6 ms·
iMessage seems to be a bit dishonest, because Apple, the owner, has way more information about you through iCloud and Apple ID - contacts, location, payment dat
by izacus 6y ago
iMessage seems to be a bit dishonest, because Apple, the owner, has way more information about you through iCloud and Apple ID - contacts, location, payment data, phone number, etc.
Forcing Facebook to clearly list all of this for the facebook account is great, but then failing to disclose this for their own account seems like double standard.
Just like having their own separate Ad Tracking switch which is on by default. (And even hidden under "System Services" on macOS!)
- pram 6y agoIt has its own section in the Privacy tab, which is exactly where I'd expect to find it. Hidden in plain sight maybe
- izacus 6y agoIt seems to be hidden enough that it's not added to this comparison.
- katbyte 6y agoThat may be true but I disabled that a long time ago and it’s _stayed_ turned off across multiple ios upgrades. Unlike others os/phones where such things are turned on at every opportunity
- izacus 6y agoHmm, I'm being badgered to reenable iCloud on every single minor iOS update and rather commonly on macOS as well. Are you sure you were never asked about it?
- manyxcxi 6y agoI have iCloud turned on but it’s set to only sync Notes or something trivial like that that I don’t even use- I can’t recall ever having been badgered for more. Maybe I got to that state because I was being badgered? It’s been long enough though I can’t recall. Might be worth a shot if the risk is acceptable enough to you vs the badger.
- izacus 6y agoI'll try it, but it was mostly for family members who didn't have any use for any of the cloud products.
- joshspankit 6y agoI don't entirely agree with you here, but I do agree that Apple should be leading by example here and putting their privacy warnings exactly where they expect everyone else to. I want to be prompted for whether iMessage can be tied to data collected from other apps, or whether I should allow “Find my” to “continue accessing location in the background”. For me, it would go a long way towards seeing Apple as not just trying to leverage their platform to be anti-competitive, but as a company who is honestly protecting my privacy.
- manyxcxi 6y agoI’m not an apologist or shill, but as a user I feel like I understand what I’m giving to Apple (or Microsoft/Google/$OS_VENDOR) when I am using their OS _AND_ enabling any kind of cloud sync. Maybe they’re taking more or less than I expected, but if I’m syncing my entire contact list I just have to assume now they have my contact list- and I accepted that when I enabled the functionality. Some feature flags/settings across all the OSes get hidden, are non-obvious, on by default, or are flat out using dark patterns (looking at you Win10) but in general I assume the default state (for all OSes) is a combination of reducing support incidents, easiest on-boarding, and trying to push some corporate strategic objective summed up as keep the average user happy enough to stick around and possibly give us more money. Any app I install on said OS, may want to access this information but without all the permissions explainers I have no idea what it’s going to want or why. Again, I assume the OS has access to all of this because it’s the OS it either needs it or is the manager of the info and access broker. To sum up my thought, I guess I agree that there’s a double standard but disagree that it’s necessarily bad or shady- but that’s because I already had a double standard in mind when I think about OS vs App. Specific to ad-tracking and Apple: I have no proof for my belief but I believe Apple who primarily wants to sell me hardware and has made public acknowledgements of the importance of privacy, including making noticeable improvements to their OS, is significantly less likely to abuse my privacy than any other OS vendor out there. I’m not saying this as a whataboutism, I just base it on my perceptions given all the things you just flat out can’t turn off in Win10 and that Google literally makes their money off of getting ads to your eyeballs and Android’s permissions are a dumpster fire nightmare for privacy. I feel (again, no real proof) that the Apple eco-system is providing me the best _mainstream and low-effort_ steps to privacy protection vs the others, but I concede that it’s probably not good enough in many ways.
- everdrive 6y ago>iMessage seems to be a bit dishonest, because Apple, the owner, has way more information about you through iCloud and Apple ID - contacts, location, payment data, phone number, etc. But do they bring all that data together, correlate it, and sell it?
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoA government agency can still order them to hand over all data they have, they are still a single point of failure from a privacy point of view.
- everdrive 6y agoI think that's fair, but is certainly a different concern than what facebook is doing.
- tinus_hn 6y agoIt is debatable what that data includes but even if true it isn’t what these labels are about. The list shows purposes and types of data and Facebook declares they use all that data for the purposes of tracking, advertising and analytics.
- grishka 6y agoYou can't know that. The moment it reaches their servers, you are not in control of what actually happens to it.
- izacus 6y agoCan any app on AppStore avoid declaring those flags if they say in their marketing that they don't sell it? Or why does it matter for Apple and not for them?
