3 ms·
Sure, if China wants to ban say, Safari, they can do that. Seems like a very bad idea to me, but it's their country and they can choose policy. I think Winnie
by tialaramex 6y ago
Sure, if China wants to ban say, Safari, they can do that.
Seems like a very bad idea to me, but it's their country and they can choose policy. I think Winnie the Pooh is smarter than Trump and won't just throw a tantrum because he didn't get his way, but it's certainly possible he'd decide to turn every iPhone in China into a brick rather than accept that we don't want to keep telling eavesdroppers which server name you wrote in the URL.
The GREASE isn't there primarily because of China, as I said they don't build crazy fragile technology, they don't have anybody to sell this too, the Great Firewall is an in-house project, so it's mostly simple and robust. Bad destination IP, connection blocked. Rarely a big problem in a technical sense.
GREASE is because of stupid corporate middleboxes. Middleboxes are a technical problem, because even when they have an apparently mundane and legitimate purpose they tend to go about it in stupid over-complicated ways that destroy forward compatibility. All of the weird spelling of TLS 1.3 is because of middleboxes. Why is HelloRetryRequest spelled ServerHello? Because if you don't say ServerHello at that point some famous middleboxes explode. Why is TLS 1.3 ClientHello written exactly like a TLS 1.2 ClientHello (including the version number) except with crazy extension values? Because otherwise middleboxes explode. Why is there a bunch of completely random data labelled "Session ID"? Is it a session ID? Nope. If that was missing, you guessed it, middleboxes explode.