takes time.
- godelski 6y agoSomeone recently posted a code snippet where it was in a new release. They also said this year which is a change from the past.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoI switched to Signal way before. And then Elon Musk recommended Signal to all and sundry on Twitter. And then that got retweeted by Jack Dorsey. Now..I am a little worried. Do I want anything that has Jack’s paw prints on it. Since he and Zuckerberg turned up like creepy ideological twins at the senate hearings, I can’t tell them apart. The first question on the Reddit AMA resonates. WhatsApp was great before FB bought that out. Who is to say it won’t repeat with Signal and someone else?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- metaxis78 6y agoSignal is well documented and the client is open source. They've done an excellent job making e2e chat accessible to everyone. But, that's always an inherent risk. I believe signal to be one of the best options right now. However, I'm also running a matrix server and working to convert my friends to that. These challenges are never going to stop, but federated messaging is a big step forward.
- r00fus 6y agoDid WhatsApp release their protocol openly with an open source reference client/server? Or did I miss that part? Having an exit plan makes me less concerned about a centralized service - if FB/TWT/etc buy Signal many parties are strongly incentivized to fork the code and provide migration paths.
- skinkestek 6y agoWhatsApp had some real issues and then it seemed they cleaned it up. It seems every mainstream researcher now agree that the message delivery part of WhatsApps is now trustworthy. That said the metadata and incentives story is about as bad as it can get[1] and in the backup department your chats can be uploaded wholesale to iCloud and/or Google Cloud if one of your contacts from the same conversations enable cloud backup. [1]: Owned by Facebook and they shut off the revenue stream so the only way they can make money from it is by squeezing it of the metadata they get or introduce ads.
- tethys 6y agoWhy are they making such a big secret about their user numbers? https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_private_messenger_team_here_we_support_an/gikq8ma/ https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_p...
- eznzt 6y agoJudging by the amount of people on my contacts list who are on Signal, I have a theory.
- searchableguy 6y agoWhat is it? Spill the beans.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI think OP is implying that there may be more beans in the can to be spilled than there are signal users. Probably signal occupies a far greater mind share than it's userbase actually warrants. If they say they have 10000 DAUs, more people will write it off as worthless rather than he interested in trying it.
- skinkestek 6y agoMy thought as well. I have 8 contacts on Telegram, one(!) conversation. Meanwhile everyone from family and friends is at Telegram now and used to be on WhatsApp. I wish Signal all the best: it is totally impressive, they got their incentives aligned totally unlike WhatsApp and to a larger degree than Telegram I think. Personally I'm rooting for Matrix, but for now, based on my limited understanding Signal seems to hit the sweet spot where "kind of easy to use" overlaps to a large degree with "trustworthy".
- zaq1 6y agoIn this video, Rob Braxman argues that most Matrix users use either Matrix.org or Element.io servers (may have gotten the names wrong). Matrix is a federation in theory but not in practice, so it's not good for privacy. What do you think? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ke8pXQQPaIw&t=623 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ke8pXQQPaIw&t=623
- almost_usual 6y agoGreat, closer to not having to explain to friends and family that I’m not a tinfoil hat person.
- rriepe 6y agoYeah that's not how it works. Welcome to the outgroup.
- fsflover 6y agoI hope someone asks all those questions from the other HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25686179 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25686179.
- meowster 6y agoBetter link (with the old.* in the URL): https://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_private_messenger_team_here_we_support_an/ https://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_p...
- soupson 6y agoAll, Signal is a 501c3 nonprofit. Your company probably matches donations. If they don't, they are eligible to be added to your company's portal. I encourage you to throw some of your wealth their way and take the extra step to get matching. This is important.
- adammenges 6y agogood point
- christefano 6y agoGreat call to action. With other nonprofits I would immediately agree, matching is important. Is Signal in more need than other nonprofits, though? I imagine they’re still sitting on some of the $40 million the Signal Foundation got from Brian Acton, former WhatApp CEO.
- nostromo 6y ago> we've structured the project as a non-profit entity, so it can never be bought, has no investors, and isn't "owned" by anyone Never is a long time. Non-profits can become for-profits. Non-profits can also spin off of their profitable components as for-profits -- just like the Mozilla Corporation is a for-profit owned by the non-profit Mozilla Foundation. Non-profits can sell ads and sell your data. And, of course, non-profits can get money hungry just like any other organization. Look at how ICANN has found ways to vacuum up billions of dollars from the internet. They also may not technically have any investors, but they have a de facto investor in the form a $100m loan from WhatsApp founder Brian Acton who is also on the board. He could have made it a gift, but did not -- which implies he wants the money back at some point. Signal will need a lot of donations to pay that money back -- or they could decide to sell ads or data. All that said, I'm happy Signal is doing well, and applaud their efforts. I hope they succeed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leoplct 6y agoIf it will be, we will switch again as done with WhatsApp. What’s problem? They have invested years giving it for free, now the ask the price (data) and users go away.
- SebastianKra 6y agoWhatsApp proves that switching away from an unfavorable service is not as easy as you think. It is still essential in many countries, and many users, including myself, are unable to switch. This is why companies first offer a product for free to gain a user base, and only then think about monetization.
- crossroadsguy 6y agoIt also proves that it will never be easy and the choice is just move away or suck it up. I decided just to move away. Like I did with Fb and Insta. If needed I will do that again - away from Signal.
