3 ms·
This is 100% on the medical device manufacturer.. Who designs a medical device that doesn't authenticate commands?!? The command to suspend operation should
by londons_explore 6y ago
This is 100% on the medical device manufacturer..
Who designs a medical device that doesn't authenticate commands?!? The command to suspend operation should come from a practicioners terminal, directed at the patients device, and have mutual authentication. It should not be a reed switch and magnet.
- perryizgr8 6y agoThey needed to have a quick, cheap, simple, easy way to let any doctor reset the pacemaker to a known-good state. I can totally understand why they went for this. Apple should have done basic testing before releasing this in the wild with plans to sell hundreds of millions of these devices. At that large scale, you must consider all kinds of users. And pacemaker usage is relatively quite common nowadays. I'd be surprised if nobody directly involved in magsafe development had a pacemaker installed.
- Perenti 6y agoAn ICD is a bit more drastic than a pacemaker. They do have a pacemaker-like mode, called overpacing that tries to slow down tachycardia, but their main function is delivering shocks to reset life-threatening arrythmias or to defibrillate in the case of ventricular or atrial fibrilation. ICDs are also much larger than pacemakers, as they have to have much larger batteries and capacitors.
- detaro 6y agoSo you are certain that the higher chance that medical personnel isn't carrying the proper terminal with the proper keys is not an issue in comparison?
- Perenti 6y agoIf the device is malfunctioning due to say a break in a ventricular lead, patients can be shocked every 40 seconds as the ICD tries to restart the heart. So the magnet switch allows fast and easy deactivation without knowing keys. Remote adjustment and monitoring over wi-fi does require two-way keys, which is a good thing. Note I have an ICD for Brugada Syndrome. Come the robot rebellion I'm already on their side as a cyborg!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]