3 ms·
Just a friendly reminder that nuclear power causes fewer deaths per terawatt hour than any other energy source known to man.
by arcticbull 6y ago
Just a friendly reminder that nuclear power causes fewer deaths per terawatt hour than any other energy source known to man.
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago...as long as you completely ignore any catastrophic risk for the next 10.000 years.
- arcticbull 6y agoNothing is risk free. The nice thing about nuclear power is that radiation is really easy to detect, with you know, a Geiger counter. On the other hand, particulate matter emitted by oil and coal plants causes millions of deaths per year, right now. And CO2 emissions from oil, gas and natural gas are bringing us to the brink of an environmental catastrophe.
- airtonix 6y agoOMG YOU HEATHEAN! How dare you! The church of climate catastrophe will seek an injuction on your slanderous lies! /s
- bob29 6y agoDetecting radiation isn't the hard (or expensive) part https://www.tri-cityherald.com/news/local/hanford/article225386510.html https://www.tri-cityherald.com/news/local/hanford/article225... Its not nuclear vs oil and gas. Renewables are an alternative with lower cost and lower waste. A good safety history is a measure of what happened, not what could happen.
- posix_me_less 6y agoNuclear energy has exceptionally good safety history.
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> Nothing is risk free. I specifically called out SYSTEMIC risk. What's the systemic risk of solar panels and wind power, for example? A terrorist attack destroying 100 millions solar panels? > On the other hand The usual false dichotomy between nuclear and oil/coal/gas. > And CO2 emissions from oil, gas and natural gas are bringing us to the brink of an environmental catastrophe. ...not to mention the direct release of heat into the atmosphere due to poorly isolated house heating, industrial production and electric generation plants themselves. None of which is mitigated by nuclear. Rather, it's made even worse by any source of cheap electricity.
- posix_me_less 6y agoNuclear power plants are designed to withstand attacks from crazies. Terrorist attacks done so far have had minimal impact on infrastructure. It is a very minor and manageable threat. Release of heat due to chemical and nuclear sources does heat the planet, but the contribution to heating compared to effect of increasing CO2 concentration is negligible in the range of 1%, this is well known.
- scaladev 6y agoDo you want a bit of perspective from someone who's been living under a very thick pall of coal-produced smog for many years? 100-500 µg/m³ of PM2.5 at day time (depends on wind speed mostly, right now it's 550 µg), twice or thrice that at night. I don't think my body can tolerate this much longer. If we were to switch the coal power plants to nuclear energy, I'd jump up and down like a little girl. A small risk of second Chernobyl seems just fine in comparison to this. I'd be fine with a risk of nuclear explosion with no chance to escape, honestly.
- oddmiral 6y agoWe cannot switch coal plants to nuclear. We can switch them to gas or hydro. > A small risk of second Chernobyl seems just fine in comparison to this. I'd be fine with a risk of nuclear explosion with no chance to escape, honestly. Chornobyl was near-miss. Potentially, it was able to turn whole Europe into radioactive wasteland, affecting lives of 1B of people. Can you just kill yourself only, please?
- rob74 6y agoSorry for that, but may I ask where you live? Because if the pollution is coming from a coal power plant, there are filters for that. And I shudder to think what the people (mis)managing that coal power plant could do if it was nuclear instead...
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> Do you want a bit of perspective Thanks but I don't need a strawman.
- mixermachine 6y agoHow about switching to renewables + batteries? Solar is now as cheap as coal power in China. When you add some batteries you will be fine with no pollution. And no waste your childerns childern (and beyond) have to take care of.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt's not actually true that batteries and solar are a perfect clean solution - and neither is wind. Better than coal to be sure, but it's not what you're making it out to be. Rare earth metals have to be mined in remote portions of China in dystopian hellscapes. Lithium and other minerals also have to be mined, and leave toxic tailing ponds. Solar panels frequently have cadmium and tellurium, which are also hazardous, and need to be managed. Plastics and composites in wind turbines also cannot be recycled. There are no perfect solutions, and the future will almost certainly require a mixture of kinds of energy.
- redis_mlc 6y agoJust a friendly reminder that nuclear power has an unbounded cost of dismantling, which will be borne by the local taxpayers. Which is one of the reasons we keep extending the operating certificates, to kick that can down the road.
- oddmiral 6y agoWe will know that after cooling of nuclear waste to background level only, which will not happen soon.
- posix_me_less 6y agoNuclear waste is safely stored in pools and other facilities, it does not hurt anybody.
- Chris2048 6y agoif you bury it in the same place you dug the uranium ore from, doesn't that resolve it?
- lovemenot 6y agoA friendly rejoinder. Concorde was the safest form of commercial air-travel, until one day in Paris it wasn't. Nuclear currently has around 3% share of power generation globally. More share than Concorde had, certainly. But not enough to say definitively that nuclear's comparative safety is not just because of its comparative scarcity. It's been a low-hanging fruit. Scale up to 30% share and be necessarily exposed to new risks which were not exposed at current levels of deployment. Many of these additional risks would be from economic factors: we'd probably never achieve 30% share without a less rigorous and much less costly safety regime.
- arcticbull 6y ago30% is a completely arbitrary level that you’ve picked with no justification. I’d suggest you cite some sources to provide depth to the argument that 30% of world power is materially different.
- lovemenot 6y agoArbitrary yes. Pick another number that is substantially larger than current share. I am not going to be able to give statistics, but to me it's obvious. After all these decades, what's been holding nuclear down to its present market share is its economics of safety. Cost overruns all but bankrupted Toshiba, just to give one recent example. If you want an order of magnitude more installations, you will have to relax those constraints. So we cannot use today's safety record as proof of tomorrow's safety if we also expect massive increase in deployment.
- jaakl 6y agoWhich day in Paris? Single accident did not increase overall air travel safety significantly, regardless of what impression you could get from the press.
- lovemenot 6y agoA single Concorde crash drove that aircraft's safety profile down from the very best to amongst the worst per passenger mile of any aircraft.