9 ms·
Identical twins are not so identical, study suggests
- ravenstine 6y agoDid anyone really think that twins were the same right down to each individual gene? Just seems intuitive that there'd be some slight differences between identical twins.
- hprotagonist 6y agotwins? hell, you’ll see different sequences between individual cells in the same person.
- zinekeller 6y agoYes, it indeed happens on a non-chimeric person (just try comparing the DNA from a muscle in arms versus legs, or even head hair and genital hair). I don't know the point of the study (except if it is just to undeniably confirm this scientifically because some doctors still don't believe that identical twins are not quite identical).
- zxcb1 6y agoAnd then there is the microbiome ...
- irrational 6y agoWould the microbiome be similar growing up (assuming both are living and eating the same foods in the same places/family) and then diverge later when they go their separate ways?
- zxcb1 6y agoFrom what I understand, it is a continuous exchange with our environment, the same way we catch a disease.
- hobofan 6y agoI would assume that the point of the study is to also quantify the amount of mutations so that future twin-based studies can more accurately attribute differences that also exist between twin pairs.
- rootusrootus 6y agoThat's interesting. I wonder what the typical variation is within a single body, versus between monozygotic twins.
- leemailll 6y agoWell, I can give one well-known example for this in genetics. Females carry two X-chromosome, against male's X and Y. There is one thing called X-inactivation, which means one of the X chromosome in the cell is inactivated randomly in cells. By this, even organs only carried the same kind of cells are mosaic in aspect to genes in X chromosome. Then think about a well-know X-chromosome linked disease, the Rett Syndrome, and the cell in body, in the brain.
- williamdclt 6y agoWhy "intuitive"? It seems far from obvious that they'd be different when they come from the same sperm and egg cells. Does "anyone" really think that? I, who's well more versed in sciency things than the average although I never really thought about this particular subject, would have guessed that they have the same genetic code. So yes, I'd guess that a big proportion of people would think that
- tpmx 6y agohttps://archive.is/KrRq0 https://archive.is/KrRq0
- tpmx 6y agoI guess this about the large amount of research that has come out of things like https://ki.se/en/research/the-swedish-twin-registry https://ki.se/en/research/the-swedish-twin-registry - hence the comment from a Swedish geneticist in the article. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Twin_Registry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Twin_Registry > The Swedish Twin Registry (abbreviated STR) is a twin registry based at the Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm, Sweden. Originally established in the 1960s, it is the largest twin registry in the world. It is widely used for medical research, with about thirty active research projects using data from the study as of 2019. As of 2012, it contained a total of 194,000 twins, 75,000 of whom were of a known zygosity. In principle, it contains records of every twin born in Sweden since 1886. Edit: A fascinating list of publications from ~2000 and onwards: https://ki.se/en/media/84204/download https://ki.se/en/media/84204/download (PDF, 1100+ records)
- mrfusion 6y agoIs this just because of mutations after the twins have split? How else could it be possible
- betenoire 6y agothe article talks about this > They measured mutations that occurred during embryonic growth and found that identical twins differed by an average of 5.2 early developmental mutations. In 15% of twins, the number of diverging mutations was higher.
- refurb 6y agoExpression of genes is also driven by the external environment. Different environment (even minor differences) can result in different phenotypes despite the same genotype. That was the theory proposed as to why identical twins have different fingerprints. Slightly different conditions in the womb result in slightly different fingerprints.
- knicholes 6y agoSee: Himalayan rabbits. https://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/environmental-influences-on-gene-expression-536/#:~:text=Gene%20C%20controls%20fur%20pigmentation%20in%20Himalayan%20rabbits.&text=This%20temperature%20regulation%20of%20gene,be%20white%20(Figure%201) https://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/environmental-infl....
- jedimastert 6y agoThere are plenty of stochastic processes during gestation, right? Fingerprints come to mind, which aren't genetically linked at all
- MichaelZuo 6y agoYes, and there are epigenetic processes that also diverge in womb. In practice there are no identical babies, it’s a form of linguistic exaggeration.
- stretchcat 6y agoIt's my impression that identical twins do actually have similar (but not identical) fingerprints. Specifically, fingerprint patterns can be broken down into a few broad categories like 'loop' or 'whorl', and I've heard identical twins will often have the same patterns on the same fingers.
- m3kw9 6y agoIt is always only identical by name but they never look identical, i.e. complete replica.
- irrational 6y agoThough sometimes it takes awhile to see the differences. My daughter has friends who are identical twins and it took her years to be able to reliably tell them apart.
- PebblesHD 6y agoI happen to be an identical twin, with a sibling born a few minutes after myself. While we are quite similar through facial features and such, we have quite different personalities, skills, even things like allergies and sexualities which one would expect to be more biological in origin. We’ve been involved in a few studies regarding these differences but the results are yet to be published as the sample is populated. If you are a twin, I’d encourage you to get involved in research like that if you have the time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- buzzert 6y agoI too am an identical twin, and it's actually quite the opposite for us. My brother has nearly the same personality, skills, and medical ailments. In my experience from meeting other identical twins in high school, you're either basically the same or polar opposites. There's rarely a set of twins that are in-between (although perhaps one could say the differences in the polar opposite twins become less pronounced with age).
- Guest42 6y agoMy grandma and her identical twin had very similar personalities, skills, interests, and life choices. Even their voices were very similar.
- throwaway2048 6y agoAre you genetically tested to be identical twins? Sometimes fraternal twins look so similar they think they are identical, but they aren't.
- floitsch 6y agoThis is pretty rare. Almost all test of twins that are in doubt are identical. Don't have a source right now but I remember because we wondered if we should take a test as well. In retrospect (now 40+ years old and still looking very similar) it's hard to understand why we every doubted.
