8 ms·
It's really hard to tell with Facebook if they understand that their massive data collection is at least morally questionable, and they business plan is simply
by mrweasel 6y ago
It's really hard to tell with Facebook if they understand that their massive data collection is at least morally questionable, and they business plan is simply a calculated risk. Given that most people seem to care more about free services, than they do about privacy, Facebook may see privacy labelling is a pointless exercise that won't change anything anyway.
Or perhaps we are back at Upton Sinclair: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." and Facebook as an organisation is simply unable to acknowledge the problem, because doing so would ruin them.
- DSingularity 6y agoIf Facebook charged 2$ a month for their services, would they not make more than their operational costs? They choose to exploit and straddle areas that are morally and legally dubious because they want more money.
- skocznymroczny 6y agoThey'd lose many users. $2 a month might not be a lot, but any non-zero amount of money is a barrier for users. On one side some users might not have an easy way to pay, others will still have to reconsider whether Facebook itself offers enough to be worth the $2 a month (even if it totally does). Also, a more likely outcome would be Facebook charging $2 a month on top of their usual data collection practices.
- mrweasel 6y agoThat's really the scary part, most people wouldn't pay $2 per month for Facebook. Most wouldn't pay the $1 for WhatsApp. That shows you how little value these services actually provide to most people. The remaining users wouldn't pay for year two, because to many others would have left the platform.
- CallMeMarc 6y agoDidn't WhatsApp actually cost like 1 EUR/year before FB bought it?
- mrweasel 6y agoIt did, first year free, then $1 per year, but I think many just created a new account, or WhatsApp perhaps didn't really enforce the payment much.
- akoncius 6y agoI think it was highly profitable business because before FB acquisition it was very small company (~100 people) compared to user base (hundreds of milions). but FB did acquisition not because of profits but because of userbase to collect more data. So to increase userbase even more, FB got rid of payment plans and made service for free. Edit: tried to google concrete numbers what revenue was back then, could not find any clear answer, because it was doing some juggling with stocks etc. https://techcrunch.com/2014/10/28/whatsapp-revenue/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/10/28/whatsapp-revenue/
- CallMeMarc 6y agoIIRC I even bought the app on the app store and then had some kind of "lifetime" plan, easier times
- fakedang 6y agoYep, first year free, then $1 payment, but if you wanted, you could just uninstall, reinstall and it would reset the entire schedule. Acton and Koum really wanted it to be something different than what it is now.
- akoncius 6y agoas far as I remember - yes, it was 1 dollar/euro per year after first year for free.
- durovo 6y agoMost wouldn't pay because there are alternative free services with a somewhat similar model. This analysis would be more interesting if all these 'free' alternatives go away.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoWhat would be interesting if they offered an ad free option - like Amazon Kindle, youtube etc. Back of the envelope calculation suggests they make about $2 a month from each user (~$70B revenue/year divided by ~2.7B active users/month)
- SCNP 6y agoI would love this if I trusted any online service to maintain the paid option as truly ad-free over time but I've been burned by the TV industry too many times. Ad creep ruins every paid service and ultimately just drives the price up.
- Spivak 6y ago* Offering an ad-free version devalues their ad network so it would end up being more tha $2/mo. * Even if they didn't show you ads they have no reason to not still obsessively track you and monetize that data in other ways.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoYes, but if they continue to hemorrhage users they may come to wish they were making $2/user. Long term, Facebook is dead. Perhaps internally they know that and are already planning for it.
- SCNP 6y agoThis is kind of my point, too. Free market will incentivize getting money both ways so without regulation, this is what we get. And I hate it.
- seppin 6y agoI don't value Facebook at $2 a month, I bet most people don't either.
- LdSGSgvupDV 6y agoSounds like cheaper version of linkedin.
- hairofadog 6y agoA family member recently relayed the story of his kid begging for $20 for a “bunny suit” Fortnight skin and how he, the adult, slowly came to understand that the skin didn’t even do anything; it just ever-so-slightly changed how the game looked (which I already knew, but his exasperation was amusing). We were like, huh. Kids today. Anyway, for reasons I don’t totally understand, in my experience this dad’s bunny-suit exasperation is how most people feel about paying for software of any kind. It’s not just frugality but indignation at the very idea that they be asked to pay for software.
- jpttsn 6y agoWhat does a real world bunny suit do that a Fortnite bunny suit doesn't?
- hairofadog 6y agoTERRIFY CHILDREN
- germinalphrase 6y agoFor one, you own it - so you can sell it when it’s no longer amusing.