- shuckles 6y agoData used to track you is gathered separately from data linked to you.
- 6y ago
- tinus_hn 6y agoOn iOS your location data, as far as Apple has it, is not associated with you or your device but with an identifier that is changed weekly. If you choose to use iCloud to store your contacts (and you can choose any other service that implements the carddav standard) Apple declares the information is transmitted and stored encrypted and can’t be used for any other purpose. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303
- suprfsat 6y agoApple shares iCloud backups with law enforcement.
- Humdeee 6y agoI don't get this take. Your bank, employer, ISP, pretty much any tech company, etc. would also share your data with law enforcement if court ordered.
- iknowstuff 6y agoIf you ask around people feel like they have more privacy when using apple products, yet the truth is they all use iCloud backups, iCloud photos and iCloud drive, none of which are E2EE. Meanwhile, Google does allow for E2EE in cloud Android backups! iMessage can be MITM’d by Apple when requested by the government and you, the user, will have no way of verifying your correspondent’s public key (unlike whatsapp, signal, keybase etc).
- jiveturkey 6y agoexcept apple has the tech to not be able to share it. they use this for some of your data. but intentionally not for icloud. it’s probably nothing to do with USA law enforcement. my reasonable guess is they don’t care much and would go full private. i think the reason here is china. that way they don’t have to have a separate china policy which would draw undue attention to that point.
- 6y ago
- jiofih 6y agoThe data listed for FB Messenger is taken directly from your phone and explicitly used for advertising and “other purposes”. If you added what Facebook has access to from your account it would cover two entire pages. Apples and.. blueberries?
- simonh 6y agoThose have nothing to do with iMessage though. If they aded them to the iMessage list people would naturally think that if they didn't use iMessage those things would be disabled, which is not true, so what you're asking for would be highly misleading and disingenuous.
- np_tedious 6y agoThat's the point, it's not about iMessage but it is about Apple. So to include Facebook things that are not necessarily Facebook Messenger things makes the comparison oranges-apples misleading
- simonh 6y agoYou're misunderstanding the warning on WhatsApp, those are the actual information specifically exposed by WhatsApp itself. The one for iMessage lists all the information specifically exposed by iMessage, so they are equivalent.
- jiveturkey 6y ago> iMessage seems to be a bit dishonest i like to call it end to end to end encryption. i came up with that for zoom but it applies to iMessage as well.
- S_A_P 6y agoClaims that company x oversteps privacy boundaries is often met with oh yeah? But Apple isn’t perfect. I agree, and I think there is room to push Apple to be a bigger advocate for privacy. Currently I think they are arguably doing the best job of this, however and pointing the finger at other people doing the same or similar behavior is not really an excuse. Pointing out hypocrisy doesn’t excuse bad behavior.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 6y agoAlso, last I checked iMessage was automatically backed to the iCloud when iCloud sync is enabled and you couldn't specifically disable the iMessage syncing alone. Is that still the case? Because in effect that makes the E2EE of iMessage irrelevant for 90% of iPhone users.
- shoo_pl 6y ago>iMessage seems to be a bit dishonest Maybe I misinterpret the idea behind this list. To me, its not listing all the things that the company knows about you, its listing all the information that app reads about you. In other terms, this is what Apple knows when I disable the iCloud and only use iMessage. And this is what Facebook knows when I only use it though that messenger and nothing else.
- whoisjuan 6y agoThat’s not it at all. If you have iMessage in your phone it’s completely tied to Apple whole data gathering context because your phone is made by Apple. I understand what you’re saying. If the App is only collecting certain amount of information on its own, then they should only list that right? ... But that’s unfair with the rest of the vendors because they are forced to list everything they track, while iMessage obscures it by saying “the app doesn’t collect anything”...yet the phone is and iMessage is the default messaging system for iOS. I’m a loyal Apple user but this is anti-competitive behavior. As much as I love Apple’s privacy focus, it seems that they’re using it as a proxy to unfairly compete with other companies and claim that they only care about the end’s user privacy, which is clearly not true. Apple does and will use your data to push Apple products. They should be transparent about that.
- ogre_codes 6y agoAnti-competitive for what? Apple's News+ advertising empire? App Store advertising? Is there any evidence at all that they cross pollinate data in either of these contexts? If so, it certainly isn't clear based on the advertising I see in News+ Much of the stuff you are complaining about is "collected" because it's needed by other services. The real question is whether the data is reasonably siloed and how easy it is for Apple or third party's (governments, etc) to access and abuse.
- pertymcpert 6y ago> Apple does and will use your data to push Apple products. They should be transparent about that. Explain how?