3 ms·
> Basically, by fighting data caps, you're demanding that a grandma who only checks their email once a day has to pay as much as a family of four who streams Ne
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Basically, by fighting data caps, you're demanding that a grandma who only checks their email once a day has to pay as much as a family of four who streams Netflix in 4K every waking hour of the day.
And there is a reason for that -- it costs about the same to provide that service.
Nearly the entire cost of operating an ISP is getting the wires on the pole, keeping them there against weather and drunk drivers, answering customer support phones, paying for staff and buildings and electricity etc. None of which costs any less for the person who uses 1/1000th as much data.
Charging the amount actually attributable to additional data usage would cause the difference to be so small that basically everybody would just pick the unlimited plan so they don't have to worry about it. But they don't charge the actual cost, they charge more. Because the point is to suppress usage of Netflix et al (the main reason nearly anyone would exceed the cap) in favor of cable TV and zero-rated partners.
- asplake 6y agoUntil that infrastructure no longer handles the demand and they have to build out again. So no, bandwidth isn’t free
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThere is no "build out again" -- they use the same wires, which was the expensive part. They just replace the cards in the box. The upgrade itself is a tiny fraction of their costs. It's also something you benefit from regardless of how much data you use, because when they go from DOCSIS 2.0 to DOCSIS 3.0 you get 1000Mbps downloads instead of 40Mbps whether you're downloading 40GB or 40TB.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago> There is no "build out again" -- they use the same wires, which was the expensive part Who told you that? ISPs run new fiber all the time.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe bandwidth of fiber is astronomical. Once you have it somewhere, that's pretty much it. They'll install it in places where it isn't, but that's a one-time cost, not a recurring upgrade cost. Amortized over the "indefinitely" that it will then be sufficient for, it's still negligible.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago> The bandwidth of fiber is astronomical. The bandwidth of a multi mode line is high. The bandwidth of the modems, switches, routers and data centers is much more finite. You don’t really seem to understand the concurrency of transmissions, redundancy, and how much copper there still is. ISPs are adding fiber all the time.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The bandwidth of the modems, switches, routers and data centers is much more finite. Those are all the things they can upgrade without expensively replacing the wire on the pole. The dominant cost of an ISP is not replacing their switches every five years. That often saves them money when newer equipment uses less power per unit data. And is typically necessary regardless because the older equipment falls out of support.