- conistonwater 6y agoDo you mean to say there is a market for used bunny suits? I think 'jpttsn might have a point specifically with respect to useless nonsense products.
- germinalphrase 6y agoWhether or not anyone wants to purchase is a separate concern from the fact of ownership. Edit: there are approx. 1000 used bunny suits for sale on EBay, so...
- sbierwagen 6y ago
- berkeleyjunk 6y agoFacebook made approximately $30 (USD) per user in advertising revenue last year. I think the bigger issue (IMHO) is that the people who are prepared to pay to not be profiled are the people who are the most valuable to advertise to. i.e. they are worth way more than $30 in revenue per year.
- thatguy0900 6y agoOn the other hand, the people willing to pay to not be profiled are probably already using adblockers and piholes everywhere they can, no?
- Nextgrid 6y agoFacebook is relatively immune to ad blockers as most Facebook, WhatsApp & Instagram usage is mobile (and why Instagram's web version is very bare-bones and lacks critical functionality).
- thatguy0900 6y agoThat's fair. I'm still using Firefox mobile with adblocking, so I didn't consider that.
- godzillabrennus 6y agoFacebook grosses about $22/user/year from their platform. If all users paid $2/month they’d be fine. Problem is, not many people would shell out $2/month to socialize online.
- FalconSensei 6y agoAlso, let's say I'm willing to pay $2 to use facebook and socialize with my friends. If 2 or 3 close(-ish) friends drop off because of that, facebook would no longer be worth $2, so I would also drop off
- chiefalchemist 6y agoIt's not hard. Clearly the understand. Their M.O. is predictable to a fault. These are not accidents. This should help. I immediately bought the book. https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/segments/living-under-surveillance-capitalism-on-the-media https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/segments/living-und...
- KaiserPro 6y agoI think you ascribe far to much skill and control to a company that clearly has little to no coordination.
- AlexandrB 6y agoOf the entire FAANG lineup, Facebook has the simplest chain of responsibility. Mark Zuckerberg is not only the CEO but owns a majority of voting shares. If he decided tomorrow that Facebook should prioritize user privacy, he could make it happen. Who's going to stop him? It's weird to describe this kind of corporate structure as one that has "little to no coordination".
- KaiserPro 6y agoI mean thats literally what he's doing now. the point is, no one believes him, or really listens to him. Its not Amazon where Bezos commands, and everyone jumps.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoPerhaps. But there is a common ends (i.e., profitting from data collection) and common means (i.e., Privacy? What's that??). There doesn't have to internal coordination any more than FB has to coordinate with (e.g.) Google. Priorities drive action.
- jliptzin 6y agoIf they can’t manage to charge $1 per user per month for their service then perhaps their service isn’t worth anything at all.
- seppin 6y agoTell that to FB and Linkedin's valuations.
- sbierwagen 6y agoAnd WeWork was worth $47 billion at peak. So?
- themacguffinman 6y agoBy that logic, is Wikipedia perhaps not worth anything at all? Monthly user subscriptions is not the only way to determine value.
- chongli 6y agoWikipedia is supported entirely by donations. I would hazard a guess that people who donate to Wikipedia consider it to be worth the money they choose to donate, and more.
- themacguffinman 6y agoSo, mostly worthless to the overwhelming majority of people who don't donate, and even more who donate less than the equivalent of $1/user/month? I'm aware that Wikipedia is supported by donations, that doesn't change the fact that Wikipedia is immensely valuable to many people even though they apparently can't manage to charge $1 per user per month for their service. In many ways, Wikipedia is so valuable because they don't charge their users.
- chongli 6y agoA lot of people in Canada don't pay anything for their health care and don't pay taxes either because they don't earn any income. I don't think it is reasonable to suggest these people think their health care is "worthless." The mistake here is conflating price with value. The price people are willing to pay is relative to their means. The value, on the other hand, is relative to the utility they derive from it. Moreover, there is an additional external utility accrued to society from having a better educated, healthier population.
- bhntr3 6y agoWell, you can't undelete data you didn't collect. So I think there's this natural tendency toward omnivorous data collection in every tech company. Then we rationalize it by telling ourselves that we use it ethically. It's almost always true . . . except when it's not. If 99% of the time the data is used ethically, it's easy to write off that 1% even when the 1% is all that matters.
- yrimaxi 6y ago> Given that most people seem to care more about free services, than they do about privacy, What a backwards analysis. A social platform that is not already popular is worthless to most people. They have no use for it. Hence they are definitely unwilling to pay for it before it gets popular; there is absolutely no incentive to. And, of course, once a social media platform _already_ is popular, it must have gotten to that point by operating at a loss.