- rootusrootus 6y agoI can believe it. My nephews are identical twins, and not at all identical. They look very similar, of course, and are nearly indistinguishable if they style their hair exactly the same and wear the same clothes, but they have very different personalities. One of them is even gay, but the other is straight. One is outgoing, the other is a quiet introvert, etc. Colloquially the family has always called them mirror image twins, because coincidentally they had some early moles on their face that happened to be on opposite sides from each other, but IIRC the term actually means something else. They are in fact monozygotic.
- danieltillett 6y agoYes they are likely to be mirror twins [0]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin#Semi-identical_twins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin#Semi-identical_twins
- rootusrootus 6y agoWell look at that, I stand corrected. Or, correct to begin with, depending on how you look at it :). I misunderstood another definition of mirror image twins that I had read, but I see now that it does describe pretty accurately the differences between my nephews. Fascinating!
- adolph 6y agoThis podcast with Michael Blastland about his book The Hidden Half touches on the topic of twin differences and how it shows how much more there is to discover and learn. The discussion of ostensibly genetically identical Marmorkreb crawfish is especially interesting. http://www.econtalk.org/michael-blastland-on-the-hidden-half/ http://www.econtalk.org/michael-blastland-on-the-hidden-half...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- abellerose 6y agoThe article mentions, nature versus nurture debate and that's complete nonsense. Any scientist should know by now, all forces factor into an equation for whatever outcome. So the phrase "nature versus nurture debate" is annoying to read and I assume it generally confuses the public. Similar to how doctors used to say someone has a chemical imbalance in their brain for the cause of whatever illness the person is suffering from. I feel like until people understand "cause & effect" an ignorance is going to continue existing and that really misleads the general populace towards incorrect assumptions or even magical thinking.
- nabla9 6y agoYou can see this in studies that try to determine how much some traits are inherited . Complex traits usually converge towards 50/50 because that's what you expect when the question is framed wrong. Different genes activate based on input from the environment.
- runarberg 6y ago> Different genes activate based on input from the environment. Precisely. Traits feed back and feed forward, etc. You cannot simply say 30% genes and 70% environment because you cannot ignore how they interact with each other.
- Geee 6y agoIsn't cell division more or less a random process? So even if the genetic code is similar, it can result in different cell patterns. I.e the process from DNA to cells isn't fully deterministic. For example, if you plant identical trees, will they grow their branches identically, even in a very strictly controlled environment? I guess not.
- kyberias 6y agoNo-one has claimed that identical twins have the exact same configuration of cells.
- copperwater69 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin#Types_and_zygosity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin#Types_and_zygosity Piqued my interest. Didn't realise there were so many types of twins. Superfetation just seems incredible to me. I'm just thinking of the perfect combination to produce the maximum amount of offspring for a woman. A quick google says the greatest officially recorded number of children born to one mother is 69, to the wife of Feodor Vassilyev (b. 1707–c.1782), a peasant from Shuya, Russia. In 27 confinements she gave birth to 16 pairs of twins, seven sets of triplets and four sets of quadruplets. If we involved superfetation in Feodor's nameless wife we could trivially improve the output by a huge amount.
- anonytrary 6y agoI grew up with two identical twins from elementary school onwards, and it was always super easy to tell the difference. They were completely different people to me (and had really different personalities, which might have helped). In high school, another pair of twins arrived from one of the other middle schools, and I was never able to tell the difference between them, even after 4 years. Why is that? I would guess is has to do with exposure and knowing them from an early age. It's weird how that works, but I imagine parents of identical twins can very easily tell the difference, so there must be some major difference. Recently, I met another pair of twins and I couldn't tell the difference between them either. It must be extremely nuanced and only obvious to people who have been around both twins for a while. I would guess that it would be easier as twins get older and diverge in physical ways (body fat, muscles, and other physical traits).
- kflzufkrbzi 6y agoIn my anecdotal experience it became harder as my twin friends grew older. They were not identical twins but many people said they look similar even though I never had an issue in recognizing them. After I returned from a one year trip abroad I met up with one of the twins. I knew which one I was meeting, but when I get into their car I was confused why the other twin was picking me up. It took me a solid minute of talking with him before I realized it actually was the twin I was supposed to meet up with. I now recognize them better again but still occasionally have a splitsecond of confusion. Their facial features, silhuetes and fashion has grown to be very similar.
- scruple 6y agoMy best friends growing up were identical twins. They both went to the same university. They both got the same degrees. Both PhDs. They both practice psychology in the same major metro. They both married men with the same _ultra specific_ backgrounds. That's where my knowledge of them ends, I haven't spoken to either of them in a few years -- I should reach out. I have fraternal twins. They are not at all that similar! Not in looks, or size, or hair color, or personality. They're only ~2 years old and the differences between them, both physically and mentally, is so staggering, already. Life is so fascinating!
- scotty79 6y agoI've read about retrotransposons lately. Completely insane mechanism that alters DNA of our cells in their lifetime in useless and dangerous way just because for DNA/RNA sequence to survive and spread it's sufficient that is figured out how to copy itself. My another recent interesting read: viroids.
- bencollier49 6y agoI have young identical twin sons. I discussed this with them, then pointed out that five mutations in a genome of 3 billion base pairs wasn't massively significant..
- knolax 6y agoI never understood why people act like the expression of DNA is a deterministic system unaffected by external inputs, as if it were just some code being compiled. It's obviously a hugely complex emergent process that can be affected by environment and even just random chance.
- monoclechris 6y agoThis online activist magazine is well known for publishing false information, this particular opinion piece should be read with skepticism.