5 ms·
Science’s Demons, from Descartes to Darwin and Beyond
- threeden 6y ago> Most of us would consider the discriminatory insurance demon to be truly demonic, but, in general, scientific demons simply represent gaps in our existing knowledge, anthropomorphic accounts of the unknown or the unexplained. Given their aspirational quality—a longing toward greater understanding—these roles might at first seem better filled by angels. But, because they often represent theories that violate laws of time or space, machines that exceed human capacities, and technologies that threaten human existence, the use of demons feels appropriate; their very identity suggests the workings of a mischievous or malevolent force This characterization of the supernatural being is irrelevant to their nature. > Canales quotes a computer scientist at Microsoft who argued that Internet and finance companies today “are trying to become Maxwell’s demons in an information network.” His example was a health-insurance company using Big Data to sort desirable customers from undesirable customers That’s a cute thought experiment albeit not directly the of the same kind previously discussed. This person is clearly discussing aggregated human effects, nothing hard to prove there. > This strange being disappears entirely from the final version of “On the Origin of Species,” where only the theory of natural selection appears, absent any miraculous causes or supernatural forces. Makes you wonder if the publication would have received the same attention had this part not being removed from the final revision. > Still, among those who studied it more closely, Maxwell’s demon has inspired new technologies and theories in fields as diverse as chemistry, cosmology, nanotechnology, neuroscience, and cybernetics. The article, albeit being a great summary, does little effort to acknowledge the difference between demons being merely analogies for the unknown versus being the catalyst of new ways to tame nature.
- chrischapman 6y ago2,665,866,746,644 is my new favorite number.
- harscoat 6y agoSocrate's demon not mentioned? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daemon_(classical_mythology)#Socrates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daemon_(classical_mythology)#S...
- gshubert17 6y agoPerhaps the difference is that according to the article, the scientific demons are explanatory metaphors, presumed to be imaginary; and according to Plato, Socrates acted like his daemon is real? [edit, wording and punctuation]
- B1FF_PSUVM 6y ago"According to such taxonomies, demons were a busy bunch, tasked with everything from promoting quarrels, discord, and war (the work of a demon called Bufas) to inserting errors into the manuscripts of scribes and keeping tabs on the mispronunciations of preachers during worship (the work of Titivillus)." I'll say the old theology (with deities, etc.) had more amusing bits than the modern scientific theology, which tends to be dour and self-righteous. (But, hey, miracles now are a lot cheaper ...)
- sradman 6y agoA review of Jimena Canales’ book Bedeviled: A Shadow History of Demons in Science [1]: > They are not supernatural creatures; rather, they are particular kinds of thought experiments, placeholders of sorts for laws or theories or concepts not yet understood. [1] https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691175324/bedeviled https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691175324/be...