- qznc 6y agoNo surprising news but I learned about https://signalstickers.com/ https://signalstickers.com/
- christefano 6y agoSurprising for me. I just shared the link with my COVID pod, and I’m giddy for the mayhem to begin. Thanks for the link!
- raylad 6y agoIs it documented (and provable) what happens when the Signal app is given access to Contacts and then verifies which of them is a Signal user? It seems that some information would be revealed in that process that could be mined to eventually de-anonymize people based on relationship networks (assuming nothing easier is possible). Does anyone here know if there's any reason not feel that is a serious vulnerability?
- anjbe 6y ago>Is it documented Yes, it’s documented: https://signal.org/blog/private-contact-discovery/ https://signal.org/blog/private-contact-discovery/ >(and provable) As the post says, their non‐SGX method requires you to trust the server: “This has meant that if you trust the Signal service to be running the published server source code, then the Signal service has no durable knowledge of a user’s social graph if it is hacked or subpoenaed.” To eliminate that requirement, they developed an SGX‐based method: “Since the enclave attests to the software that’s running remotely, and since the remote server and OS have no visibility into the enclave, the service learns nothing about the contents of the client request. It’s almost as if the client is executing the query locally on the client device.” Of course, there are plenty of attacks on SGX (I’m not enough of a cryptographer to know how practical they are to apply to Signal’s methods or not); but at some level you are going to have to trust servers you don’t control, whether your system is federated or centralized. I’m mostly willing to give Moxie the benefit of the doubt here.
- bluefox 6y agoWhy do Signal releases contain an expiration time bomb? That is, why is the user forced to update in order to use the application, even if no critical security issues arose? The passage of time is not a good excuse for a mandatory update.
- anjbe 6y ago> That is, why is the user forced to update in order to use the application, even if no critical security issues arose? Because they’re adding new features, both security improvements and user‐facing sugar. Moxie’s thoughts on this are well‐known: he believes he can build a better and more secure messenger by keeping deployed clients as closely aligned as possible. Even if you disagree (and plenty of people disagree, as we see in almost every Signal comment thread), it’s at least a valid opinion to hold. https://signal.org/blog/the-ecosystem-is-moving/ https://signal.org/blog/the-ecosystem-is-moving/
- bluefox 6y agoSo when Signal decides to stop supporting your device, you're left with no choice but to get a new one. So there's no point in auditing a Signal release. So as Signal becomes more and more disagreeable (something that's bound to happen with any actively changing software), you're forced to take it or leave it. It's a trap. I am a user of Signal, and have been using it for a number of years now, but this concern remains.
- rakoo 6y agoUntil you have a contract with someone explicitely saying what you want and what you don't want, no one owes you anything. Signal creators are doing it this way because they decided it's the best way to bring the best cryptography available to the masses, considering that they don't earn any money.
- shafyy 6y agoI'm a bit worried that the CEO is so vehemently against federation [0]: > It is unlikely that we will ever federate with any servers outside of our control again, it makes changes really difficult. I think as long as there is no federation there will always be the "benevolent dictator" situation, which often doesn't end up well in the long run. At the same time, I'm sure that I couldn't convince my non-tech friends to switch over to a federated protocol like Matrix. The clients have been getting better, but they still lack a lot of mainstream UX. So, while Signal is better than WhatsApp for now, I think the only sensible solution is a federated protocol. 0: https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37#issuecomment-217231557 https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37#issueco...
- kitsunesoba 6y agoAside from network effects, UI/UX is really king when it comes to getting people to switch messengers. It's why Telegram has managed to stake as large of a following as it has, despite its glaring flaws when compared to Signal, Matrix, etc. I understand wanting to focus on security and privacy at the cost of all else, but if the goal is to get as many people on a reasonably safe messenger app as possible, UI/UX is unavoidably going to be a focal point — it can't just be made an afterthought, or as is the case with many FOSS projects disregarded almost entirely.
- oehtXRwMkIs 6y agoI would argue that Element on android is really good in terms of UI/UX. But I think the desktop experience is definitely behind others, and I have no idea how the iOS client is like.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoI haven't used Element on iOS extensively, but in my limited experience it's "ok" but not stellar. It has a number of papercuts like the registration and login screens not hooking the password manager API and thus not offering password generation services, ability to save/restore from password manager, etc. On that front I think the iOS version of Signal is probably better.
- dirtylowprofile 6y agoWow the Reddit website is painfully slow.
- brobinson 6y agoTry using the 'old' subdomain: https://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_private_messenger_team_here_we_support_an/ https://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_p... It's a lot faster for me and also more information-dense.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- permille42 6y agoThey say now they are working on letting people sign up without having to use a phone number. I've hated this about Signal since first beginning to use it. Forcing everyone to use a phone number makes it so much harder to have a partially anonymous way to communicate. I can't help but feel this was intentional to prevent use by those wishing to remain anonymous. I don't believe they'll ever actually do this. If they could have they would have done so already imo. Perhaps they are fighting whatever restrictions force them to do this. We can only hope. My belief is that various governments prevent Signal from allowing anonymous registrations and will continue to prevent them from allowing it. I expect that what they will allow is something like "you can now register with a gmail account". That is the same restriction since you need a phone number to register for a gmail account these days.